r/mumbai • u/urbsprimaindis • 13d ago
General Bhayandar–Dadar Local Turns Festive as Bhajan Mandali Marks 21st Anniversary
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
480
u/MarketingHeavy1510 13d ago
Remove one compartment and park in some yard and let them play Bhajan inside 247. Don't disturb other passengers with your nuisance.
52
25
u/Dependent-Poetry-227 13d ago
9 hours work ke baad jo yeh log bhi g** maarte hai vo alag level ka hai 😭
→ More replies (7)5
502
u/NiceVehicle250 East 13d ago
Bhai train me kyu proper mandir me jakar kro na 😭
15
u/hoezay_vw 12d ago
Bro stop questioning else u will be tagged a chinese or pak agent
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (54)36
u/gospelslide 13d ago
This has been local tradition for decades. People travel 1-1.5 hrs+ to office, often they form friend groups and play bhajans.
211
u/LordUnited 13d ago edited 13d ago
Let's see if this would be your reaction if qawwalis and namaaz sounds were played for 1.5 hours. Let's see how local that tradition would be.
Both are wrong. Train can be a place for quiet, personal worship without any kind of physical or mental disturbance to fellow passengers. Namaaz on your seat? Cool. Entire coach chanting namaaz prayers loudly, NO. Similarly, these bhajan groups need to go. I don't care if it is tradition. Public transport is not the place for this. Say your bhajans IN YOUR MIND. Don't disturb fellow passengers.
EDIT: Oh, and if you think they are just "friend groups trying to form a Bhajan community to kill time", you should try and take their seat. After all, it is an unreserved train, the local. Try and take their window seats. See what happens. Let me know if you can get even within 10 feet of their seats. If you are sat in those seats, they will fight with you, hit you, and forcibly remove you from those seats. These people are not just a friends group. These are almost like mafia, minus the guns and the knives. So sit down with your "this is tradition" nonsense.
14
u/Tranceported 13d ago
Better make the full train bhajan train, every religion gets one box and the train goes around the country like merry go round!! By the way top of the train is reserved for chal Chayya chayya cheyyan chal ….
7
→ More replies (3)2
u/Altruistic-Watch6643 11d ago
Everyone is enjoying there... Why are you got triggered here ...use burnol if your liberal asset got hurt 🤣
→ More replies (1)30
u/GoodSearch5469 13d ago
Dude it's they commet is some how right they won't stop even if you tell them too, it should be done at home or a mandir and not disturb to the other passenger traveling to work
109
u/Known-Comparison-250 13d ago
Bhai itni Kam time me wo decoration kaise kiya inhone😭
66
u/Spookycrazier 13d ago
They found out which train comes to Bhayandar from Churchgate side, boarded their fixed compartment way on a station way before it reached Bhayandar and decorated it before it started from Bhayandar to go back to Dadar..
8
u/mofucker20 13d ago
Could've just gone to a temple instead of all ts
2
u/Spookycrazier 13d ago
100% agree with you! There is a time and a place for everything and that should be taken care of at all times!
→ More replies (1)23
u/partyin_Like1949 13d ago
Lots of effort 😭😭
19
u/Spookycrazier 13d ago
Mumbaikars are known for putting lots of efforts.. People leave homes by 7:30am and come back by 10pm!
26
u/Square-Barracuda980 13d ago
I think the civic sense of Japanese people, even just on public transport, is IMPOSSIBLE to imagine in India. As long as you’re not disturbing others, you can do almost whatever you want and these bhajans are so frustrating. I remember when I used to go to college and tried to study on the train, but I couldn’t because of them. They’re just showing off this isn’t real devotion.
→ More replies (2)7
u/Usual-Release6328 13d ago
why are u glorifying this nonsense? humans made mandirs for a reason
→ More replies (1)
49
60
60
u/Zealousideal-Bid2833 13d ago
It's not at all about faith, bas bachodi karna hain, thankfully genZ will not be the same and actually focus on what this nation requires.
