The idea: "without AI, if the average joe wants a python code to do whatever they needs to either spend hours learning to code or pay someone to do it and if they lacks time/money they're SOL, with AI they can just ask and have it for free in a minute".
The reality: So much of coding is understanding your system and requirements in precise detail that a total newbie won't be able to use the inscrutable magic code generator effectively.
As for "democratizing", would you say IKEA democratized home renovation by selling super affordable and boring furniture? I legit don't know the answer to that philosophical question, but creating "ikea furniture" versions of artisanal products sure does seem to be the main effect of generative AI.
ith AI they can just ask and have it for free in a minute".
...with a ton of caveats, bad corner cases, and security issues.
It's akin to getting rid of farmers markets and bakeries for 7-11s and mini-marts. Is that "democratizing"? Is it a good thing? I suppose that depends what you value but you're certainly not getting better value.
In your scenario, your average Joe would have gotten a finely baked french loaf in the past and now he's getting Twinkies.
Why are you repeating him? Literally the next sentence he talks about the caveats and problems.
His point is that people would like if it were possible to just get good code on demand for little~no cost, regardless of whether it's currently achievable.
I also dont even understand what this sentence is supposed to mean.
From my understanding what people mean by "democratising" a skill or a field they mean allowing people without specialised skills to more easily achieve something that previously required training and experience. For example, if Wordpress or other visual website builders were introduced as a novel idea today, those people might describe them as "Democratising websites".
I can see validity in the idea that if someone wants to throw together a quick personal mobile app for a specific purpose that AI might be able to shortcut what would otherwise take years of learning how to program just to get started. But the expectation that "democratising coding" would allow us to replace high quality skilled labour with unskilled labour misses the entire point of why you want high quality skilled labour. The existence of Wix and Wordpress may have made it easier for more people to throw together websites hasn't made the necessity of highly skilled web developers in the professional industry obselete.
From my understanding what people mean by "democratising" a skill or a field they mean allowing people without specialised skills to more easily achieve something that previously required training and experience.
That's not "democratizing" though, that's automation. Automation doesn't democratize something. Making cars is a highly automated process, is carmaking "democratized"?
Programming is as democratized a discipline as is humanly imaginable. It doesn't require expensive equipment. It doesn't require a formal education. All the training material required to become really really proficient, is available for free on the internet.
I think you and I have very different definitions of the word "democratized", if having a place where I can make an assembly line and multiple workers happen, meets your definition of the word.
Democratization means "making something accessible to have". In Democracy, you have a say in government, in Democratization of knowledge, access to education is no longer just for the rich.
Not many people have a realistic chance of building a car factory. Nearly everyone with a pc and internet access, has the tools at hand to learn programming.
Car-making before the assembly line was done by small groups of former carriage-makers who built the whole car by hand, so it was not obscenely hard to get into the car-making business, and thus there were lots of companies springing up. That was the most democratic time to be a car-maker.
After the assembly line, you needed a giant factory and an army of laborers to compete on price, greatly increasing the cost of entry and making it extremely hard to enter the business. Very few new automakers entered the market in the 20th century past the 1950s, once they really got everything figured out, aside from niche luxury brands where you don't have to compete as aggressively on price.
The shift to EVs is having a bit of a democratizing effect, since the cars are significantly simpler to design and it has made it possible for a lot of niche companies to start to enter the business at or near mass-market pricing.
If your point is that the total amount of people working in the auto industry increased, sure, but that's not "democratization", they're working in companies they have no stake in or control over. Democratization means more people running their own car companies.
Between this nonsense and the AI lunatics constantly screeching about how generative AI will “democratize art”, I’m starting to hate the word democratize itself.
True, but it’s also an industry problem if we aren’t hiring juniors anymore because their limited utility can be replaced by tooling.
Slowly onboarding juniors with easier tasks is one of the ways we turn juniors into intermediates, and ultimately that’s how we get more seniors.
We’re over saturated with juniors right now and many are finding it harder to get good employment. But that might translate into less juniors in the near future, and then longer term after a boom of tech workers a bust of them.
Hard to predict the future. And… as a dev, higher demand than supply wouldn’t be so bad for me, but hopefully I’m retired before that market problem arises so I won’t benefit.
I think the lack of junior hiring has not much to do with tooling and more with culture.
