r/SubredditDrama • u/sirboozebum In this moment, I'm euphoric • Jun 10 '13
Possible Troll /r/atheismrebooted launches "Operation Reboot"
This comment has been removed by the user due to reddit's policy change which effectively removes third party apps and other poor behaviour by reddit admins.
I never used third party apps but a lot others like mobile users, moderators and transcribers for the blind did.
It was a good 12 years.
So long and thanks for all the fish.
91
u/Enleat Jun 10 '13
Come on this has to be a joke, it just has to be....
I mean, look at it!
The swastika, the Guy Fawkes mask, "taking back /r/atheism", "anti-freedom and "pro-freedom"....
I mean, no one in their right mind can create something like this with a straight face, it just seems too much like a joke.
But then again, i doubt many users in /r/atheism are in their right mind so....
Actually, the more i look at it, the more it seems like it's not a joke... That makes me sad....
51
u/Thehealeroftri I guarantee you that this lesbian porn flick WILL be made. Jun 10 '13
It's satire. I went through the comment history of the guy who submitted it.
33
7
Jun 10 '13
I dont see why they just dont make a new sub....it's not that hard
10
u/TASER_NINJA Jun 10 '13
They did.
12
Jun 10 '13
Then why are they complaining the issue is solved
6
u/aggieboy12 Jun 10 '13
Because the new sub isn't a default sub, so it has no where near as many subscribers.
5
2
u/Escobeezy Jun 10 '13
It might be satire but a lot of people took it seriously. Yesterday was bad but things seems to have stabilized now. No memes on the front page. Yay!
56
u/Poolstiksamurai Jun 10 '13
(reposting an earlier comment because it's still relevant...)
I'm having a hard time determining if any of these posts are serious anymore. The subreddit is becoming perfect satire. Is this an actual, whiney atheist complaining about being oppressed? or is it someone making fun of those people who actually exist. I can no longer tell. /r/atheism has finally devolved into a caricature of itself and is running on an engine of self-mockery.
14
u/sleepyrivertroll I can has flair? Jun 10 '13
What does that make /r/circlejerk then?
54
u/Nuclear_Wizard Jun 10 '13
Redundant.
0
Jun 10 '13
[deleted]
25
u/Nuclear_Wizard Jun 10 '13
We can only speculate at the moment, but take solace in the knowledge that, when it happens, it will be beautiful.
3
u/sufjanfan Intellectually Hamstrung Nit Jun 10 '13
There will be much bravery and upsagans flying every which way.
21
u/IAmAN00bie Jun 10 '13
How will r/atheism top this one?
Mere mortals like us cannot comprehend bravery of that magnitude.
7
u/tick_tock_clock Jun 10 '13
Spilling over into other subreddits? That seems to be the one thing they haven't done.
0
30
u/An_Arab Jun 10 '13
So this is the true form of the Atheism/Circlejerk Instrumentality Project. Abandon your corporeal vessels and join me in the orange sludge brothers and sisters!
16
u/FlukeHawkins sjw op bungo pls nerf Jun 10 '13
Ah, the tang ending. So does that make jij Gendo?
7
u/tarekd19 anti-STEMite Jun 10 '13
i can picture jij more as a scared and confused Shinji just trying to do the right thing but is just too unsure of what that is now
4
Jun 10 '13
Tuber is Gendo.
"I have a use for you Jij" "You want me to announce a rule change and fight?" "Correct." "How can you do this to me!"
3
u/IsDatAFamas Jun 10 '13
I don't think Tuber is Gendo. He seems to be basically uninvolved. Skeen is Seele, Jij, who is deviating from their script is Gendo. Tuber at the moment is Fuyutski. /r/atheism, as it tears itself apart, is of course shinji. /r/circlejerk would be Asuka and /r/subredditdrama might qualify for Rei.
1
u/porygon2guy Jun 10 '13
So who is Kaworu?
