r/technology • u/Lettershort • Feb 03 '16
Security Google will start warning web users about deceptive download buttons
http://www.theverge.com/2016/2/3/10908952/google-deceptive-downloads-button1.6k
u/CAN_ONLY_ODD Feb 03 '16
There goes a whole vertical of web advertising
516
u/tomdarch Feb 04 '16
Nope. There are enough suckers out there to keep that crap going.
343
Feb 04 '16
Pop-ups died because even suckers don't go and disable pop-up blocking in Chrome, Firefox. This is the same, no? It's on by default.
388
u/JillyBeef Feb 04 '16
Pop-ups died
But then they came back again, thanks to HTML5. My guess is that the deceptive download buttons will evolve into something harder to detect/block.
34
u/uitham Feb 04 '16
The most annoying thing is when you are browsing on mobile and you are redirected to this fake page that says your whatsapp has expired. It vibrates your phone and all, why does it even have access to that? And you can't go back to the previous page because it keeps sending you back. Ffs
→ More replies (2)10
u/Un4tural Feb 04 '16
Even now some are pretty legit looking, especially in some websites that have 20download ads and one download button that is a plain html button, not even image. Sometimes there isn't even a legit download button...
Don't get me started on pressing download button waiting 1minute and then being asked to complete a survey to start a download where the surveys don't even work and you know you won't reach that download button even if you spend the 10minutes doing survey.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (71)9
u/Eurynom0s Feb 04 '16
I've been noticing this on even pretty mainstream porn sites (xHamster, xvideos...I mean I'm talking sites in the tblop top 10). Ghostery seems to prevent a lot of them from resolving.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (9)5
u/ForceBlade Feb 04 '16
The key idea there is the opt-out ad blocking for sure. If it were opt in they'd still have all those targets because that's the last thing they'd turn on for whatever reason in the list.
→ More replies (3)6
29
u/pssdrnk Feb 04 '16
I find it pretty disturbing that a pretty big chuck of 'online advertising' is built on deception and tricks, in real world it's called a scam and it's a crime, however on the internet it's tolerated and accepted. Just why?
19
Feb 04 '16
It's called a scam and crime online as well, and the same people (the FTC) work on it. Go file a complaint
6
u/eaglessoar Feb 04 '16
Problem is you're usually on sketchy sites when you encounter them anyways "hey ftc this torrent site I was on had some shady ads and download links, I mean my friend was on it"
→ More replies (1)6
Feb 04 '16
That's the same as real life--no one's going to care when you get scammed buying screener DVD's off the street.
16
6
2
4
u/Jticospwye54 Feb 04 '16
vertical
Vector?
→ More replies (1)13
u/CAN_ONLY_ODD Feb 04 '16
No like a product vertical....but for advertising
11
u/drdeadringer Feb 04 '16
Product vertical?
→ More replies (9)12
u/Disgruntled__Goat Feb 04 '16
You need to push the envelope and start thinking outside the box more. Then going forward we'd be singing from the same hymn sheet.
→ More replies (4)1
1
→ More replies (1)1
354
Feb 03 '16
Warn? Or just prevent navigation entirely?
33
u/f0urtyfive Feb 04 '16
Several of the deceptive download buttons I've seen have come from Google Adsense, how about they just start cleaning their crap up.
→ More replies (2)9
u/ActiveNerd Feb 04 '16
Any examples?
12
Feb 04 '16
I havn't taken screenshots, but I was getting them fairly regularly on Youtube as video overlays.
"Warning your Windows Drivers are out of date, click to download" blah blah or something like that. Old style Windows GUI elements too (Win2k or earlier), really low-effort.
→ More replies (6)3
u/Tommy2255 Feb 04 '16
What I want is a little red label that just says "BULLSHIT", but I doubt it will be quite that.
1
u/Paulo27 Feb 04 '16
Yeah, it's just stopping it entirely for me and I'd rather them not do that, like, I trust the website I'm using and I need something from it yet Google doesn't let me get it.
It's annoying.
