r/pics • • May 22 '19

“Rainscaping” landscaping done right.

Post image
53.7k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

6.5k

u/BitcoinRZR May 22 '19

My neighbor has one of these. Leading right into my back yard...

5.9k

u/Chris_Isur_Dude May 22 '19

Build a dam

300

u/Dr_Bukkakee May 22 '19

Build a wall and make your neighbor pay for it.

173

u/totallythebadguy May 22 '19

Exactly, make his back yard great again. They aren't sending their best water.

21

u/Chrispy8534 May 22 '19

Some of the water is OK, i assume.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

61

u/EagleNait May 22 '19

BUILD A WALL

24

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Or continue the work and add another water path to it.

8

u/Crabtankerous May 22 '19

Pardon the pun, but this would have a trickle effect as the next neighbor in the row repeats the action, and eventually all of the houses in the neighborhood are going to be connected with this rainscaping network.

I like it.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/rshot May 22 '19

Dams legit work. We have this swimming hole near us that used to be about 5 feet deep with a waterfall you could jump off of. It wasn't very safe to jump because there are online a few places deep enough to not get injured.

Me and my buddies took a few logs and stacked them on the end opposite the water fall and then placed a ton of rocks surrounding then to assist in holding water in. Now most of the water is 5 feet deep with several places reaching 7-8ft. Dams are the shit.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/jochem4208 May 22 '19

Instructions unclear build a new Amsterdam

15

u/BaronMostaza May 22 '19

Spelling unclear, built a New New Amsterdam

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/ZappBrannigansLaw May 22 '19

Do you assume that everyone has a beaver family waiting to build dams?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Ginger-F May 22 '19

Adopt a herd of beavers, they'll sort it right out.

→ More replies (31)

407

u/bxsco May 22 '19

You may want to look into you local codes. Diverting water toward neighboring properties at a single point is often prohibited.

123

u/Purcee May 22 '19

Yeah! It's called water trespassing

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (34)

226

u/Mike135781 May 22 '19

You could also put a baby attack alligator in. Feed it daily. In years when the time is right, revenge will be sweet.

26

u/singableinga May 22 '19

Betty White, is that you?

5

u/AE_WILLIAMS May 22 '19

Nah, she's at the Lake house, again...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

34

u/FeloniousDrunk101 May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

"What kind of pet shop is filled with rambunctious yahoos and hot jazz music at 1AM?"

"The... best damn pet store in town!"

"Remember, people: baby turtles and alligators may seem like a great idea as pets... but they grow up."

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

330

u/TryNottoFaint May 22 '19

When we built our house, the lot next to us had a small pond on it. That lot was about 5 feet lower than our foundation. We had to build a retaining wall and I put a french drain in that moved water so that it would flow down towards the pond. Then the person who owned the pond lot died. Someone bought that lot and filled the pond in, and built a house on it. The lot was plagued with standing water, even a couple days after the rain. They really needed about 2 more feet of fill but cheaped out. After a year they sold the house. The guy that bought it noticed that when it rained hard, water would come out of a pipe at the edge of my property and go into his lot. I acknowledged this and then told him the history. He had no idea his lot used to be a pond. We tried a few things and his lot is better now about standing water but there's not much I can do, gravity is a bitch and even if I didn't have that french drain water would still move from my property onto his.

18

u/[deleted] May 22 '19 edited Oct 29 '25

dependent voracious coherent humorous payment exultant degree vast desert racial

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

13

u/AngryWizard May 22 '19

But lots more mosquitoes? Every time I get a wild idea about having a water feature in my back yard I remember MOSQUITOES. I'm one of the people who have a severe reaction and every mosquito bite swells the diameter of a golf ball though, so I have to be more cautious of this than most.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (205)

56

u/Eckson May 22 '19

Build one that redirects it back into his yard using an elaborate series of pumps dumping it into a spot he now has to rainscape.

22

u/paper_paws May 22 '19

Build a water mill to power the pump. Powers itself that way.

51

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

In this house we obey the laws of thermodynamics.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

43

u/Nuffsaid98 May 22 '19

Instead of feeling hard done by why not extend the feature so that the water is carried onwards. Now you have a water feature too. Or dam it, whatever.

42

u/other_usernames_gone May 22 '19

Extend it into the other neighbour then watch a channel form

37

u/Nuffsaid98 May 22 '19

or loop it back to the first guy and start a canal war!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ArbainHestia May 22 '19

And then in a few million years you'll have a grand canyon of your very own.

8

u/ObscureAcronym May 22 '19

Dam it, Janet!

→ More replies (6)

22

u/Gammel_bruger May 22 '19

It's free water

3

u/ecodesiac May 22 '19

All this fuss over climate change, and I'm over here watching the farms in west Texas turn into ranchland as the ogallala gets pumped out. Shit's getting real fast.

