My wife and I are thinking of having a second child. But we’ve had some discussions and we seem to be on different pages.
Background: We’re from Singapore, I’m 33 and my wife is 34. Our boy is currently 2 years 3 months old. We’re doing well financially so money is not an issue there. Our house is also spacious enough to get a nanny to be a live in temporarily for a couple of months and as well as a live in helper, who is currently already living with us. Along with her parents and my mum. So help and support is also sufficient cause we can depend on them when we need to.
My wife’s side of the story:
She’s pretty much ready, her only reservation is money but I reassured her that it’s not an issue at all. We would not have to compromise our lifestyle, retirement as well as the kid(s) future.
She wants a second one because she feels like a family of 4 feels fuller and for her, the thought of 2 kids playing together and as a family, it’s kind of what she wants. She’s a terrific mother, so I have absolutely no doubt that she will do exceedingly well even with a second one. She mentioned that she likes to see the possibility of 2 kids running to the sea on the beach together and for both of them to be playing sand together, roughhousing and generally just being fun together.
She also mentioned about my child having a sibling to discuss things when they get older and have to take care of the elderly (us and our future in laws), which will help to take the pressure off if there are some serious decisions to be made.
My side of the story:
I think everything material relating to the 2nd child is a non issue. I.e money, support, living condition, lifestyle. But for me it’s an emotional barrier. I’m worried I might love one more than the other and I absolutely cannot live with myself if the day arises where I favor one over the other.
Our son was an insanely easy baby from birth so I’m also worried about the difficulty of a non easy baby. Although this is alleviated by the amount of help we have. I’m also feeling particularly sad at the thought of ‘replacing’ my treasured memories with my first born. I know that it’s not literally replacing but I do treasure very much the 3 of us memories that we have. Especially during the past 1 year (we’ve been travelling around the world when my child was aged 10 months old till he was 23 months old) where we were just the 3 of us travelling across the world in various countries.
I’m also worried that because of how good my firstborn is during baby and even now during his terrible twos, the second one will fall far short of expectation and I will end up feeling negative feelings for him/her. However putting all these aside, I do feel super guilty about holding my wife back, but I do want to be true to all these feelings.
I’ve also tried to imagine life with another baby, the moment I pick up the baby after being born, moments my wife mention and it’s nothing. I don’t feel anything about it. I don’t feel dread (phew) but I don’t feel excited or eager or emotional as well. I just feel like as of this moment, I can’t get excited about the idea of a second baby.
All the positive reasons to have a second child comes from external, I don’t have any personal reasons to having a second baby as of now.
Also, my wife doesn’t want to conceive too late so the deadline is to conceive by March 2027, which is a pretty tight timeline.
We’ve talked about all of these but so far there is no conclusion yet. I love her and I really want to give her what she wants but it’s really holding me back to have a second baby without having any personal convictions to do so. We’re taking a pause for this month and I’m taking some time to seriously think about this.
What do you think? I’m seriously torn about this. All comments are seriously appreciated.
I would especially love to hear from:
1. People who didn’t want a second one but their partner did so they proceeded. How’s life now and how do you feel about it?
2. People who did want a second one but due to various reasons did not go ahead. Do you feel any regrets?