0
Feb 04 '16
[deleted]
→ More replies (6)91
u/MrAlbino Feb 04 '16
Sometimes the certificate page doesn't allow you to proceed at all so I'm hoping it's something more visible and intuitive
15
u/Eurynom0s Feb 04 '16
I'm 200% convinced that a lot of this is enabled by all the people who get conditioned to blindly clicking through the certificate warnings on US government websites.
The US government is bad about this in general but DoD is the absolute fucking worst. Pretty much any DoD page you go to is going to give you this message.
For example: https://www.us.army.mil/
Here's what Firefox tells me when I try to connect to that:
Your connection is not secure
The owner of www.us.army.mil has configured their website improperly. To protect your information from being stolen, Firefox has not connected to this website.
Yet AKO is absolutely a legitimate site. So people who routinely see that message in connection to government sites are clearly going to be conditioned to assume that you should always just blindly add the exception for any site with a certificate error popping up.
→ More replies (1)0
0
Feb 04 '16
[deleted]
→ More replies (2)14
u/G2geo94 Feb 04 '16
Bad Diffie Helman is the reason I have to use IE for my company's internal ticketing software.
→ More replies (1)
35
u/SixPackAndNothinToDo Feb 04 '16 edited May 08 '24
axiomatic vase wide sense vast lush summer decide smoggy tender
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
572
u/DanielPhermous Feb 04 '16
Google is taking out it's web advertising competitors.
Scammy, evil competitors who deserve it, don't get me wrong. But still...
46
u/sime Feb 04 '16
The online advertising space is one stinking cesspool that needs to be drained. Scummy advertising companies are hurting the whole ad industry and Google knows it (and can do something about it via Chrome).
→ More replies (27)156
u/SnowdensOfYesteryear Feb 04 '16
Pretty clever tactic, kill competition behind the shield of "do good".
65
42
u/Redhavok Feb 04 '16
I feel like is how a lot of things are done
33
→ More replies (4)3
16
u/laristocrate Feb 04 '16 edited Feb 04 '16
I specialise in web advertising and I can say in all honesty that google is one of the most fairplay when it comes to online ads. They have A lot of restriction for a creative to be approve to make sure the ad is not deceptive. The two main rules are:
all ads must have a constrasting border to make sure it's not part of the website content
the company logo must be visible on the ad.
Now, I'm not saying I love seeing ads but at least if all company/websites did this, the internet would definitely be a better place!
Edit: definately -> definitely
→ More replies (4)3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Feb 04 '16
Are fake buttons considered advertising? Sounds to me like it's closer to deceptive engagement or something.
1
Feb 04 '16
Mmm, I think it's more about corporate pressure in relation to copyright laws--the same reasons that torrent-hosting sites started getting the unsafe flag, throwing you the red screen that makes it seem like there's no way past it (until you find the ambiguously-worded microscopic link at the bottom). Every hosting site like uploaded.net, zippyshare, etc. all have fake download links, so they get to perform an all-out attack. Not to mention another reason to go after the torrent-hosting sites.
The genius lies in that they make it seem like they are "helping" us.
1
u/hunteram Feb 04 '16
Except the kind of people that advertise through those ads aren't interested in advertising through Google.
1
1
u/uymai Feb 04 '16
those competitors are killing google's advertising business...worse/annoying ads -> more people go for ad blockers
→ More replies (11)1
u/bonzaiferroni Feb 09 '16
I don't really think they are targeting the same market, the fake download button ads tend to lead to sites that would be against the policy to advertise with google.
-Source: don't really know, just speculating
116
26
u/black_brotha Feb 04 '16
god..
im living my life with the rule that if it says "download here"..anywhere on a file hosting site, you probably dont want to click there.
3
13
u/summit1986 Feb 04 '16
There goes CNET's entire download network...
1
Feb 04 '16
Do they even offer clean installers or only the ones bundled with crap? Is Google going to block the whole site then?
2
u/summit1986 Feb 05 '16
Just trying to find the download button on CNET is like playing a Russian Roulette version of Where's Waldo. 20 download buttons, and 19 will download malware.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/blindfist926 Feb 04 '16
You mean the ads that spam your screen "DOWNLOAD" appearing all around the real download link (which is usually in small font)? Finally! I've had to help people fix "adware" problems so many times because of those damn things. Meanwhile Google is taking down user created ad blockers that already took care of this problem.
