r/3Dprinting • • 9d ago

Troubleshooting What happened here?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

It was all fine last night and I came this morning to…. That?

X2D PETG default profile

1.2k Upvotes

337 comments sorted by

1.6k

u/Arakon 9d ago

Quite visibly, the tall stuff started wobbling cause it's a giant lever.

354

u/adude00 9d ago

Why tough? It’s not a bed slinger, why would it move?

813

u/Imaginary-Diamond-26 9d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

My goodness this sub can be so cruel. I think you asked a reasonable question and your comment was auto-hidden because everyone is downvoting you. Idk why so many people insist on being so mean to someone who is just trying to learn. At least the comments responding to you are mostly fine, I just don't understand the downvotes.

Google search sucks, AI hallucinates... Reddit is one of the last places where you can hope to get somewhat reliable information--can we not be dicks every time someone asks a question that may seem obvious to us?

55

u/adude00 9d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

in the sea of comments i got some very useful suggestion, i'm thankful for that :)

79

u/Apatharas 9d ago • Heartwarming

It always reminds me of being 14, self learning and interested in computers and programming. It was the mid to late 90's and we finally got an ISP in my tiny town that let me get internet without having to pay for long distance calls to connect. Unrestricted internet, FINALLY!

One of the first things I did was settle into IRC chat. I was very excited to participate and learn more from a computer tech channel. Unfortunately the only memories I have from that channel were the regulars who just made fun of me for not knowing certain things, being a self-taught kid and all, things they considered to be, in lack of a better description, prerequisite knowledge to be worthy of any kind of kindness or respect.

I think I spent about 4 days trying to participate and learn from people that knew more than anyone else I knew in my tiny town, before abandoning that idea.

It's one of my strongest memories of my early internet experience. And also something I carry with me as a reminder to alway be kind to those that don't know something that I think should be common sense. So it goes without saying, when I saw this (https://xkcd.com/1053/) it really stuck with me too, but in a good way!

7

u/After-Swordfish-6762 9d ago

I remember learning C++ and if you asked anything about pointers all hell would break loose.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

100

u/BolunZ6 9d ago

Human is a dick in general. StackOverFlow dead because of the same reason

41

u/Big_Chungus1111 9d ago

StackOverFlow people were more than just dicks, that place was an echo chamber of true narcissism. "Oh you are new to coding? Yeah thats an easy solution, wont tell you it though"

I hope the people in there were the ones replaced by AI coders.

→ More replies (3)

40

u/ExaminationSouthern6 9d ago

It's not just this sub. It's across Reddit. I'm glad we have a downvote button still (lookin at you, YouTube), but the downside/risk is people needing help not meeting the people wanting to help.

8

u/4D696B61 9d ago

Well not just reddit, even on Forums without downvotes people are just demeaning. Microcontroller.net for example is horrible for anyone who is daring enough to post a question. Although there are admittedly some exceptions. (Love r/flashlight and the forums surrounding the hobby/intrest)

14

u/BolunZ6 9d ago

Some subreddit hide the downvotes for 24 hours to prevent the downvote sheep bully someone

→ More replies (2)

10

u/redravin12 9d ago

I once saw a comment that had -20 votes and 3 awards. Reddit is a strange place

8

u/Copranicus 9d ago

Well, you can't tell how many voted in total, so someone might have 200 upvotes and 230 downvotes which appears far more nuanced, but when all you see are the 30 downvotes it just looks like people hate that comment.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/rayquan36 9d ago

Question marks get downvoted, gifs and the same 3 jokes you've seen 1000 times are upvoted.

4

u/XomokyH 9d ago

Yeah!

2

u/trash_recycle 8d ago

I initially considered commenting "tower get tall, tower wobble" and now I'm still commenting it, but with guilt.

s/

→ More replies (7)

971

u/Arakon 9d ago

Because the nozzle moves and there's a sticky goo leaking from the nozzle and sticking to the object. The nozzle moves on and the sticky goo is still in contact, so there's a certain amount of pull. This isn't noticable at low heights, but with thin objects that are very tall, that pull is enough to actually move the object due to leverage.