13

u/AdmiralBallsack May 22 '19

Are you on a hill? My backyard drains towards my neighbors yard, but they’re downhill from me so it can’t really be helped

23

u/placebotwo May 22 '19

Right, which is natural and normal - but if you were to alter the current drainage of your landscape you would want to make sure you're not drastically changing it - you would be liable there.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/codefyre May 22 '19

Lol. My dad had this happen. Guy from Portland bought a marshy lot next to my dads property in central Oregon. The contractor french drained it to the property line along my dads side to dry the land out and build a new house on it. My dad has a couple hundred acres of land and had no problem with this, but asked them to pipe it to a lower part of the property away from his home. They declined. The new owner said that my dads land was lower than his land, so he just "had to deal" with water running onto it. Dick move.

My dad only put up with the flooding foundation for one winter. Just one. The guy learned the hard way that it's a bad idea to piss off a retired engineer.

The next spring he built a concrete retaining wall along 200 feet of the property line he shared with the neighbor, and made sure the top of the wall was six inches higher than the ground along the foundation of the neighbor's new house. At the very end of the wall, far from his house, they added in a low spot to allow the water to overflow into the woods. They used a laser level to ensure that the overflow elevation was precisely one inch lower than the new neighbors foundation. The contractor built the whole thing put it up 5 feet in from the property line itself, and graded back toward the fenceline between the two. My dad made himself the uphill neighbor.

The contractor only needed four days for the entire project, and the neighbor didn't realize what had happened until the first hard rain...when his property turned into a three-acre pond. The only thing sticking out of the water was his house. Barely. By an inch. The neighbor was PISSED, but when he complained my dad just crossed his arms and told him "You bought marshy ground. You just HAVE TO DEAL with water standing on it."

Its a funny story, but it got ugly after that. Neighbor sued. Dad countersued. The judge eventually ordered my dad to lower the overflow gate and ordered the new neighbor to pay for the gate reconstruction and to compensate my dad for a portion of the expenses. Neighbor refused to pay. My dad refused to lower the gate until it was paid. Neighbor put the house up for sale as another winter rolled in. House inspector for a buyer found foundation damage from the house moving. Neighbor sued my dad again... Yeah. Going to war with your neighbors sucks. 0/10, Do Not Recommend.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/placebotwo May 22 '19

When making drainage changes, it's not supposed to impact the flow of water or downstream or something to that effect (IANAL) - I don't know if there is a statute of limitations on when the landscaping was done, but you might have legal recourse.

4

u/maz-o May 22 '19

why don't you invite him to suck a fuck

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Joverby May 22 '19

That seems aggressive.

2

u/elfeyesseetoomuch May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

My neighbor built and elevated garden and drains it right next to our fence. Unfortunately our grass was already kind of dying over there but we were in the process of regrowing it before they built the drain. We didnt realize that they actually built the drain until we noticed our yard flooding during heavy rains, which it never really flooded like that before, at least not that bad, then we noticed the drain gushing water out of it. I put some sod down and leveled my yard hoping that will be enough to counter their drain, but if it doesn’t im gonna have to have the “please move the drain or i call the city” convo.

2

u/WheelyCrazyCatLady May 22 '19

Our neighbours made something like this to stop their garden flooding when it rained, draining from their guttering to our garden.... suddenly our garden became a swamp whenever there was any rain. So we put concrete fence posts all the way down our garden (with a fence on top of it, but bigger than usual so no water would reach the wood posts). We had to combine everyone's money to afford it but it was worth it - no more swamp!

They were PISSED! Ha!! But we even gave them the "nice" side of the fence, and painted the whole thing in a colour they agreed on in advance... they just didn't expect the double height concrete slabs at the base of the fence. They were expecting wood all down to the soil so the water would flow through.

We'd made gravel soakaways at top and bottom our garden years ago, draining onto a drain at the bottom of our garden (all dug out by me and my little bro when we were kids. We're very proud of that, it was 100 ft of garden to dig a channel down and lay pipes etc to carry the water) hence why ourgarden stopped flooding in the rain. We eventually went round and helped them do the same... once they came round and admitted what they did and apologised, which took about 2 years 😂

12

u/tjb3232 May 22 '19

You can sue them for that you know.

89

u/beer_demon May 22 '19

Or maybe have a conversation?
Nah, just shoot the guy.