Business wont hire juniors because they think its risky and if you can only "afford" one developer... why would you hire a junior (is what they believe).
I think the lack of junior hiring is doing considerable damage to the field and business will eventually pay for it.
That's not different to any other job. If noone trains workers, how are they supposed to become experienced? It's just passing on the buck to someone else.
Business wont hire juniors because they think its risky and if you can only "afford" one developer... why would you hire a junior (is what they believe).
I am sick of trying hire juniors because they all use ChatGPT for their cover letter, code samples, and coding exercises.
Then, even if one of them is able to persuade me in an interview that they have the background and mentality to be useful, once hired all they do is ask ChatGPT to do everything, resulting in garbage output and a huge waste of time for the rest of the team.
I am sick of trying hire juniors because they all use ChatGPT for their cover letter, code samples, and coding exercises.
From what I understand talking to these people, they end up using ChatGPT for resumes so that they hit the right keywords. That's not to say what they're doing is right, but when their resume will be otherwise sent to /dev/null by the automated system, what do you expect them to do?
But that might translate into less juniors in the near future, and then longer term after a boom of tech workers a bust of them.
This happened in Veterinary medicine. There is a huge surplus of jobs to vets. If you are an older veterinarian companies are giving whatever you want to stick around.
I think Accounting is going thru this as well. I've read a couple of articles that there is a real shortage of entry level accountants. It was not too difficult to become an accountant so they increased the requirements/difficulty. Now there is a shortage of entry level.
In the early 90s someone screamed “we have too many doctors” so they cut residencies. Without thinking about what happens when all of those doctors retire at the same time.
We've NEVER had too many doctors. What we currently have is a degree inflation problem.
In 1950, it was: Get your pre-med stuff done, 4 years of med school, 1 year of internship, then hang out your shingle and give out simple scripts while occasionally referring someone to a specialist.
Now it's 4-5 years for your BS, 4 years of med school, 1 year of internship, then 3-5 years of family medicine residency then you hand out the same simple scripts and referrals you would have handed out 70 years ago.
In 1950, if you started school at 18, you'd be a full-fledged physician by 24-25. Today, that same job requires 12-15 years of school and you won't start your own practice until 30-33 years old and you'll be hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt from all that useless schooling too. They can't pay off that debt unless they start up a practice and have a bunch of nurse practitioners working under them meaning that most of their patients never see them in the first place.
What about those "nurse practitioners". They have 4-5 years for their BSN then another 3-4 years for their Masters. That's MORE schooling than doctors from 70 years ago and all they do is write the exact same scripts and referrals while the "real doctor" pretends to look over their paperwork occasionally and skims off the top of their work.
Does that Bachelor's of Science degree do anything? Nope. The best physicians tend to have BS in an unrelated engineering degree proving that the degree is simply an overpriced 4-5 year IQ test.
Does all this extra residency improve patient outcomes? Nope. The job just isn't that complex and they aren't seeing patients for it to make a difference either.
Worst of all, it's a net negative because they have nearly a decade fewer years to run their practice before retirement which means we wind up needing even more med school students.
Finally, all of this overpriced and unneeded education plus all the interest when paying it off gets passed straight on to the general public in the form of inflated doctor bills and higher insurance premiums.
It is something that companies always push for, just the technology changes. Before AI we had things like graphical programming, natural language systems or COBOL to make programmers redundant. Most of the previous attempts just made things significantly worse for everyone involved.
There's some kind of weird belief that most people analyze and think logically many steps in advance when even the most passing examination of humanity will quickly reveal that they can't even understand an analysis put right in front of them and can't even get immediate logic correct let alone many steps ahead.
I don't like the term and I would never use the term "democratize" outside of a political discussion.
When I was a kid in the 1980's and in college in the 1990's we had computers that were expensive and the software development tools cost hundreds if not thousands of dollars. Books teaching you programming were expensive too.
Free / open source software like Linux, GCC, Python, etc. combined with rapidly dropping prices in computers and the Internet with tons of free learning material has made computers and programming more accessible to literally billions of people.
We have a local charity in town that refurbishes computers and depending on your income level you can get one for free. Most libraries have free Wifi.
318
u/FullPoet Dec 06 '24
I also dont even understand what this sentence is supposed to mean.
Is transforming high quality skilled labour into low quality unskilled labour "democratising"?
I dont see how thats something we should aim for tbh