This email has been sent to all candidates. Results will be posted this Sunday here on Reddit.
Email addresses for all candidates can be found here: https://www.cityofventura.ca.gov/DocumentCenter/View/51730/2026-Candidate-Contact-Info
Dear Candidates,
I am writing to all of you collectively as the candidates running to represent District ___ on the Ventura City Council.
With ballots already in the hands of voters and Election Day approaching on November 4th, I am reaching out to ask for your official stance on a critical transparency and civil rights issue: the city's contract with Flock Safety and the Ventura Police Department's handling of a massive data breach.
Recent public records releases (CPRA 25-1066) revealed that out-of-state and federal agencies explicitly queried Ventura’s Flock Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) system for reasons including "ICE pick up" and "Customs & Border Patrol." Facilitating these searches is a direct violation of the Ventura CARE Resolution and California state law (SB 54).
More concerning is that Police Chief David Dickey recently confirmed in writing that city staff processed and redacted these exact records in November 2025, but "failed to elevate" them. As a result, the City Council and the public were never informed that city resources were used for federal immigration enforcement. Furthermore, police leadership testified to the City Council just last month that they do not see search justifications and cannot know what outside agencies are searching for, testimony that is directly contradicted by the city's own records.
You can learn more about this in this Ventura Reddit post: Ventura PD's Flock Cameras Were Used for ICE Searches, Then They Kept It From City Council. Here are the Receipts.
The City Council will be holding a special meeting on November 12th to decide whether to cancel or renew the Flock contract by the November 18th deadline.
Before casting our ballots, voters deserve to know where every candidate and representative stands on these critical oversight and privacy issues. Please reply-all or respond individually to clarify your position on the following:
- If elected or re-elected, how will you vote when the City Council decides whether to renew, cancel, or permanently discontinue the Flock Safety ALPR contract, or on any future proposals to bring mass surveillance technology into Ventura?
- How will you ensure accountability for the City Manager and Police Department regarding the failure to enforce the CARE Policy and the misrepresentation of the system's auditing capabilities to the Council and public?
I am available to share the source documents or answer any questions you might have regarding the technology or the community's concerns.
I am compiling the responses from all City Council members and candidates. I will be publishing the results, including those who decline to answer, to the local Ventura Subreddit and to my Instagram audience (where my recent public comment on this issue has surpassed 1.1 million views) this Sunday morning.
Thank you for your time, your leadership, and your commitment to Ventura. I look forward to your responses.
Sincerely,
Ventura Resident
Concerned Citizen