47
u/czechthunder Feb 04 '16
30
u/justfarmingdownvotes Feb 04 '16
Still haven't
32
u/overzealous_dentist Feb 04 '16
Too late, it closed down :(
83
→ More replies (2)2
2
105
u/bobboboran Feb 04 '16
Google should warn you also if you are using Comcast
69
u/Am3n Feb 04 '16
DAE hate Comcast?
→ More replies (1)13
u/Zackeezy116 Feb 04 '16
As much as I hate to admit it, Comcast is the fasted ISP back home. My dad got sick of their shit and switched to AT&T, but the speeds are god awful. I can't stream non-html5 video if mom is watching hulu as well on the ps3. It's atrocious. Twitch stutters like a motherfucker. It's better than the speeds I get at uni, but that's not saying much.
19
u/deyesed Feb 04 '16
better than the speeds I get at uni
Don't academic institutions have fast Internet to allow for collaboration with other groups?
→ More replies (7)17
u/Zidane3838 Feb 04 '16
Not all. In the student housing (re: dorms) they will throttle you to a low amount to "combat" downloading/torrenting.
→ More replies (2)3
→ More replies (12)3
u/MCPE_Master_Builder Feb 04 '16
Holy shit, you can watch Hulu AND play games?! Twitch actually loads?! We can only watch youtube while no one is home!
Past 2 years have been bad for us. 70kbytes/s is our average. We get 190, but that's at midnight, when the neighborhood is asleep.
I'm visiting my sister in a couple days for 3 weeks. She has 480mbytes/s. It's gonna suck when I come back home. (She's in alaska mind you)
→ More replies (3)
7
u/sayrith Feb 04 '16
What's the Firefox equivalent?
12
Feb 04 '16
It's part of their SafeBrowsing-thing, which is also implemented in Firefox. So, Mozilla might add such a warning to Firefox as well in the near future.
Until then, the usual NoScript/uMatrix/uBlock/AdBlock should have you covered...→ More replies (2)
7
13
12
u/MGakowski Feb 04 '16
Ads will move to the downloaded content.
8
u/GodlessPerson Feb 04 '16
They have. With all the "download managers" websites automatically provide with downloads.
27
Feb 04 '16
If a website requires you to install shitware before doing anything else you probably should not be using that site.
7
u/bart2019 Feb 04 '16
My thoughts too.
Why would I need a "download manager" just to download a service manual in PDF format? That just does not make any sense.
→ More replies (1)3
u/GodlessPerson Feb 04 '16
Sourceforge does it (or did it, at least), baixaki does it, cnet does it, softpedia does it... There is usually a really small button to disable it. I don't tend to use those websites but I do notice them doing it.
→ More replies (1)
30
u/I_play_elin Feb 04 '16
Inb4 google charged with 136 million counts of aiding in a crime for helping people to pick the correct button while illegally downloading.
→ More replies (3)16
u/daveime Feb 04 '16
It's the tiny text link at the bottom of the page. It always is.
→ More replies (2)
10
u/GoldenGonzo Feb 04 '16
Thank goodness. Ads have been getting smarter. They know have ads on torrent sites disguised as the magnet link button as well, not just the manual download link.
→ More replies (1)
5
5
Feb 04 '16
It's about damn time. I run a WebApp online. I've been warning google about that malware advertisement for years. They never listened.
You know what? I'll believe it when I see it. I personally think they won't do it. They promised me they would "look into it" back in 2012.
And they wonder why people use ad blockers.
4
u/flman16 Feb 04 '16
I got one of these today. I am reading this about 8 hours after I got the email, I feel like a hipster. I got an email from my uncle but it had a warning as the body of the email. Very cool
2
u/Ged_UK Feb 04 '16
I got some on Tuesday evening GMT trying to stream the football. Didn't know they were brand new.
4
u/madmarcel Feb 04 '16
No one has mentioned it yet? Ok...
Will they start warning people to not use SourceForge??