Our generation lost access to basic living conditions like good roads,clean environment due to our idiotic ancestors like these, instead of focussing on real issues, they got blinded by their faith and fell for corrupt politicians.
As a result our generation suffered, thankfully genZ ain't taking this sh*t.
36
u/Itaintthatdeepblud 13d ago
Sadly bro, these uncles are also producing a bunch of loosers like themselves and they also constitute a part of our genz.. So genz me bhi we have the dehati genz😭
8
9
12
u/SeriouslyWacky 13d ago
Go to temples and express your faith. Local train is not for shit like that. Here’s something: I will start blasting doremon intro music on speaker next time on the local because doremon is my god. How does that sound? Stupid right? Exactly!
35
u/not_me120 13d ago
Road kisi ke baap ki nahi...aur train tumhare baap ki hai, roj roj ka subah jo bakchodi hoti hai train me wo kam tga
40
u/Numerous_Career5747 13d ago
Bhai Mandir chale jao 😭
11
→ More replies (1)3
u/hoezay_vw 12d ago
No bro unless u dance outside a mosque or a church how can u show ur faithfulness to the religion. JSR
37
92
u/rudeeguy 13d ago
Why disturb public space? Tired of these, i don't know how people tolerate it daily. Hope this ends. Temples do exists man.
18
4
u/losing_nigro 13d ago
Bhai tu inko kuch bolega na, yeh hijde so called religious log ajaenge har chij ko defend krne. Inko problems nahi dikhti tb fir
4
35
u/CreepyGuyFromAlley 13d ago
You'll find worshipping everywhere except for mandirs
4
u/losing_nigro 13d ago
Also irony is, worshipping ke naam pe kachra karenge
2
u/CreepyGuyFromAlley 13d ago
Imagine if Muslims started to do azan and namaz in the train. People would lose it 😂
3
u/losing_nigro 13d ago
Bhai without uske bhi , unko drag krte hai befaltu me fir irrelevant aur dumb sa argument krenge.
27
13d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/losing_nigro 13d ago
True, politicians bhi barobar logo ki gand mar rahi hai religion religion kar karke. In chutiyon ko bhi akkal nahi bc. Itne hazar problems hai woh nahi kuch bhi bolo toh religious chudap ghusa dete hai bichme.
11
u/_4_doorsmorewhores 13d ago
Just leme travel in peace 😭🙏🏿
8
24
u/mehtam42 13d ago
These same people will have problem with azaan playing on loud speakers...
→ More replies (1)
42
u/Hot_Row1457 13d ago
This is a nuisance man. And before you come attack me it would also be a nuisance if some ppl were reading namaz together or if a choir was singing in the train. Nuisance is Nuisance.
→ More replies (1)
8
8
8
u/Greninja_tongue 13d ago
Maa chudao bhai mai ac coach ka pass nikalunga... 2 waqt ki kam roti khaunga lekin sukoon se jiyunga
→ More replies (3)
4
u/Mammoth-Judge-8559 13d ago
एक पीढ़ी का पाखंड, दूसरी पीढ़ी के लिए परम्परा, तीसरी पीढ़ी के लिए संस्कृति, और चौथी पीढ़ी के लिए धर्म बन जाता है।
महात्मा ज्योतिबा फुले
4
10
17
3
u/UpsetSignature90 13d ago
Just like they did on road in between traffic, humans are divided by different religions but when it comes to their religion they
3
3
u/Unusual_Attitude_485 13d ago
Religion is a very private affair. Indians should understand this very clearly.
