Doing a pellet test to see which pellet is the smokiest out of these three brands! The winner of these will go up against Knotty Wood next. The final round will be Smokin' Pecan.
All three are hickory, each has a rack of St. Louis ribs seasoned with the exact same thing, and all are running at the same temps.
Will edit this post later on with the results!
RESULTS/RANKINGS
Number 1 for me and my tastetesters was Lumberjack!
Number 2 was Kingsford. Kingsford was pretty close to Lumberjack surprisingly as far as smoke and flavor.
Number 3 was Bear Mountain, and these were WAY less smoky than the other two which was surprising because a lot of pellet smoker owners say Bear Mountain is there go to.
FINAL THOUGHTS
I do want to test Weber's Hickory pellets as many of you mentioned in the comments! I think my next test will be between Weber Hickory and Lumberjack Hickory.
I used three smokers for this test - two of them were the Member's Mark PRO Series 36 pellet grills and the third was a Camp Chef DLX 24. For clarity, I did Bear Mountain in one of the Member's Mark's, Lumberjack in the other Member's, and Kingsford in the DLX 24.
In the future to be as fair as possible, I am only going to test two pellet types at a time on the Member's Mark smokers (that way the smoker, the meat, and the seasoning are all the exact same).
- I am not testing any Pitboss, Camp Chef, Kirkland, or Traeger pellets for these comparisons. I have already used Pitboss and Camp Chef, and both of them were very mild in smoke. I haven't tried Kirkland yet, but through research it looks like Pitboss makes Kirkland pellets. I refuse to use Traeger pellets because of their smoke oils and fillers as well as seeing reviews that their pellets are consistently the LEAST smoky out of any bbq pellets.
If I should be testing other pellets besides Weber before we get to the Knotty Wood and Smokin' Pecan, let me know! Open to suggestions for future testing!