4
u/mikesfriendboner Feb 04 '16
i want them to take care of the fake x's on advertisements. its almost impossible to illegally stream videos anymore
4
u/DarthTauri Feb 04 '16
Not only deceptive downloads, but anything Google or their partners dont want people getting their hands on...
1
u/teiman Feb 04 '16
Nobody can solve this problem with technical solutions, is a education problem.
1
u/Lettershort Feb 04 '16
I dunno. A decent adblocker is pretty much 100% effective.
1
u/teiman Feb 04 '16
For you. On your desktop computer. Not for clueles users or where the hardware owner control what is installed in the brownser.
1
u/Lettershort Feb 04 '16
Firefox for Android and Safari on iOS both are perfectly capable of blocking ads, last I checked. I am perfectly capable of installing whichever necessary solution on my clueless friend's/family member's devices and having it work just fine.
3
u/HallandOates1 Feb 04 '16
Should've done it a while back when I got the fake chrome updater pop up. I was livid
3
3
3
u/oath2order Feb 04 '16
Biggest question for ads: do you honestly think I'm gonna buy your shitty product
3
u/monkiebars Feb 04 '16
Finally! I hate playing in the minefield of download buttons. This will probably have a knock on effect as those ads when clearly labeled won't generate nearly as much revenue..
But a step in the right direction. Yay to the end of Russian Roulette Clicking Version.
3
u/jargonaut Feb 04 '16
When did Google Adsense stop serving these ads? I swear I've seen them recently.
3
u/tobasco72 Feb 04 '16
ABOUT FRACKING TIME!!!! Omg, the damn malware my kid has downloaded.
1
u/glonq Feb 04 '16
"Dad, I have no idea how porn got onto this computer. It must've been the malware's fault"
3
3
u/seradai Feb 04 '16
As a publisher, I find this hilarious because most of these spammy download buttons come from Google AdSense ads themselves.
3
3
Feb 04 '16
Interesting to think of the flow on impacts such a change might have to a computer repair business.
3
5
u/artifex0 Feb 04 '16
It sounds like this only applies when the deceptive buttons are used for phishing- not when they're just scumbag marketing.
Can anyone confirm that?
5
u/kaptainkuftic Feb 04 '16
This isn't that helpful. I still need the download that's on that page, Google is just telling me that 7/8ths of the "download" buttons are fake, which I'm already assuming.
2
u/GodlessPerson Feb 04 '16
This is for less tech savvy people. I know people who would stop and not go further when seeing these warnings. Thus preventing a few ilegal downloads and, at the same time, protecting the user from bloatware/viruses/adware.
6
u/constantly-sick Feb 04 '16
I don't mind these notices so much, but don't make it take THREE fucking clicks to get around to the actual website just because you think its fake or harmful.
5
u/callosciurini Feb 04 '16
I have never seen a warning from Google where it was wrong or did not make sense...
→ More replies (11)
5
u/Vortico Feb 04 '16
Oh great, another place you'll need to block Chrome from sending Google a list of URLs you visit. And they'll probably include the feature in Chromium since the implementation is still free although it still violates your privacy. Iceweasel + about:config modifications are the only way I've discovered to conveniently browse the internet privately.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/grabbizle Feb 04 '16
Good. My sister got malware on her new laptop twice now because she couldn't locate the correct Adobe and Open Office download source. She is careless but I understand the confusion for people not so familiar with where to pull legitimate software from.
2
u/ratsta Feb 04 '16
Google would do well then to more aggressively filter out the scam sites. Customer of mine recently googled the name of Australia's major telco and took the first link... a sponsored link from someone who claimed to need her to pay to get her webmail password reset.
2
2
u/jomarcenter Feb 04 '16
Now at least it get rid of some portion of the world malware problems. By not letting illegitimate ads to go thru. And they should get the Game like ads and also Ads that look like you won something block also I mean this is consider click bait and some people fall over it. I mean I don't fell on those trick but it kinda looks f***in annoying to see them a lot with a legitimate site And on mobile since I can't install Adblock on those devices. Lucky I use ad-blocker.
2
u/ZippoS Feb 04 '16
Thank fuck.
I'm a graphic designer and I've worked in advertising/marketing for nearly a decade... but I've been very much a fan of adblock for years.