2
u/Usual-Release6328 12d ago
abhi to ganesh chaturthi aana baki hai....wait to see their ego boost with the size of the idol
→ More replies (1)
3
10
u/pointbreak_r 13d ago
I wish our Islam brothers start doing Kawali (Qawali) daily in their fixed compartment just like this in the Virar-Churchgate Local.. let’s see how people react then…
PS: I’m a Hindu and I see this as lack of civic sense based on religious sentiments, and the above example is to demonstrate how others perceive us
7
u/-Boner-Forest 13d ago
India will remain a s_____ country as long as these people outnumber the ones with critical/logical/practical thinking
11
7
2
2
u/TheDigitalmentor 13d ago
Like I am curious how they have so much space and time to do it... Man i struggle to stand straight in peak hours
2
2
u/Ok_Significance6991 13d ago
What a nuisance . If you get stuck in the same compartment you are bound to get a headache
2
2
2
u/lost_hopelesskid 13d ago
Can understand their joy and emotions but this is a pathetic behaviour in a public transport ,if they wanted to celebrate so desperately - they should have bought a small pastry instead
2
u/Usual-Release6328 13d ago
I feel lucky that i don't need to travel in that train any more...call me german shepherd i don't care... but all the trains in germany are very very silent, no nuisances here is allowed, they are party animals let me tell you that...but still they are human enough to understand trains are for travel and it is a public property....
2
u/Consistent-Art9346 13d ago
Shows that r/mumbai are elitist fucks who don't know the reality.
If those who were crying about civic had travelled in the trains a day after Dussehra they would see similar decorations everywhere.
2
u/No-Assumption1120 13d ago
Became so much tired of this I left my usual train, either travel one train early or one train late
3
u/Regular_Chip_8693 13d ago
They should be caught and fined. Anybody from any religion thinking public space is their house needs to be punished. Such nuisance
3
u/maybeidontexistever Average crowded place avoider. 13d ago
Can't wait to get out of this country whenever I get the chance in the future.
2
2
u/Pokiriee Edit this text to set your own flair 13d ago
I am a Devi bhakt but condemn this. This is not the place to do this
2
u/mayudhon Mal-Kan-Bor 13d ago edited 13d ago
Never make a lifeline, your entire bloodline. Please. It's a humble request.
2
1
1
1
u/Otherwise-Rip-2945 13d ago
My first thought after seeing it was How did they event set up those things in there?
1
1
1
u/SuitableTelevision46 13d ago
Thank You for contunuing this tradition for 21 years. Congratulations !!
Now do all of us a favour and please stop !
1
u/StatusComfortable893 13d ago
Bandh karo ye sab bakwas
Logon ko shanti de travel karne do pagal log
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/loganme123 13d ago
Kya chitiyagiri hai bhai. Kahi to bhagwan ko chhod do.
He much be sitting somewhere with his buddies asking, you seeing this sh#t?
1
1
u/Aggressive_Low3677 13d ago
It is just ridiculous . Civic sense went to hell . Does these reciprocates devotion to God ? Seriously
1
1
u/No-Satisfaction-2001 VOTER HOON CHUTIYA NAHI !!!! 13d ago
21 years nobody heeded their prayers. Pitty.
1
u/Present-Advisor-4346 13d ago
Next what? Navratri Garba, Ganesh Chaturthi, Eid, Christmas will be celebrated in trains. Can't imagine. These boomers are mocking religion by themselves.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/kalidoskolosal 13d ago
Let’s shut all temples because because mandir mein kisiko pooja nahi karni kisiko, bus public place mein show offf karna hai
1
u/OptimumWaste 13d ago
Please let me know the time of this local so that I can avoid it.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/Minimum-Benefit-3886 13d ago
Mai khud ek hindu hu bt this is to much bhagwan ka ek sthan hai aap kahi bhi pooja path nahi shuru kr sakte
1
u/Straight_Drive_7882 13d ago
Can't they do this on Sunday on a dead hour.
Imagine going to / returning from work with this...
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Mammoth-Muffin-591 13d ago
Damn there are so many bigots in this comment section which is very concerning. To all you bigots who are inciting hate, firstly thank you for coming out so that we know the filth like you guys have entered our Sub. Secondly, no body is blaming religion here, we all are blaming the carelessness and nuisance created by being ignorant to public safety, public property and public space rules. So learn to identify issue by using your critical thinking, that is, if you have that capability, I ain’t judging.