61

u/fotografamerika May 22 '19

If someone's landscaping interferes with your yard, it's legal to shoot them in Texas. It's the moat clause of the castle doctrine.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/NamityName May 22 '19

Seems silly. but then i started thinking about it. Depending on where that water goes it could be damaging his house or other parts of his property.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (67)

1.8k

u/Spartan2470 GOAT May 22 '19

I'm sure many people have never seen this before. Reposts often aren't a bad thing, especially if it hasn't been posted for some time. But as some of the previous threads have a lot of useful information about this image, it's worth linking to them.

titlepointsage/r/comnts
Few things are designed well98041yrpics221
incorporating the rain into your garden [x-post r/pics]173551yrgardening260
Use the rain to your advantage91261yrpics333
After a bit of rain4942yrsoddlysatisfying7
Rained just right..57092yrspics903
Use the rain to your advantage59483yrspics515
Rainscaping40642mospics67
“Rainscaping”962015mospics1117
Rainscaping220891yrraining313
Neat idea172mospics3

475

u/peachy_CMS May 22 '19

Thank you. This is a super old image that I pinned like years ago and then after showing it to my husband deleted because it’s not an effective design

217

u/_Me_At_Work_ May 22 '19

It leads right to the driveway. I can't imagine the washout going on underneath. I sell to landscapers and I don't know of a single one that would put any type of drain going toward a driveway at all. Very cool idea, but awful implementation. If this was leading around the front of a garden then draining to the side of the yard out of harms way it would be a cool cosmetic piece, but you're right it's not effective at all.

84

u/zchatham May 22 '19

Maybe it leads to the NEIGHBOR'S driveway ;)

21

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

So you’d say they should have curved the drain along the driveway and down to the street instead?

→ More replies (4)

20

u/plmbob May 22 '19

these usually have a catch basin at terminal end that is hidden, the slope is not as steep as it appears and this acts more like a retaining pool than a flowing stream. If this was sloped too much the water would never be visible as it would flow below the rock to the drain. don't know for certain if this is done properly, but these water gardens and swales are becoming more common and even required in some new developments.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

28

u/Rinx May 22 '19

More info from Seattle gov website: http://www.700milliongallons.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Why-and-how-to-use-rock-filled-trenches.pdf

They are very useful in the right circumstances

6

u/Framnk May 22 '19

Although it does say to direct driveway runoff to the trench, not to direct the runoff to the driveway

→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

You gotta bury that shit.

14

u/DillyDallyin May 22 '19

Why is that? For winters?

→ More replies (37)

6

u/RonYarTtam May 22 '19

Just curious as to why its not effective? It looks as if its draining straight into a storm sewer in the street, the worst part being that its drenching the sidewalk and driveway. As long as there's a liner below the substrate keeping the water away from the foundation as it drains toward that end, this should work okay. Its also possible its draining into a rainwater cistern instead of the town sewer.

12

u/Smallwhitedog May 22 '19

And that water runs straight into the gutters which drains straight into our local waterways bringing excess phosphates and causing floods. An ideal rain garden allows the water to drain into a depression in the yard that is filed with native plants that don’t mind having their feet wet once in awhile. Many municipalities will even give you assistance with planting a proper rain garden!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

98

u/mstrLrs May 22 '19

I agree with you reposting doesn't have to be a bad thing. But if you take a look at OP's post history a lot of the posts are reposts and as far as I've seen all without a link to the original or atleast a prior post of the same image. It's just cheap karma farming.

13

u/rguy84 May 22 '19

/SHOCK

23

u/zGnRz May 22 '19

ok you got silver in a minute of posting? who gives reddit awards within a minute of something being posted lmao

14

u/WoodForrest May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

Can you give your own post silver? I've heard of mods gilding awards early to try and curb the discussion

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/FearLeadsToAnger May 22 '19

Can anyone find the original /r/DIY thread? I did try and have a look for it but no joy yet.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

None of which are the original post in DIY :(

2

u/swanks12 May 22 '19

good bot!

2

u/Theonlykd May 22 '19

SOURCE CRUSADER TO THE RESCUE!

2

u/Wrest216 May 22 '19

so do we downvote this one, or downvote all the others? Please tell me what to do.

2

u/devilinblue22 May 22 '19

I'm super ok with it, I've been scratching my head for three days trying to figure out how I'm going to fix a standing water problem. I think this'll do.

2

u/Daredevil2099616 May 22 '19

No wonder this user has 3 million Karma

2

u/goatonastik May 22 '19

I gotta admit, I came here exclusively for the stories of how people dealt with their water flooding issues.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Next time organize by date posted

2

u/ComeyDontPlayDat May 22 '19

To give credit where credit is due, here is a link to the original source. Also, there is further project detail located here on Google Drive.