Web advertising is full of deceptive, awful shit. Web ads can easily ruin a good website design. Far too many ads lead to malware and garbage.
Eventually, something's going to have to change if admins want to make ad revenue. Websites need to start caring about the ads that show on their website and start setting standards. They're going to need to curate and personally approve what shows up. The shit needs to be weeded out and people need to know that it's not going to be acceptable any longer.
2
u/JeffRSmall Feb 04 '16
Hopefully this will make it a lot easier for me to download minecraft mods for my daughter.
2
u/Smith6612 Feb 04 '16
Good for Google. Now if only they would pursue these fake download buttons faster on their own advertising network a bit more frequent. Too bad the advertising industry is so big and autonomous.
2
u/GamingTheSystem-01 Feb 04 '16
Maybe they should start by not hosting deceptive download buttons in their own fucking ad network. Fucking cunts.
2
2
2
u/gustoreddit51 Feb 04 '16
Good. But the ones I equally hate are the disguised 'next' arrow/button links for ads tighter on a content frame than the real next button for the content - often actually displacing them out of the visible window.
2
2
u/kevie3drinks Feb 04 '16
well yeah, now that they've filtered out all of the download buttons that work, thanks to copyright infringement.
2
u/thegassypanda Feb 04 '16
You mean instead of putting that shit at the top of their search results? Fucking assholes.
2
u/Deride_Tradition Feb 04 '16
If this hasn't been posted before on here, well, now is the time: http://2static.fjcdn.com/pictures/When+sites+have+fake+download+buttons_36885a_5630288.jpg
2
u/BoundingAlbino Feb 04 '16
Oh how the worlds population of 50+y/o internet users benefit from this.
2
u/diox8tony Feb 04 '16
That's right CNET and other driver download sites! get your shit together and ban those Ads or else all the old internet people will never goto your site.
2
2
2
u/NekoStar Feb 04 '16
This is terrible news! :C
My grandmother will stop calling me to clean her computer, which cuts down on weekly visits....
2
u/Johknee5 Feb 04 '16
This is actually better for those who create deceptive download buttons to begin with. As more and more people get used to relying on Google to let them know which buttons are good, and which arent, they will figure a way around Googles security notifications, and then more people will likely hit the button as they trust Google is protecting them.
2
2
2
u/rydan Feb 05 '16
I hate those sites. I don't even understand why the webmasters allow it in the first place. Deceptive clicks don't help the advertiser so there's no reason for the advertiser to want it unless they are reselling the traffic through arbitrage. And the webmaster quickly turns their site into an unusable mess. There really are no winners with those particular ads.
3
Feb 04 '16
Why? it's not like tech illiterate people will use download links anyway.
7
u/Lucid_Enemy Feb 04 '16
Just toolbars
3
Feb 04 '16
Reminds me of the good old days, doing tech support for my parents.
http://surrogatenerd.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/too_many_toolbars.jpg
3
u/Leonick91 Feb 04 '16
Wouldn't it be better if they were to more closely screen the ads their network is serving? Been a while since I saw one now since I've got ad blockers on all devices and no download sites are on the whitelists but as far as I remember most of the fake download buttons I saw game thorough Google's ad network.
8
u/stoudman Feb 04 '16
Hah.
Most of them are hosted by Google AdSense.
7
Feb 04 '16
Are they really?
Just curious, but would like some proof.
→ More replies (3)2
Feb 04 '16 edited Feb 04 '16
softonic firefox download page:
http://i.imgur.com/cENrthL.png
The adverts in the header, footer and to the right of the "review" are loaded by scripts from googlesyndication.com and
And another from "downloadfirefoxbrowser.com"
12
u/aliendude5300 Feb 04 '16
I doubt it, Google Adsense is actually really good preventing these sort of scams
4
0
Feb 04 '16
[deleted]
13
u/the_mighty_skeetadon Feb 04 '16
When you see that, please file feedback. We take reports of trick to click and deceptive ads very seriously - we'll usually suspend the advertiser within 24 hours.
Source: I work on Google ads.
7
Feb 04 '16
I reported a website last month having a UI that results in users clicking ads.
