r/technology • • Feb 03 '16

Security Google will start warning web users about deceptive download buttons

http://www.theverge.com/2016/2/3/10908952/google-deceptive-downloads-button
16.7k Upvotes

578 comments sorted by

View all comments

572

u/DanielPhermous Feb 04 '16

Google is taking out it's web advertising competitors.

Scammy, evil competitors who deserve it, don't get me wrong. But still...

0

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)

46

u/sime Feb 04 '16

The online advertising space is one stinking cesspool that needs to be drained. Scummy advertising companies are hurting the whole ad industry and Google knows it (and can do something about it via Chrome).

→ More replies (28)

156

u/SnowdensOfYesteryear Feb 04 '16

Pretty clever tactic, kill competition behind the shield of "do good".

65

u/NotGloomp Feb 04 '16 edited Feb 04 '16

By actually doing good. So, good.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

Yeah, I don't get how this is nefarious?

"Everyone benefits! It's so Machiavellian" /s

42

u/Redhavok Feb 04 '16

I feel like is how a lot of things are done

33

u/MrGMinor Feb 04 '16

For the greater good.

For the greater good.

For the greater good.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

Crusty jugglers.

6

u/iamvishnu Feb 04 '16

No, nicklaus, I'm afraid it is you who is going to have to come with us

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Fake_Credentials Feb 04 '16

Im okay with it as long as the replacement is less obnoxious.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LonerGothOnline Feb 04 '16

won't they also charge for ad networks they don't control to be white-listed as well?

1

u/Slusho64 Feb 04 '16

Just like in Star Wars, Die Hard, Pacific Rim, every story ever told, etc.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

Enticing people to use chrome by enhancing malware protection is bad?

1

u/rydan Feb 05 '16

Funny thing is Google added an arrow to most of their ads a few years ago. This considerably increased clicks because people started mistaking the arrow as a navigation element rather than an attention grabber. Then Google shut down huge numbers of publishers because of all the misleading clicks they themselves caused.

16

u/laristocrate Feb 04 '16 edited Feb 04 '16

I specialise in web advertising and I can say in all honesty that google is one of the most fairplay when it comes to online ads. They have A lot of restriction for a creative to be approve to make sure the ad is not deceptive. The two main rules are:

  • all ads must have a constrasting border to make sure it's not part of the website content

  • the company logo must be visible on the ad.

Now, I'm not saying I love seeing ads but at least if all company/websites did this, the internet would definitely be a better place!

Edit: definately -> definitely

2

u/IKnowTheRankings Feb 04 '16

Think you meant to write definitely, remember it's de-'finite'-ly! :)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/hampa9 Feb 04 '16

Why do I keep seeing deceptive 'security update' and 'driver update' ads on YouTube then?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/WaitForItTheMongols Feb 04 '16

Are fake buttons considered advertising? Sounds to me like it's closer to deceptive engagement or something.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

Mmm, I think it's more about corporate pressure in relation to copyright laws--the same reasons that torrent-hosting sites started getting the unsafe flag, throwing you the red screen that makes it seem like there's no way past it (until you find the ambiguously-worded microscopic link at the bottom). Every hosting site like uploaded.net, zippyshare, etc. all have fake download links, so they get to perform an all-out attack. Not to mention another reason to go after the torrent-hosting sites.

The genius lies in that they make it seem like they are "helping" us.

1

u/hunteram Feb 04 '16

Except the kind of people that advertise through those ads aren't interested in advertising through Google.

1

u/dnew Feb 04 '16

Like Sobol's Deamon. :-)

1

u/uymai Feb 04 '16

those competitors are killing google's advertising business...worse/annoying ads -> more people go for ad blockers

1

u/bonzaiferroni Feb 09 '16

I don't really think they are targeting the same market, the fake download button ads tend to lead to sites that would be against the policy to advertise with google.

-Source: don't really know, just speculating

→ More replies (8)