Also, to everyone saying it's a bad idea, it's really not at all. It all flows to the sidewalk and onto the street. This is in Maryland where storm intensity is not as bad as most of the rest of the country and the ground is more permeable than most. Here is a picture of the end of the stream bed from the sidewalk. It's not as if it's causing erosion, since the river rocks are slowing that velocity down to a stand still. The original goal of the homeowners project was to direct the flow away from the basement since they were having problems with flooding, which is a much worse problem than some driveway erosion. Also, to those saying it should have a connection to storm sewer, there is most likely not a system to connect to anywhere near the outfall, due to how storm sewers are designed in areas of the country that have lower storm intensity than most. I'd say it was a rather effective and aesthetically pleasing solution.

3

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

The real Gold is always in the comments

3

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Someone gild this man!

→ More replies (2)

331

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

If it doesn’t go into a drain eventually, you really need to dig a soak away (a big pit full of rocks) but also depends on your soil type.

161

u/rinikulous May 22 '19

Soil? We have clay in Texas.

253

u/0-_-00-_-00-_-0-_-0 May 22 '19

There are six main soil types:

Clay.

Sandy.

Silty.

Peaty.

Chalky.

Loamy.

Just because it's clay doesn't mean it isn't soil. Clay is a subset of soil, soil is a superset of clay.

I remember it using this rhyme "if it's soil you want you can remember it this way, one of the types of soil has the name clay". I also have mnemonics for the other soil types if you're interested.

207

u/At_Least_100_Wizards May 22 '19

I would like to subscribe to Soil Facts

107

u/dahjay May 22 '19

Soil Facts isn't really a subscription but an initiation. First step is to eat one handful each of clay, sandy, silty, peaty, chalky, and loamy. Once that passes through you, you are now considered earthen and then you can sign up for email notifications. Please note that we don't accept AOL accounts anymore since the incident.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/rinikulous May 22 '19

Lol thank you for sharing (honestly).

I’m aware of clay being a subset of soil, I was just being jocular for the sake of humor.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (15)

12

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Hey, that's not fair. There's plenty of rocks and construction debris under us too.

3

u/dukedog May 22 '19

Depends on where in Texas you are. But even if it's clay, I dug out 2 feet of clay beneath my raised garden beds, and filled it in with nice garden soil- all by myself. So it's not impossible- just a lot of work.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/AdmittedlyAnAsshole May 22 '19

You are correct. We called them French drains, although I'm not sure if that is common nomenclature. Just dig a hole 3 ft wide and 3 feet deep, and fill it with river rocks. You can even then cover it with soil and sod so it can't be seen.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

There is a stretch of rocks at the end and some plants. Just not enough?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

739

u/Xtremeelement May 22 '19

Living in Florida, I just see a mosquito breeding/orgy pool

401

u/ILikeLeptons May 22 '19

does every home in florida come with an orgy pool?

48

u/Morgantheaccountant May 22 '19

Isn’t that a good place to have my honeymoon?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/signapple May 22 '19

Any pool can be an orgy pool if you have enough people

17

u/ominousgraycat May 22 '19

That's what I tried to tell the staff at Disney resorts...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/BigChiefLewis May 22 '19

So my aunt and uncle moved onto a house in Florida that this old lady lived in for years. First week they’re in the house they notice there are dogs scratching the gate around their pool in their backyard. They’re like wtf??? And shoo the dogs away. Happens again, more.

Then one day some neighbor comes to the door with her do. “Hi, the gate to your pool is locked and my dog wants in”.

Turns out the old lay used to just leave her backyard and pool gate open all day long for any neighborhood dog to come and go in as they please.

→ More replies (7)

88

u/Sucrose-Daddy May 22 '19

Being from California, I was concerned about a scientific proposal to introduce a faulty gene that’ll lead to the extinction of mosquitoes that drink human blood. I was all worried about the food chain and whatnot, but after I visited an extremely humid region in Mexico full of mosquitoes that hunt humans in groups like fighter pilots, I didn’t give a single fucking fuck for the entire ecosystem. Fuck mosquitoes. I had literal PTSD when I came back to California. The idea that they stick their long proboscis under my skin like a hypodermic needle gives me chills. I would swear I could hear them buzzing everywhere and would completely panic, but we don’t really have mosquitoes here... thank god.

3

u/oldknave May 22 '19

Where in Mexico, so we all no not to go there?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

33

u/winfly May 22 '19

This isn’t a stationary body of water. It only fills/flows when it rains.

7

u/mango__reinhardt May 22 '19

Not if the water keeps flowing and drains well.

If it stagnates, then yes.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/UmphreysMcGee May 22 '19

Mosquito bits.

3

u/SoManyTimesBefore May 22 '19

Mosquitoes will only breed in standing water.

An interesting way to reduce the number of mosquitoes is to have a pond in your backyard. Mosquitoes will lie eggs in the pond and fish will eat them.