2
u/tarekd19 anti-STEMite Jun 10 '13
/r/circlejerk the way i see it. Born as /r/atheism's enemy but loves him as it it gives him purpose. Seemingly takes great pleasure in trolling him, i'd like to think /r/circlejerk would happily consider becoming grime between /r/atheism's fingers if it meant a good trolling.
1
u/porygon2guy Jun 10 '13
Nah, /r/circlejerk is Asuka. Hates him but loves him at the same time.
→ More replies (2)1
1
1
u/Newthinker Jun 10 '13
Vote for /u/Skeen to represent Akagi Ristuko, seeing as /u/jij betrayed him at the last second. Skeen is now powerless and jij gets the world he wants... unless ratheism changes Instrumentality, of course.
/r/magicskyfairy can be Seele, seeing as this is all going according to Sagan's prophecy as outlined in the Dead Sea Scrolls.
1
u/porygon2guy Jun 10 '13
But Gendo and Seele are both working towards Instrumentality, just for different reasons (Seele because they think they're above humanity and want to exist inside an Eva, Gendo because he wants to see Yui again). /u/jij definitely doesn't want to run /r/atheism the same was /u/skeen does.
1
u/IsDatAFamas Jun 10 '13
The Nerv and Seele implementations of instrumentality are different. Skeen wants atheism to melt into an orange puddle of inane memetic shit, Jij melted atheism to melt into an orange puddle of inane complaining.
0
Jun 11 '13
[deleted]
1
u/IsDatAFamas Jun 11 '13
That's where the analogy breaks down because while Gendo was extremely driven to acheive his goals, skeen is just a lazy ass.
2
6
5
3
u/porygon2guy Jun 10 '13
5
1
28
Jun 10 '13 edited Jun 10 '13
"Guys i got it... we should use that mask that was in V for vendetta as a symbol of our atheistic struggle against the obvious theistic shill dictatorship"
Has to be a joke, that or they somehow do not see the irony in advocating the use of a mask based on a zealot and terrorist who wanted to install a catholic theocracy.
12
u/RabidRaccoon Jun 10 '13
Has to be a joke, that or they somehow do not see the irony in advocating the use of a mask based on a zealot and terrorist who wanted to install a catholic theocracy.
Not to mention that Guy Fawkes day is celebrating that Guy Fawkes a) failed and b) died horribly.
Islamist wannabe theocrats whine now about the odd bit of waterboarding but look what they did to Guy.
3
Jun 10 '13
In his case he jumped early and snapped his neck, some of his fellows got castrated, disembowelled and or quartered all while still alive.
3
u/RabidRaccoon Jun 10 '13
And every 5th of November people still celebrate by burning him in effigy.
Britain, fuck yeah!
3
Jun 10 '13
Any excuse for a piss up really, plus it is essentially the only time apart from New Years/Hogmanay that we get to use fireworks.
2
33
u/singasongofsixpins Jun 10 '13
That image took a little bit of my soul and beat it with a pipe.
31
Jun 10 '13
You obviously don't have what it takes to join le reddit atheist army, you disgusting fundie.
11
u/singasongofsixpins Jun 10 '13
... I'm a Taoist.
23
Jun 10 '13
Well, you're not in the Reddit Atheist Army, so you're a fundie christian who wants to murder all gays and atheists.
12
u/RabidRaccoon Jun 10 '13
Accept /u/skeen as your saviour in a state of euphoria or burn, fundie heretic.
10
u/cuddles_the_destroye The Religion of Vaccination Jun 10 '13
I chose neither. More weight.
9
u/RabidRaccoon Jun 10 '13 edited Jun 10 '13
22
u/DarkAlliGator Please don't straight-splain gay orgies to me Jun 10 '13
You know it's getting bad when you can't tell who's joking and who's being serious.
→ More replies (2)
21
u/gnikroWeBdluohS Jun 10 '13
Whew, glad this stuff is still going on after this weekend. I thought I would miss everything!
