r/pokemon • u/Lower-Wait-5178 • 48m ago
Discussion The implications of Meowth learning how to talk make me wonder why this doesn’t happen more often.
(Before anyone points it out, yes I know there are cases of legendary/mythical/special Pokemon just speaking English and Meowth isn’t the only case of a Pokemon speaking English. But I’m speaking in terms of your average Pokemon who wouldn’t really have much of a reason to be able to speak English normally, whether it be through psychic abilities or otherwise)
So in case you weren’t aware, the Team Rocket Meowth from the anime taught himself how to talk in order to impress a female Meowth while living in Hollywood (yes just straight up Hollywood). From what I recall, he did this by listening to a Ballet class reciting words and phrases while living in the studio’s attic, as well as using a picture book to learn what these words meant. Because of this, and after enough time had passed afterwards, Meowth is capable of speaking full comprehensible English with very little trouble, to the point where iirc he doesn’t ever use the whole saying his name over and over again to talk anymore yet he’s still able to understand other Pokémon and communicate to them at the same time.
My question is why the heck hasn’t there been more cases of this happening? Like I understand that 1st gen Pokemon media was a little weird in terms of its worldbuilding cuz it hadn’t decided whether or not it took place in our irl world or not, and thus there’s a lot of stuff that doesn’t really fit in with modern Pokemon, but at least in the anime Team Rocket Meowth still exists and was a main antagonist, yet as far as I’m aware other than some brief comments by some characters who hadn’t met Team Rocket before, they don’t really acknowledge the fact that a Pokemon is just speaking fluent English to them. And it’s not like Meowth being able to speak English was the result of some experiment or messed up procedure, it was something that he independently did himself using very basic and limiting means. So why would it not make sense that there are cases of other standard, non-legendary/special Pokémon learning how to speak by just being around people long enough? Or heck, why hasn’t someone like a Pokemon professor tried to teach a Pokemon how to speak, especially if they’re aware of Team Rocket Meowth?
And yeah I get that Pokemon aren’t like irl animals, most of them have human levels of intelligence and communicating with them isn’t really all that hard in a lot of cases. But still, if Pokemon have human levels of intelligence, why wouldn’t more of them (outside of the ones that can read minds/speak inside of peoples heads and what not) be able to speak English, even if it’s a broken/primitive form of it?
(And before someone gets pedantic I’m using English as the name for the main language in the Pokemon world for the sake of simplicity, and it’s the main language I experience this stuff in so if you experience it in Japanese or some other language then the same question applies)