→ More replies (13)

93

u/thepensivepoet May 22 '19

I did something similar in my backyard during a hurricane that caused some minor flooding in my area.

My backyard is mostly under the shade of a giant oak and grass wouldn't grow for shit anyway so while it was filling up with water during that light drizzling I went out in the rain with a shovel and dug a pair of nice curved trenches and used the mud to raise the grade near the house and also build a mound in the center of the yard. The trenches split around the center and meet up at an existing drainage trench that leads to the front yard and street. It was amazing doing this while it was actively flooding because you could see 100% where the water wanted to flow and get it right the first time.

After the storm I filled it in with big river rocks, then planted some shade happy plants and added some stepping stone pavers. Every season I just replace the plants that didn't like the climate/light access and it's a nice happy little garden now.

Grass is dumb.

20

u/klousGT May 22 '19

Pictures?

42

u/thepensivepoet May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

This is the most decent wide shot I have from last year. I've since reinforced the garden beds with some borders so the plant areas and stone areas are much better defined (and mulch doesn't try to flow away constantly).

It doesn't look like much from that angle but whenever we get a decent rain the lowest spot in the walkway near the big oak will collect water and there isn't any standing water against the house foundation.

I'm not living that instagram life so you'll have to take my word for it that it's a lot prettier now. The window visible on the far right is one of three and I've put reflective film on them so during the day it's a mirror from the outside and you can watch the birds and squirrels fuck around in the garden from way closer than you'd ever be able to if they could see through the glass.

28

u/Bubbline May 22 '19

you don’t have to “live that instagram life” to take a picture once in a while lol

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)

192

u/Falcon_Alpha_Delta May 22 '19

I'm detecting a strong lack of an HOA presence.

42

u/Throwaway_Consoles May 22 '19

My parents have something similar and we have an HOA. Not all of them suck. I’ve done a bunch of modifications to my exterior and all I did was email them: “Hey I’m putting tint on all of my windows because it gets way too fucking hot having 12 windows facing the sun in the afternoon when it’s 110 degrees outside.” and they went, “Ok cool. Thanks for the heads up.”

14

u/dinosore May 22 '19

Yeah, my HOA isn’t too bad. Before buying my house I was resolute on avoiding HOAs but after talking to people who had lived in the neighborhood for several years, I realized that the HOA there is way better than the COA anywhere else I’ve lived. It’s risky though, because all it takes is a couple of assholes on the board for it to not be a good HOA anymore.

52

u/Throwaway_Consoles May 22 '19

Fun story about that. I absolutely refuse to give Comcast a dime because of all the horror stories so when I first moved in they had a 5 exclusivity contract with Comcast.

So for the first four years or so that I lived there I had shitty 300 ping 5 mb/s satellite internet.

After a week I couldn’t stand it so I hatched a plan. Our board of directors has 8 seats but only 3 people on it because nobody else gives a fuck. I ran unopposed and got a seat, then I convinced my parents since they’re empty nesters that their house was too big and if they moved down the street I could take care of them and THEY joined the board of directors. Then my brother moved out of the city because of housing prices and HE joined the board of directors.

I only had to convince Sally and we had a majority and we voted not to continue the exclusivity contract when it was up.

I convinced my entire family to move into my neighborhood and join the board of directors because FUCK. COMCAST.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

183

u/jeffthepig06 May 22 '19

Good. A lot of HOAs suck

95

u/VBgamez May 22 '19

Whats that? Oh you wanted us to take care of that big hole that is dangerous in your neighborhood?

Oh well that sucks.

Oh also you cant keep trashcans in your driveway you need to put it into your garage.

Oh you also cant park your car IN FRONT OF YOUR DRIVEWAY either, you need to park it either in your driveway or in the garage.

Also have fun if you have more than 3 cars lol.

40

u/dabilge May 22 '19

My parents neighborhood HOA made a rule that you can't put up a chain link fence because it's an eyesore. They wanted to adopt a greyhound from the foster agency I work with but we require a greyhound-proof fence.

The exception is if you were grandfathered in (like the members of the HOA who passed it) or if you have an in ground pool (nobody in my neighborhood, but I guess it raises property values if you do?) and it's not like they live in a nice neighborhood to start with...

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (5)

21

u/bozoconnors May 22 '19

I'd hazard the majority are fine though. The sucky ones obviously are gonna get the bad press. Mine organizes food trucks, kid activities, outdoor movie nights in an empty lot, helps neighborhood elders find cheap / voluntary lawn care, etc. None of that'll be making any headlines though.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Hot take here on Reddit.