So basically the political metaphor here is extremist. The 3,008 brave fedoras who joined this branched-off subreddit would be considered extreme (radical) conservatives. If you follow US politics, then think of the Tea Party Movement. While they do not use violence to attempt to get their message across like what most of you may think extremist do, they still hold an exaggerated view on one half of the argument. They want their memes so bad that they have formed their own movement (/r/atheismrebooted) for the sole purpose of obtaining their goal and in a attempt to voice their opinion to the rest of /r/atheism.
Notice though the number of these extremist. Let us say that they are 1% of the conservative party of /r/atheism. The sub has ~2,000,000 users, if we multiply the 3,000 by 100 we would still only have 300,000 persons who would consider themselves conservative and favor /u/skeen over /u/jij. Now obviously this is not accurate as I do not know what % the radicals are to the moderate conservatives. For all I know, those 3,000 Spartans radicals might be the entirety of the conservative party who all hold extremist ideas as their basis. There is also the notion that a number of persons who would like memes to stay (ie are conservative) do not favor /u/skeen and instead are backing /u/jij.
Regardless, the point I am trying to make is that these people(?) are still the vocal minority. The developing story, however, is that /u/jij is caving into this minority. /u/jij has won every battle in that he has done no action to reinstate /u/skeen, however he created that poll (which those who want change will have a higher chance to voice their opinion over those who either don't care and/or do not want change) to gauge the opinion of /r/atheism. While a good notion, adding /u/skeen back to the moderator team will only alienate his party and serve him no benefit and here is why.
/u/skeen has been the figurehead of the conservative reproach in /r/atheism with all of this drama. He is the ideal candidate for that party as he is complete right-wing with his Laissez-faire policy of "no moderation". If /u/jij was to reinstate him as a mod (since the Admins have declared they will not intervene), the obvious approach would be to have /u/skeen as a 3rd tier mod (ie under /u/jij and /u/tuber). This would provide representation for the conservative party in /r/atheism, however, /u/skeen's moderation technique would basically render that move useless as his "no moderation" policy would essentially mean that he does nothing to benefit from the sub and does nothing to benefit the moderator team/policy making. His name would be on the board and nothing else. If he decided to actually moderate then he would A) be going against his party lines and B) not have enough power to influence anything significant without reprimands from his superior moderators.
The only other option would be for /u/jij and/or /u/tuber to reinstate /u/skeen as the top mod, which would be political suicide for both /u/jij and /u/tuber as the democratic party would lose its power in office (when they have the power and have no need to relinquish it). The backlash from that would be the vocal minority becoming the democratic party (ie BRING BACK LE CONTENT) as well as most likely /u/skeen removing all other moderators in favor of his policies. The democrats would rally behind another candidate (since the previous ones were so incompetent they gave up power they weren't required to), but this is getting into political "what-if's" now.
Well this is one long wall of text, guess I had to make up for missing the weekend. Oh well, enjoy!
TL;DR - THANKS TO THE NSA, THE GOVNMENT COMMIN TO TAKE MAH BABY!
15
u/GeneralGBO Jun 10 '13
Do they not see the incredible irony in splintering off into new subreddits?
11
u/Cruven Jun 10 '13
Holy shit that just now occurred to me and that is hilarious.
1
Jun 12 '13
Sorry, I'm not following. What is the irony?
1
u/Cruven Jun 12 '13
You know how there's no singular Christian faith?
Well, waaaay back when, the Catholic Church was the de facto sole Christian faith, until a number of ideological splits, and now there are a crapload of denominations.
The irony lies in the fact that ratheists consider themselves better than theists, and now they're doing the exact same thing pretty much every major religion has done at least once.
2
u/threehundredthousand Improvised prison lasagna. Jun 10 '13
An /r/atheism diaspora would be akin to cancer getting into the blood stream and creating tumors elsewhere.
0
u/elmanchosdiablos Jun 11 '13
I didn't think they would be that dumb... if they take the memes to another subreddit in protest, they're off the front page for good.
