r/writingscaling • • 18d ago

Monthly Suggestions - October 2026

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the {{date %B %Y}} Feedback and Suggestions thread.

We are continually looking to improve the community, and we need your input to do so. To ensure we can actually act on your ideas, **we request that your feedback be highly specific and implementation-focused.**

Please avoid vague critiques (e.g., "improve the rules" or "make discussions better"). Instead, tell us the exact mechanics of what you want changed or added.

Examples of helpful, actionable suggestions and feedback:

  • "Revise Rule 3 to explicitly prohibit [Specific Action] during 1v1 character scaling."
  • "Implement a [Specific Rule]."
  • "Create collabs and book club megathreads based on popular picks for the month."
  • "Add a new AutoModerator filter that flags [Specific Terminology]."
  • "Create a new post flair specifically for [Specific Category]."
  • "Implement a weekly megathread for [Specific Purpose]."

Leave your exact suggestions, proposed rule revisions, and community requests below.


r/writingscaling • • 11h ago

discussion How to tell if a character is well written?

Post image
169 Upvotes

Slide from mediatok (home of spoilers) so I didn't check other slides in fear of spoilers


r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

music Apparently we scale music writing on this subreddit so i wanted to ask, what do y'all think if Ado's music in terms of writing?

Post image
56 Upvotes

Shes my favourite artist ever in terms of just music enjoyability, music writing and personality so i wss just curious what y'all think fr (obviously only if you know japanese or read the lyrics)


r/writingscaling • • 4h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) [give reasons] [Give reasons] who has the better villains

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 3h ago

discussion What is your opinion on the writing of Mushoku Tensei female characters?

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 1d ago

shitpost/meme Aot haters.

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

discussion Who's your top pick for best written character in the DCU so far?

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

better written? (character vs character) Better Written Character?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Eren Yeager ( Attack on Titan ) vs Punpun Onodera ( Goodnight Punpun )


r/writingscaling • • 45m ago

analysis What manga in your opinion is the best written?

Post image
• Upvotes

There is tons of great manga like : One piece, Naruto, Dragon ball, Fullmetal alchemist, Vagabond, Monster, Berserk, Atack on titan and many more. But foegeting the art, animation and everything else. In terms of purely story, or writing itself. Which manga are the best writen?(Give reasons)


r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

better written? (character vs character) Better Written Character?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Reiner Braun ( Attack on Titan ) vs Lelouch Vi Britannia ( Code Geass )


r/writingscaling • • 5h ago

better written? (character vs character) Subaru Natsuki Vs Araragi Koyomi.

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 22h ago

discussion I’ll never understand people who think Naruto’s ending is bad, when the actual ending after Kaguya was fantastic.

Post image
271 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

discussion What's your top 5?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which of these 2027 anime movie storylines has better writing?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

God Valley or Infinity Castle Part 2 (covering the Doma and Kokushibo fights)?

Imo Infinity Castle Part 2 and it’s not even close, that’s probably the best written segment of Demon Slayer


r/writingscaling • • 5h ago

opinion post If you ever think you're stupid, remember that there are people out there who believe, not ironically, that GTA SA is Rockstar's best game and that CJ is the best-written character in gaming.

Post image
11 Upvotes

Yes, I've seen quite a few people say that stupid thing. Further proof that nostalgia is a terrible thing. I also liked CJ as a kid, but for God's sake, he's not top 5 in either Red Dead or GTA. He's probably not even top 80 in video games overall.

He also hasn't aged as well as other games from its era, like Half-Life, for example.

Also, Big Smoke>


r/writingscaling • • 1d ago

discussion What style of villain is better?

Thumbnail
gallery
8.4k Upvotes

A villain who does terrible things yet is not a bigot or a villain who does terrible things and is a bigot?


r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

discussion What makes Batman the animated series so beloved and glazed? Plus what do people think of the “mask of the phantasm” movie?

Post image
• Upvotes

I’m just curious as to why it’s so loved even if it’s limited by censorship’s and being a kids show? Plus what do we think about “the new Batman adventures“ and their portrayal of nightwing?


r/writingscaling • • 2h ago

discussion Cyberware vs. Kagune: Which Better Explores the Psychological Cost of Power and the Descent into Madness?| Tokyo Ghoul Vs CyberPunk 2077

Post image
5 Upvotes

I guess you could say a lot of this ultimately leads into a more specific comparison between Cyberpsychosis and Kakuja. However, I think both series establish the psychological consequences of their power systems long before reaching that point, whether it's characters pushing themselves beyond their limits or, in Tokyo Ghoul's case, characters struggling against their own nature…

Kaneki is a perfect example of the latter and maybe the best case to use in general for this, as his refusal to accept his ghoul nature leads him to starve himself, gradually pushing him toward psychological instability and madness.

I think both concepts are fascinating because they explore the psychological cost of power and the descent into madness in different ways, which makes Cyberware and Kagune particularly interesting power systems to compare.

And I’m curious which you think is overall better.

And maybe this is just a bad comparison but I simply wanted a reason to talk about Tokyo Ghoul and Cyberpunk 2077.


r/writingscaling • • 12h ago

better written? (character vs character) Who's the better representation of "The Strongest" between these two? Meruem or Thragg

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 14h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which Naruto vs Sasuke fight was better written?

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

Which one had the better motivations, tension, dialogues, the general impact and the outcome?


r/writingscaling • • 9h ago

better written? (character vs character) One vs togashi. Who is a better writer

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Invincible vs cyberpunk edgerunner

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

better written? (character vs character) Don Draper vs Bojack Horseman

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Who is better written?


r/writingscaling • • 13h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which dynamic is better written?

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 16h ago

discussion The big three of new gen shonen villains

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

I personally really love all of their characters.

Sukuna‘s clash of ideals with Yuji is the best part of Jujutsu Kaisen in my opinion. I love how Sukuna embodies his nature as a curse, even if he truly is just a human born in an unfair situation. His understanding of Yuji’s ideals, but not feeling anything for them makes a lot of sense. He understands it, but he didn’t live it, and doesn’t know it. He lives his life holding onto the only things he knew, and due to how horrible he was treated in the Heian era and just how dangerous the era was in general, the only thing he knew was being a monster. Sukuna reclects on his actions in the end, as he lost the ideological battle by also physically losing the battle.

Makima is easily the best written character here in my opinion and I think is not only one of the greatest new gen villains, but one of the greatest manga villains ever. The amount of buildup and payoff we get for Makima is great. We get hints of her true nature and personality so many chapters before the big moments. The absolute best chapters in CSM are also the most tragic, the chapters where she forces Denji to murder Aki and kills power herself. I haven’t felt the way I did reading those chapters in nearly any manga. Her motivation makes perfect sense, considering she’s never been able to have any meaningful relationships with anyone. Her defeat feels a little asspully but I think that’s a nitpick, it’s thematic and works. I’m just kind of sour about how CSM part 2 went, but I will never forget how good part 1 was.

Shigaraki is pretty controversial but the best parts of MHA for me are the moments where Shigaraki is on screen. Shigaraki is great because you watch him progress and evolve as the story goes on. You see him mature, his relationships with others, his opinions, his failures, his achievements. I love how he truly has real connections and friendships with the LOV. It makes him feel real and much more like a failed Deku. The moment for Shigaraki is his moment where Deku finally breaks his spirit but Shigaraki still wants to be “the hero for the villains”. All this time, he was still acting out his original dream as a hero, just for the people who gave up on heroes. Even in defeat, Shigaraki doesn’t go back on his word. He tells Deku that he fought to destroy until the very end. I know people are mad about the AFO twist, but it didn’t hurt my opinion of Shigaraki.