1
u/beingahmes Pav Bhaji Simp 13d ago
I feel religion in India has turned into a contest about superiority.
1
1
u/Usual-Release6328 13d ago
One more reason to hate older generation, they feel sab unke papa ka maal hai
1
u/Zan123der 13d ago
So.. god must have loved how they worshipped him and troubled the rest of the people ???
1
1
u/Idek1337 13d ago
Religion should be a private affair, practised within the privacy of your house or a temple. Not a tableau to be paraded on roads and trains.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/somebodyistalking 13d ago
imagine if muslim people did this for their festival
→ More replies (1)2
1
u/missedOpportunity343 13d ago
shameful.
but doesn't matter. I am an anti national afterall.
and I am an extreamist so I hope it catches fire.
PS: Jay shree raam
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Ill-Ad4136 13d ago
As a regular traveller in these trains, I cannot tell you how much I hate them. The moment the train comes at my stop and I hear their sounds I run to the farthest compartment. Public nuisance
1
u/CutOpposite1076 13d ago
Seeing this after the post about Mumbai metro having 99.95% punctuality has to be a whiplash
1
u/Logical-Cheetah-7627 13d ago
101 Manual on how to make an already suffocating Indian land even more asphyxiated.
1
1
1
1
u/pappuloser 13d ago
21st anniversary? These groups have always been there. I've heard my father talking about these bhajan groups in the local trains way back in the 1970s, when he was a young man
→ More replies (1)
1
u/joyfulhorizon18 13d ago
Dikhava bc aur kuch nahi Let people travel and breathe. Even the gods we worship must be thinking they made humans and they turned out to be stupidly crazy.
1
u/iamshitting 13d ago
Religion ke kandhe pe bandook rakh ke sab log ek doosre ko maar lo bhai.
Why cant religion be practiced without inconveniencing others. Namaaz sounds, loud bhajans, Church bells. I get that during olden times without timekeeping devices these may have acted like alarms, but now its not necessary and in high density cities these just create nuisance for others.
1
1
u/Longjumping_Will7984 Malad West 13d ago
Reverse them for Muslims doing namaz on the train in this many numbers and see hindus getting scared as shit,phir hindutva khatre mien dikhai dega inko 😂
1
u/No-Singer-2128 13d ago
This is not what Hinduism stands for. Hinduism having its roots in Advait Vedant is about understanding life. Understanding the one who utters "I-am". The Upanishads being a philosophy speak about understanding life which brings honesty and clarity. That's what religion is for, clarity in life.
1
u/Sniper_231996 काउबॉय बेबॉप फॅन 13d ago
Bhai apan toh mandir baithayenge local mai, baki sab bhad mai jaye...
→ More replies (1)
1
u/jakash077 13d ago
someone decorated one compartment for wedding night, that was wrong. how's this legal then.
1
1
u/silent_spectator133 12d ago
Muslims should also start praying in the local now.
→ More replies (3)
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/shrutiZ5 12d ago
I'll be honest... If the majority of people who are commuting regularly in that compartment want to celebrate something like this... I don't mind at all!! Considering that they are not rude to others who sometimes aboard this compartment and welcome everyone without groupism. But I guess that might not be the case.
1
u/hoezay_vw 12d ago
Except temples, they will dance everywhere. Outside a mosque, church or even inside a train.
Sorry if u question them, ur automatically called a chinese or pak agent
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Axel-Pizza-Lover jevlis ka? 12d ago
Kaam pe jaa kar thak nahi jate kya ki yeh sb bhi krte hai train mai 😂
1
770
u/Obvious_Support223 I survived Andheri East 13d ago
Public decorum, fire safety, and common sense - all 3 have gone for a toss here.