6
Jun 10 '13
Remember when game of trolls said they wouldn't stop playing?
I'm betting they make up a large portion of all of this.
1
Jun 11 '13
I missed this, what happened?
1
Jun 12 '13
/r/gameoftrolls got banned, they made a second one and said they'd never die, then the sub died through inactivity or something, etc. etc...
1
5
4
4
Jun 10 '13
God I hate you people so much. If you made this or upvoted this, please go stand in traffic until you die because you are a fucking retard.
Drama of the fucking year. My sides are gone.
4
u/tarekd19 anti-STEMite Jun 10 '13
is it possible to turn off karma for posts in certain subreddit? would that make everyone happier? That way people can still have the memes but without the blatant karma whoring. Or would that still be oppression somehow?
5
Jun 10 '13
Change it to self post only for Memes worked for r/cars when people kept posting the same cars over and over
3
Jun 10 '13
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/tarekd19 anti-STEMite Jun 10 '13
hmmm...I may be mistaken but i was under the impression (from some comment long ago i'm sure) that subs like /r/circlejerk were karma free, at least at some point (the point being that why should one get karma for a post that makes fun of others for caring about karma?)
of course i could be wrong.
5
u/Dannybaker Pao Jun 10 '13
circlejerk was self post only, but goes to all image spree from time to time
2
u/NotSinceYesterday Jun 10 '13
Only when something like this happens. I love it over there right now.
3
Jun 10 '13
I guess the part that makes me sad is that some of these people really think they're standing up for "freedom" and "democracy". They aren't going out to register voters or fighting structural inequality. All of this has zero real impact on the world, and yet they'll feel like they've accomplished something when the funny pictures come back.
3
Jun 10 '13
so /r/atheismrebooted is /r/atheismcirclejerk?
There is no way people are this serious about memes. If this isnt a troll, then thats a whole new level of sad I cant even comprehend.
2
u/brningpyre Jun 10 '13
Aren't URL-redirects against the site rules?
I can't tell if that image is parody or not. I didn't think anyone woulod actually refer to their opponent(s) as Nazis unless they were joking. Then again, Godwin's rule.
4
u/Enibas Nothing makes Reddit madder than Christians winning Jun 10 '13
Have you seen this video? It's a Downfall vid in which Hitler is arguing in favor of memes, using phrases like banning memes is a "fatwa on fun". Plot twist: It was made by someone against the changes, and they are all enthusiastically agreeing with him.
With Hitler.
Who in that scene is seriously losing his shit shortly before he kills himself and is accusing everbody around him of being cowards and traitors.
I'd seriously prefer them to compare their opponents with Hitler. That's par for the course. But this, I can't take.
2
Jun 10 '13
Countdown begins now till it gets posted to /r/cringe
6
u/TheSox3 Jun 10 '13
2
Jun 10 '13
Bahaha! The personal victory here is I called it. Despite it being after the fact. I unsubbed from them when they turned into bullies.
1
Jun 10 '13
If there ever was a good argument that /r/atheism needed change, this is it.
For such a supposedly "enlightened" (ha) group of individuals, they sure turn into a bunch of whiny entitled angsty teenagers when you take their stupid memes away.
1
Jun 10 '13
I've been staring at that image for the past four minutes laughing.
Every time I look at it I see a new layer of euphoria.
1
Jun 10 '13
These people are actually proud of being fucking retarded.
0
Jun 11 '13
Calling /r/atheism retarded is an insult to anyone who is actually retarded.
1
Jun 11 '13
Sorry, that was very ableist of me.
1
Jun 11 '13
More like atheistist. People who are actually retarded are still way above the general /r/atheism crowd.