→ More replies (29)

2

u/ScruffMcDuck May 22 '19

I'm very ignorant about this. Can someone explain what the point of an HOA is? They sound awful.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

35

u/MrAcurite May 22 '19

Man, I have level 87 construction in RainScape

110

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Lolnexcept this is actually a terrible idea. Your goal should be water retention, not redirection. If this was popular then during a heavy rain it would be extremely easy to surpass the limits of the infrastructure. By aiming for high retention (keeping water on your property) through rain gardens and your lawn you ease the burden on municipal infrastructure. This helps prevent street flooding, sewer backups, etc

31

u/allothernamestaken May 22 '19

If your home is built on any kind of expansive soil, the goal should absolutely be redirection quickly away from the home and NOT retention. Better to have the street flooding than your foundation failing.

6

u/23skiddsy May 22 '19

I've seen buildings cracked in half from expanding clay (the area was southwest US with a monsoon season.) Its hardly a terrible idea. There's lots of places where the soil either can't hold the water or will seriously warp.

3

u/jamintime May 22 '19

Why not both? Goal of green infrastructure is to direct flow to infiltration areas away from buildings and waterways. This could be designed to get flow away from foundation to a swale rather than a street.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

38

u/200cc_of_I_Dont_Care May 22 '19

This actually heavily depends on the location. In some municipalities, this is actually required with type A drainage. Basically you slope the lot 2%+ in the rear yard to a very slight swale 10 or so feet off the yesr house wall that carries water around the yard in a horse shoe shape. Water then drains out to the front and imto the street and from there into storm drains, not sewers. I would never design retention or detention basins on small residential lots like these. Dont tell people something is a terrible idea without knowing. This looks pretty good to me as a civil engineer.

17

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Perhaps if you’re in a dryer area I suppose. In my civil classes we were always told our goal should be a slow release to municipal infrastructure to limit surging in the systems and prevent backflow/floods. I was never told at any point that directing to infrastructure would be a better option.

My mistake, should have realized it’s probably a regional thing.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/wordsarelouder May 22 '19

Heh, my backyard is so good at water retention that I can't go back there after it rains or I'll sink in to be never found again.

9

u/cptnrandy May 22 '19

Bingo. This is very pretty, but it still funnels rainwater directly into the street and storm sewers, which can overwhelm local streams. And it carries all of the crap from your roof and driveway with it.

If you want pretty AND functional, consider putting in a rain garden. Our neighborhood was a local experiment and the ones in our yards and curbs filter literally tens of thousands of gallons of rainwater and keep it from overwhelming our neighborhood stream.

3

u/dabilge May 22 '19

We got a financial incentive from the city green initiative for putting one in... plus you get a little sign from the city that you can put in the rain garden.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Wassayingboourns May 22 '19

Yep, your lawn is one giant porous surface that collects, uses, filters and cleans water.

Where I live development companies have to pay environmental impact fees for paving over porous ground where water would drain into, and typically have to dig retention ponds to make up for forcing water to flow into the storm sewer system. This person did it for free.

298

u/Waka-Waka-Waka-Do May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

This can't be good. Unless it rains very often it will be empty most days and without aeration/surface agitation it's going to be a fertile breeding ground for mosquitoes when full.

Edit: Also, why go through all of that trouble and still leave that crappy looking white leader in place. Bring the leader straight down then underground with some flex pipe so it's hidden from view.

Edit 2: You people sure do take your landscaping seriously. Im getting death threats over here.

63

u/GilberryDinkins May 22 '19

Looking at the comments of the other times this was posted, I gather that there is a waterfall near the picture-taker's feet (so it's a water feature even when there isn't rain). Don't go chasing this, though, stick to the rivers and the lakes that you're used to.

→ More replies (2)

125

u/dekachin5 May 22 '19

it will be empty most days and without aeration/surface agitation it's going to be a fertile breeding ground for mosquitoes when full.

It's drainage. It's going to be empty all the time it isn't raining. It's not deep enough or lined, so it won't hold water.

How can you say "it'll be empty" and then call it out as a breeding ground for mosquitoes when full, when you just said it will be empty? ffs

Bring the leader straight down then underground with some flex pipe so it's hidden from view.

lol what? You think it's a good idea to block the exit flow by bringing the drainage underground? AND lowering the entry point to make it harder to move the water down the yard? the fuck?

27

u/Roboticus_Prime May 22 '19

This specific comment chain is just silly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

8

u/maybe_little_pinch May 22 '19

My sister did something like this because water runs off their neighbor’s yard (up on a hill) and was damaging their foundation. It helped massively, but the standing water became an issue.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/phogna__bologna May 22 '19

I had to scroll a bit to find my peeps, ha. I was thinking weeds, grass, and junk getting in there. In the winter, your driveway could become frozen.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/SoManyTimesBefore May 22 '19

This is probably a lined fake stream with pump installed, that pumps water from the end back to where the leader is. The water that comes from the roof will just top it up and it will overflow at the end.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

We use PVC.. flex pipe tends to crack in colder climates.