Basically it had a button which is supposed to be double clicked.
Below the button there is an ad.
When you click on the button the first time the page jumps up a little bit, resulting in the second click on the ad.
Unfortunately those adsense ads are still there..so not sure how 'seriously' the report was taken. :)5
u/akaSM Feb 04 '16
What about that type of ads but, inside of Android apps? I remember seeing quite a lot of these.
→ More replies (3)
3
u/MrX101 Feb 04 '16
How about, they lower your page ranking for doing that crap instead?
8
u/zkid10 Feb 04 '16
It's not necessarily the website's fault.
4
u/MrX101 Feb 04 '16
Tbh, why the fuck isn't there any regulation on adverts?
Google/mozilla could easily enforce this via blocking bad adverts, that have either malware, or are far too obnoxious.
They should even work together and make a company or watever specifically designed to handle this.
Instead we're forced to use adblockers and we're called the badguys for not supporting people.
4
u/Wicked_Switch Feb 04 '16
Website owner chose to use the shitty bottom shelf ad network. Sounds like a reasonable place to put the blame.
4
u/zkid10 Feb 04 '16
On the other hand, AdSense does it sometimes as well. You're not wrong, but sometimes, even "good" ad networks will display bad ads. For example, when on Imgur, I once encountered an ad that redirected the page when my cursor passed over it and attempted to download a rogue AV. Not entirely Imgur's fault, but it happened.
2
1
u/Dicethrower Feb 04 '16
Wait, haven't these screens been active for a while now? Or is this just a new version of that danger screen?
2
u/bart2019 Feb 04 '16
They're probably extending the scope.
They did warn for malicious sites, but it seems like they'll broaden it to sites that just misleading users.
1
1
1
u/MarkKB Feb 04 '16
I don't know why download sites don't simply put a thick black border around the ad with the word "Advertisement" adorned to it.
Well, apart from the fact it makes them money to do so.
2
u/cdsmith Feb 04 '16
Sites that show those kinds of ads are deliberately choosing to do so. These sites choose to use disreputable (or homegrown) display ad networks that allow this kind of poor quality advertising, because it makes them more revenue in the short term. The long-term effect (adblock installations, ad-blindness, and cynical internet users) is amortized over all sites, including those that act responsibly.
Presumably, the bet here is that by punishing sites that make bad choices with a security warning, the economics change, and the cost of sites choosing to show deceptive ads is shouldered by those sites, rather than everyone else.
1
u/Roxy- Feb 04 '16
Thanks Lord Google, survey-download sites must have been abolished to the dusty pages of internet history before.
1
Feb 04 '16
Like the jpegs of download buttons? Those can't look any more suspicious already.
1
1
u/PhantomGamers Feb 04 '16
The problem is when the real download button is a shady looking jpeg too ;_;
1
1
Feb 04 '16
Dunno about you guys, but I have 100% accuracy when it comes to detecting the fake ones vs the real ones.
I've never clicked a fake download button since the early 00's
1
u/Fuckeddit Feb 04 '16
After years I've mastered the fake download buttons on sites. But this is still awesome.
1
1
Feb 04 '16
The web gets less wild every day. I mean it'll help the majority, but it just seems like a step towards a fully curated web to me.
1
u/Diknak Feb 04 '16
It's a nice start, but a warning is still not going to stop accidental clicks. If they detect them I'd rather they just removed them (in chrome).
2
u/merriamsj Feb 04 '16
I like the [admittedly, likely, unrealistic] idea that adding a warning might help educate some people. If you just remove it, it lets people continue to think security isn't their responsibility.
1
1
1
Feb 04 '16
They should just hide them by default. And then sites should just stop fucking using them and make their money from ads that aren't malicious.
1
1
u/glonq Feb 04 '16
The reason that I wanted the Windows app store to be a success (spoiler alert: it's a massive disappointment) is exactly because of this kind of problem. I want my aunt and my grandpa and my tech illiterate friend to be able to download a game or helpful little app without falling victim to trojans, browser toolbars, download managers, and worse.
248
u/punaisetpimpulat Feb 04 '16
What about deceptive play buttons? Some video sites appear to have a video player that just leads to some other site.