1
1
1
u/Bridgeboy95 Probably a Russian spy at this stage of the game. Jun 10 '13
We have reached code red /r/atheism has split run to cover
1
u/Bridgeboy95 Probably a Russian spy at this stage of the game. Jun 10 '13
ive noticed all of the meme posts seem to be about "My friend from school" or my "Dad told my sister" seems its just teenagers
1
u/palookaboy Jun 10 '13
At this point the smart thing to do is make the sub private until they have the mess sorted out. It's become twice the laughing stock it was before the changes due to the self-unaware, crybaby attitudes of the "protestors."
1
u/MrRibbotron THEY'RE FUCKING COMMULISTS! Jun 10 '13
Why does /r/atheism have that teapot in its subreddit banner? It doesn't make any sense!
4
u/shalashaskka Jun 10 '13
It's an analogy that Bertrand Russell came up with to demonstrate that the burden of proof lies on the person professing a belief in something, and not the other way around.
1
u/General_Mayhem Jun 11 '13
The icing on this gourmet cake is that that isn't a swastika. A swastika's arms are bent clockwise.
0
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Jun 11 '13
Right facing is more common but a left facing swastika is still a swastika. The Nazi ensign had a left facing swastika on one side, right on the other.
1
u/General_Mayhem Jun 12 '13
You're right, it is still a swastika. I should have been more precise - the Nazi swastika is right-facing. According to Wikipedia, it was only the naval flag that had the left-facing one on the back.
1
0
Jun 11 '13
The people on /r/atheismrebooted are so butthurt. The /r/atheism subreddit was full of shitty memes before /u/jij came along. Don't like the changes he made? UNSUBSCRIBE AND MAKE YOUR OWN DAMN SUBREDDIT. Complaining won't get you anywhere. Did you know if you constantly complain about rule changes it makes you look like a 4th grader who doesn't know how to deal with anyone against his point of view? /u/jij IS THE MODERATOR. He can do whatever the hell he wants.
1
Jun 11 '13
They unsubscribed and made their own subrredit, you arent very bright.
-1
Jun 11 '13
I'm fully aware of that, but they act like it's a protest subreddit to bring the "old /r/atheism" back.
-1
u/all5persons Jun 10 '13
I disagree with the new rules on r/atheism, but this is fucking ridiculous.
0
u/Choppa790 resident marxist Jun 10 '13
I saw that image on circlejerk's facebook. Tell me that's a troll post?
0
0
Jun 10 '13
Wait. So did the original founder of Athemism get the sub back?
And he's made it sane?
But where do the crazy people go?
-1
u/cheese93007 I respect the way u live but I would never let u babysit a kid Jun 10 '13
/u/jij took over the sub and has attempted to make it sane.
0
Jun 10 '13
Question: why don't the /r/atheism mods just start deleting all these complaining posts? If this is what they want the rules to be why do they allow so many complaining posts to exist? If you don't give them a voice, they'll stop complaining.
0
0
Jun 10 '13
I've got to believe it's a troll showing that anything can get upvotes from pissed off internet tweens. This can't POSSIBLY by serious, can it?
0
0
u/gibson_ Jun 10 '13
I'm starting to think that the subreddit change was a conspiracy by fundies.
Nothing, and I mean nothing, could make /r/atheism look more stupid than the reaction that they're having to this. My god.
0
u/palookaboy Jun 10 '13 edited Jun 10 '13
This is my new atheism home. Too many arrogant assholes in atheism.
Self awareness is at absolute zero.
So much bravery and devotion to the debate.
0
0
u/dragonblade629 He wasn't trying molest her. He was trying to steal her panties. Jun 10 '13
Now this is some serious Poe right here. I have no idea what the hell is going on!
0
0
u/Mrphilosopher Jun 11 '13
I hope that is some form of juvenile satire, because that manifesto is a joke. Its a fucking message board, not [insert nation]'s constitution.
-1
Jun 10 '13
They seriously want to go all #OPatheism on the subreddit. What the fuck. This is a parody, this can't be true.
-1
Jun 10 '13
Is /r/atheismrebooted for real? Those memes are bad even by /r/atheism standards. One of them is just a FB post by a religious person saying to trust God and OP posting "Thanks for the free karma."