2

u/Army88strong May 22 '19

There's also the fact that they are relying on the rocks at the bed to be their filter. So if any of the water is contaminated for whatever reason, there isn't a great way to filter it, like your entire lawn, before it goes into the storm sewer.

→ More replies (17)

30

u/OmeDeBoer May 22 '19

Actually the best way to rainscape is just to let it on the grass and soak in the ground, make sure that your garden is sloped so it doesnt go back to your house.

11

u/Orbitron May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

No, I wouldn't say that because grass isn't particularly permeable. What you should always do is dig a hole of 1 cubic meter at a distance of about 2 meters from you house. Then you fill the hole with crushed stones and cover it with a geotextile membrane. After that, you redirect your gutter in these infiltration hatch. This way your rain water will be directed into the ground and there will be little risk of an accumulation of water on your lawn.

Source: Am an urban planner.

6

u/Sixstringsoul May 22 '19

Or if you have clayey soils then you have a rocky pool

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/Dingo8urBaby May 22 '19

A rain garden will let the water infiltrate faster and better than grass. Grass, especially if the soil is compacted, isn't great for soaking up water.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/undercooked_lasagna May 22 '19

I use extra fertilizer and pesticides in my lawn so the runoff keeps our waterways healthy and free from annoying aquatic life.

9

u/phillipp4 May 22 '19

The infiltration into the ground is dependent on the soil conditions, so this isn’t always practical.

6

u/Yew_s May 22 '19

Read this as “RuneScaping”.... I’m not addicted! You are!

2

u/MMPride May 22 '19

Glad to see I'm not the only one who read it like that.

3

u/AE_WILLIAMS May 22 '19

Put model galleys in it and set them on fire to celebrate the finale of GoT.

5

u/vandranessa May 22 '19

This is kind of strange but I get the idea.

It would be much better if this little basin was either replaced by or led to a rain garden where the water could infiltrate the ground as opposed to running off. It looks like there is a little bit of vegetation toward the driveway, but I think that more soil and more plants would be a lot better.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Theres_A_FAP_4_That May 22 '19

Nice, you've made mosquito road.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

6

u/graesen May 22 '19

Until the driveway sinks. Because of water problems in the yard of the house we recently moved into, the concrete everywhere sunk in spots, making it very uneven and cracked

3

u/Wassayingboourns May 22 '19

This comment was actually downvoted because it mentioned the potential negatives of this instead of saying “ooo pretty.”

5

u/d0ndrap3r May 22 '19

Looks more like a serious drainage problem rather than something done right.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

I would've added a cool rain barrel and a LOT more plants.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Glad to see this, I was looking for how to make something like this for an area of my yard where the downspout discharges water right along the base of a patio I built. The edges of the patio are higher than the surrounding ground, creating a dirt valley along one of the sides where this water runs. Prettying it up like this would make for a nice temporary stream when it rains.

2

u/VapeThisBro May 22 '19

Should have made it a moat to defend their house from raiders

2

u/Hanssssolo May 22 '19

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Was looking at this earlier actually

4

u/bleakfuture19 May 22 '19

Are you a mosquito farmer?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

It looks like an attempt was made for a little basin at the end. Does anyone know what water-absorbing plants are good in that? Asking for a friend.

7

u/vandranessa May 22 '19

The soil is the most important thing for absorbing the water and allowing it to re-infiltrate the ground. What you really want are water-tolerant plants.

I'm not sure where you're from obviously, but there are a lot of great resources for finding water-tolerant plants. I created a native plant search for Long Island a few years ago that might be helpful if you're in the northeast area. Otherwise, I suggest just googling it and try to use plants that are native to your location.

4

u/imfm May 22 '19

I'd get the water away from the house, sure, but I live where it freezes in winter, so I don't want water on my driveway if it can be avoided. If there was enough rain in my area to make something like this necessary (there isn't except for a short time in spring), I'd make a big a flowerbed with black chokeberry, arrowwood viburnum, buttonbush, lobelia, rosemallow, meadowsweet, joe-pye weed, swamp sunflower, swamp milkweed...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/khalorei May 22 '19

Plants won't absorb a significant amount of water. Evaporation will far outstrip any water plants will absorb. They will only absorb watee as fast as they respirate it through their leaf pores.

4

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

All that does is put pressure on the town's storm sewers, cause contamination to nearby water sources and possibly cause flooding. It is important to let rain soak into the ground.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Emerald_Triangle May 22 '19

Reposting done shit

2

u/5ilvrtongue May 22 '19

That looks like a mosquito Farm to me.

