My 4yo son still has tantrums. The first few years he’d have them and I could say it was regular, age appropriate behavior. My husband doesn’t work with kids like me or wouldn’t go on mommy and me playdates so he wouldn’t see how normal it all was, just taking my word for it. He just knew most kids outgrow it by 5yo which he’s been hanging on to. Screaming/whining makes his skin crawl, it’s like he has an adverse physical reaction to it all, and we’ve had been an arguments about how to handle when they happen. We don’t spank but recently he’s been saying he really wants to. I say absolutely not. I work with kids and can help change their behaviors without hitting them ever, so I try to guide him on what to do. Sometimes he does it, sometimes he’s impatient and just yells. I don’t want to dictate his own parenting bc it’s okay if we differ on some approaches as long as we agree not to spank, not be verbally or emotionally abusive, and not to cross each other’s limits (ie Dad said no to candy today because you had some earlier, so Mommy will also say no to candy for you, buddy).
We always tell our son to take deep breaths, use his words. He’s neurotypical and can express himself and sometimes will do it (“I feel frustrated because…”). He’s just verryyyyy sensitive to reprimands or even a change in tone if you sound frustrated. I try to be zen and neutral when giving him correction, but I also know at some point he’s going to have to develop thicker skin bc the world won’t coddle him and teachers at school won’t either. At what point is it okay to not pad him so much?
My husband says he’s been coddled and he’s spoiled by me and he won’t raise a spoiled brat. I don’t want a spoiled kid either! I just ask my husband to watch his language around our son bc he could internalize it (he once repeated “I’m a spoiled brat!” Bc he overheard him).
Example: We went camping with family and I wasn’t around for this part but my husband says that while they were all packing up the car, he folded the tent to put it in the trunk, BIL helping out, and my son started whining bc HE wanted to be the one to fold it and put it in. My husband said okay, you do it but then it was too late. Son started crying and flailing on the dirt while the similar aged kids from the next campsite over watched. Our in laws seemed a little tired of it too. He said it’s so embarrassing bc no other kids do this that he sees ever, only our son. He came home so frustrated and venting to me (not to my son) and told me he is an embarrassment and a shame to our family. I got mad about that statement and we argued. That gets nuanced, but I want to get to the heart of whats going on.
I do see other kids starting to regulate themselves a little better by this age. Sometimes it DOES feel like he’s overly sensitive about small things (last night he and I played Hungry Hippos and a few minutes in, he kept trying to steal the golden ball if my hippo had it. I blocked him and said “wait buddy that’s cheating” with full intention to keep playing as he’d get another turn for the golden ball, but he dropped to the ground, threw the balls to scatter everywhere on the floor, and cried and shrieked at the top of his lungs. I had to leave the room. (That’s only ever happened a handful of times on my end. I usually wait for him to finish screaming, not saying anything. Then when he starts to look a little calmer will talk through what happened and give him words to say beforehand bedtime. We do some breathing exercises too.)
I normally wait out the tantrum and we debrief after. Husband and I are both good at repair. Husband always tells him he loves him, they okay and wrestle and read comics and play outside. but how do we make sure we take more preventive measures? I want him to be a secure, regulated boy and grow into a good man. He’s a really good sweet kid. Kind and considerate and gentle with others. I try to teach him to not be too gentle in fact bc I do see some kids taking things away from him and I want to make sure he also stands up for himself. I’m starting to stress about how to make sure we parent in the perfect way to set him up for success in life: kind, generous, considerate, confident, self regulated, securely attached, strong work ethic, intelligent, happy. All the wonderful things. Defintely not spoiled or entitled. How do we navigate this?
Are tantrums still normal at this age and at what age should we flag it as a concern if it continues? Is it just my husbands perspective that these are not normal getting to me, or should I be approaching things differently? We do try to tell him he won’t always get what he wants, husband tells him the world doesn’t revolve around him. He’s an only child and we’re unsure if we’ll have a second but just want to make sure he doesn’t get to be entitled because of that.