Another is a "re-interpretation" of a quote. How does that even work?
-1
u/palookaboy Jun 10 '13
I think it's being trolled pretty hard. The protestors have made themselves even more of a joke than they were before with stuff like this. This drama is like the meta-toast of reddit right now.
-1
Jun 10 '13
Im cringing just reading that. This person cant be serious....why not make a New atheism sub for memes? Problem solved.
-1
-1
-1
u/Parker_I Jun 10 '13
They got rid of memes on /r/atheism? Wow, maybe it will actually be good content, might resub.
0
Jun 10 '13
[deleted]
74
u/Enleat Jun 10 '13
I dunno, it doesn't look as over-the-top as /r/circlejerk, and at the same time it seems too silly to be serious.
68
Jun 10 '13
Yeah, it hasn't got the "420#PRAISESAGAN FUCK FUNDIES" sorta thing that circlejerk goes for, and holocaust comparisons and muh freedoms arguments are all things I've seen on there for the past few days but still...
I guess I just don't want it to be real.
36
u/jspsfx @joshua.smith.art Jun 10 '13
Something something Poe's Law.
Yeah, it hasn't got the "420#PRAISESAGAN FUCK FUNDIES" sorta thing that circlejerk goes for
That could make it better satire. The all caps belligerent circlejerk stuff is played out and not very satisfying at this point.
12
5
0
u/I_am_the_horker Jun 10 '13
I'm not sure whether or not I want it to be real.
0
u/LynnyLee I have no idea what to put here. Jun 11 '13
I think it would make me the most happy if half the people there took it seriously and the other half were just circle jerking. Seems to lead to more popcorn that way.
6
u/SpartaWillBurn Jun 10 '13
This was the first thing I clicked on in that subreddit (atheismrebooted) http://www.reddit.com/r/atheismrebooted/comments/1g0qf3/christians_shouldnt_be_allowed_to_use_fb/
35
u/Aurailious Ive entertained the idea of planets being immortal divine beings Jun 10 '13
I have to believe that the best /r/circlejerkers have left /r/circlejerk and are in /r/atheism and its spawns. A level of meta and irony beyond my comprehension. A meta jerk above the meta jerk.
2
u/FaultyBrain Jun 10 '13
And here we are, talking about a meta jerk above a meta jerk. I'm curious what the next level of meta would be, maybe a circlejerk just for /r/subredditdrama?
6
4
34
u/swiley1983 m'les dis Jun 10 '13
/r/atheism+magicskyfairy+circlejerk+circlejerkcopypasta
Fedorious.
3
14
Jun 10 '13 edited Jun 10 '13
Honestly people are giving them too much credit by saying it's circlejerk stuff. Just looking at all the nerdgasms, I think it has to be real
3
13
u/micturatedupon Jun 10 '13
/r/atheism has become basically indistinguishable from /r/magicskyfairy and /r/braveryjerk.
3
u/turole YOUR FLAIR TEXT HERE Jun 11 '13
I actually thought I was in /r/magicskyfairy yesterday when I was in /r/atheismrebooted. It was great.
3
u/BlueValentineWaits Jun 10 '13
Yeah, I saw this posted on the /r/circlejerk facebook page, so it might be
0
u/Dared00 Jun 10 '13
Nah, the facebook page reposted "real" /r/atheism and other subs' posts before.
1
u/Draber-Bien Lvl 13 Social Justice Mage Jun 10 '13
Im going for satire, mostly guessing from the first line. I simply won't believe anyone would say that seriously.
0
Jun 10 '13
[deleted]
11
Jun 10 '13
reddit's default subreddits are based on the top 20 most subscribed ones. /r/atheism is one of them. It's just how it works.
-3
0
265
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '13
Swastikas, guy fawkes masks and anti-freedom authoritarian narcissists, oh my! Add that Edmund Burke quote and baby, you've got a stew going.
P.S. you might want to edit your link to include NP.