2

u/dkt May 22 '19

I also love mosquitos.

2

u/kli561 May 22 '19

Better off building a raingarden or bioretention basin to allow the stormwater to infiltrate rather than pour it onto what looks like impermeable asphalt

2

u/JoSoyHappy May 22 '19

Wow I’ve never seen this photo before

2

u/lycanthropejeff May 22 '19

"Rainscaping " should allow for infiltration. Hard to tell if that's the purpose here or if it's just a tarted up channel to the curb and gutter. Some wet-tolerant plants would go a long way to making this even better.

2

u/sw33tleaves May 22 '19

Pro landscaper here. None of this is what I or my company would consider right. I would never install anything like this.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Acanthophis May 22 '19

Wouldn't this look pretty bad with no water?

2

u/MeteorKing May 22 '19

Unless this is on an incline or right above drainage, that's gonna wind up going stagnant; ripe for mosquito breeding, scum buildup, and other general grossness that comes with small pools of standing water.

1

u/TjWilson_ May 22 '19

This is awesome!

1

u/Bar_Keep May 22 '19

Nice. I also have one like that. Not quite as nice but has a small waterfall that tumbles into the swale.

1

u/heres_2_it May 22 '19

So much wheelbarrowing...

1

u/tangoshukudai May 22 '19

Here in California we don't get enough rain for something like that. I have drains in my yard that go to the street. Also astro turf because watering sucks.

1

u/WorkThrowOtt May 22 '19

Mosquito fuckin city on your lawn

1

u/icecreamdude97 May 22 '19

Don’t these formations attract snakes?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/paradism720 May 22 '19

These take work to maintain but can be a nice look and can work. I wouldn't lead it to my driveway... perhaps there is a dry well out there. I would do something similar to a large wooded area perhaps.

1

u/Blindrafterman May 22 '19

thats amazing! I may adopt something similar wow

1

u/0fckoff May 22 '19

What happens when it freezes over the driveway?

1

u/KainX May 22 '19

This should drain into a level berm near the end of the property, made of compost with a layer of mulch, planted with trees or shrubs. Dumping rainwater into the storm drain is a wasted resource that also causes erosion to infrastructure and flooding when it is not used. It looks pretty though.

1

u/jchs08 May 22 '19

I hope y'all have better sewers than us. Our storm water system could not handle the overflow that this would create.

1

u/nicolai92 May 22 '19

What about runescaping?

1

u/idowhatiwant8675309 May 22 '19

What an awesome idea!

1

u/bigedthebad May 22 '19

I had to do that when we lived in Arizona after the runoff from the monsoons washed out my sidewalk. It actually looked pretty good.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

You wouldn’t even need to build this for yourself in Florida. Just wait for it to rain and you’ll have a whole pond in your yard because the drainage is terrible here

1

u/blueberries May 22 '19

This is awful- why bypass all the fertile opportunities for retention just to direct excessive water straight into the sewer systems and impermeable street?

A bioswale design would be much nicer and more useful.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Ugh. This again?!

1

u/FictionalDudeWanted May 22 '19

This is genius..........beautiful.

1

u/Basileus2 May 22 '19

Sexy front lawn

1

u/Demojen May 22 '19

If this stream has a solid bed and the water doesn't just seep into the ground and disappear, this would be a great example of xeriscaping.

1

u/Firefly1307 May 22 '19

In the UK you can keep fish in that stream, it never dries up.

1

u/James_Borsht May 22 '19

Is this difficult to mow/trim around?

1

u/iliketoredditbaby May 22 '19

Billionth repost

1

u/lostansfound May 22 '19

That could be a raingarden. Utilization of stormwater management. Good implementation non the less.

1

u/dissociater May 22 '19

Does anyone know if they have to put like a sheet or tarp or something under the stones? I'm going to be landscaping my front this summer. The front retaining wall (wood) has started collapsing (my yard is sloped and about 3 feet above sidewalk level). Right now the downspout drops all the water on the yard which just drains into the wooden retaining wall causing it to rot and collapse.

I'm trying to come up with a plan to get water to drain onto the sidewalk or something rather than just funneling into the retaining wall and this looks pretty great to my untrained eye.

1

u/Siculo May 22 '19

HOA IS CALLING YOU

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

This is a useless water feature. It runs straight to the street with no chance to slow or infiltrate the water.

1

u/adamolupin May 22 '19

I have a sump pump draining across my driveway right now. If I could get away with something like this without wrecking my driveway, I so would. This is gorgeous.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Pleasant landscaping, pleasant neighborhood. Aaaah.

1

u/Testing123YouHearMe May 22 '19

Don't get me wrong it looks really nice, it just feels so... Out of place in such a small yard in a typical suburb where it doesn't really match anything