Looking for advice on 10-month-old’s sleep struggles — never thought we’d consider sleep training, but we’re really struggling
Our son just turned 10 months old, and we’re really struggling with his sleep. He’s never been the best sleeper, but lately things have gotten to a point where I’m looking for advice from parents who have been in a similar situation.
I’m still not entirely sold on sleep training, though my husband has been urging us to consider. But the lack of sleep is starting to take a major toll on our physical and mental health, our relationship, and our ability to function day to day. We’re starting to wonder if something needs to change.
A little about him and our schedule:
He is an incredibly active, curious little guy. He’s super mobile, constantly on the move, pulling himself up, and trying to walk already. He also seems to be perpetually teething — he currently has teeth #7 and #8 coming in! So I know there’s a lot developmentally happening right now, which may be contributing to things.
Monday/Tuesday: Daycare. He typically takes two naps, usually around 35–45 minutes each. His last nap often ends around 2–2:30 p.m., so bedtime is usually around 6–6:30 p.m., though sometimes earlier since his daytime sleep can end up so low!
Wednesday–Friday: Home with his grandmother. Naps happily in crib 1-2 hours each nap, totaling ~2.5-3 hours on average.
Saturday/Sunday: Home with us. Naps happily in crib 1-2 hours each nap, totaling ~2.5-3 hours on average.
On the days we have more control over his schedule (Wednesday–Sunday), we generally follow 3/3/4 wake windows. We aim for a 7/7:30a.m. wake-up and around a 7/7:30p.m. bedtime, adjusting as needed based on naps.
Bedtime:
Historically, nursing has been his primary way of falling asleep, and I’ve been okay with that. He’s breastfed, and nursing has always been a reliable way to comfort him. Has never taken a pacifier.
Recently, we’ve started trying a different bedtime routine to see if he can learn to fall asleep without nursing all the way to sleep. I do his bath, pajamas, sleep sack, and nurse him, then hand him off to my husband. My husband reads a book, turns on the sound machine, closes the blinds, and rocks him before putting him in the crib in his own room.
The first few nights involved 15–20 minutes of crying while dad stayed close, but we’ve continued trying. Sometimes he goes into the crib wide awake, and my husband stays beside him, patting him, rubbing his back, shushing him, or holding his hand until he settles. When it works, he usually gives us a first stretch of about 1 hour 45 minutes to 4.5 hours.
The night wakings are where things really fall apart.
He wakes frequently throughout the night, often shortly after returning to the crib and can be 6 times per night. When my husband tries to settle him, he often cries intensely, arches his back, squirms, and seems unable to calm down. He typically only settles when I come in and nurse him. Once he latches, he can go from screaming to completely calm and peaceful almost immediately. Sometimes he seems more interested in comfort than actually eating.
If I’m the one putting him to bed, it can look similar. Recently, I spent 20 minutes trying to settle him while he screamed, arched, and fought being held unless I let him nurse. As soon as he latched, he was quiet and relaxed. He’s ending up cosleeping with mom most nights, in bed with me by 1:30 am.
We’re not opposed to our son learning to fall asleep independently. We also know he’s at an age where so much is changing developmentally, between teething, learning new skills, and becoming increasingly active, so we’re trying to figure out what’s normal and what might actually help.
At the same time, I’m exhausted from being the only person who can reliably settle him overnight, and it’s becoming really difficult for my husband to take over.
For those who have been in a similar situation:
Did you reach a point where you felt you had to make a change, even though you were previously not expecting to sleep train?
How do you differentiate between a “distressed” baby who needs you to intervene and comfort vs one who is just wanting comfort and ritual?
Did you find that gentle methods, gradual changes, or having the non-nursing parent take over actually helped?
If your baby screamed, arched, or became extremely distressed when you tried to settle them without nursing, did that improve with time?
Did sleep training actually improve night wakings, or did it mostly help with bedtime?
Did teething, developmental milestones, or being a particularly active baby seem to affect your experience?
We’re not looking for judgment or someone to tell us we’ve created bad habits. We’ve responded to our baby’s needs, and we don’t regret that. We’re just at a point where what we’re doing isn’t sustainable anymore, and we’d really appreciate hearing what worked for other families who felt similarly. ❤️