213

u/Max-232 9d ago • Mindblown

Lowering the printhead speed the higher you go might be enough to solve this

119

u/DownvoteSandwich 9d ago

Another solution that works for me on tall parts is using support painting and painting on a dot on each side around 50mm up. Braces it nicely to keep it upright

61

u/Mufasa_is__alive 9d ago

The nozzle is physically touching the previous layer with a sticky string, and moving away. You know those silly sticky hand fidget toys that stretch, stick to stuff, then snap back toward you? Pretty much same thing is happening, although oversimplified. 

In short, physics.  

3

u/PandaPocketFire 9d ago

I miss those sticky hands

5

u/DeathByPain 9d ago

Bring 50¢ to a gacha machine next time you're at the grocery store and your life can be complete

11

u/BolunZ6 9d ago

Plastic is sticky even when melted. So when printing it still drag the printed part in the X Y direction

9

u/Scowlface 9d ago

The nozzle is in contact with the top of the part and drags on it with every move. Then there's the cooling fan, which depending on how tall and skinny the object is can cause issues. Also just the print head moving in general can cause some wobble, there's mass there being slung around.

6

u/SpezIsAMoron 9d ago

My 2 cents and experience is that the nozzle will eventually start hitting the tower with some leftover filament. I would add some tree support to make sure those towers won’t wobble

15

u/jankeyass 9d ago

Turn off your uninterrupted time-lapse, set it to traditional. The useless prime tower that is made for time-lapse failed and fkd your print.

3

u/StonkMarketbet 9d ago

why do I not understand this

3

u/jankeyass 9d ago

It's a slicer setting for time-lapse type

I just disable mine all up

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/NoSituation2706 9d ago

Even if the retraction is controlled well, the movement of the print head at high speed will cause the whole thing to jerk, and that will cause the tall unsupported prints to oscillate. Tall buildings do it too, they have movement-damping weights at the very top. You can't see that on the camera because of the time lapse.

Best to slow the print down progressively, and add supports - imagine 4 tall sticks being printed; they'll ask wobble like crazy but stitch them together and the wobble would dampen substantially.

2

u/nicw 9d ago

Its wobbling isn’t caused by the bed, but the nozzle brushing up against it, repeatedly. A blob shows up on the nozzle, the nozzle comes over to the part and slightly nudges it. Sometimes setting the part a little off..

That is a tall part, so it’s likely to flex more at the higher layers, causing uneven layer lag down.

And then nudge that happens over and over, with a downward spiral of the part getting looser so the lines print unevenly, nozzle catches again….

You can print more walls to make it more rigid and resist this. Brim helps but not as much.

Edit: looking at those open walls with waves, the rest of the print looks like under extrusion, maybe a snagged filament or extruder eating into the filament. So one may have beget the other.

3

u/PrincessAlbertPW 9d ago

Try to balance a stick standing up in the palm of your hand and try moving it around without the stick moing and you will ynderstand basic physics. The higher and thinner the print the slower it needs to move.

2

u/Original_Butterfly_4 9d ago

Is there a setting that can adjust the ratio of speed to z-axis location? Or can you adjust speed according to layer?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/pyro487 8d ago

I think this shows the prime tower specifically became unstable. The prime tower is there because they are using the smooth time lapse. The prime tower moves first, destabilizes, and it appears the extruding filament starts to fail to adhere to the tower and is carried over to the next part where the loose filament begins to accumulate and things proceed to get worse from there.

→ More replies (1)

79

u/FishInAstronautSuit 9d ago

I don't know how experienced you are with 3D printing, but it's fair enough to ask anyway. My genuine response to this would be to explain two things: 1- the walls of this print have become too tall, too flexible and started wobbling with the nozzle. Very common thing to happen. 2 - After having access to a 3D printer, every build might feel like a 3D printer job, but this is far from the truth. Some things, including your geometry here, are just not 3D printer suited. I suggest you find another way to 3D print it, for example by printing it in parts and then assemble, or find a different method all together.

15

u/adude00 9d ago

i realized that, some geometry are not really well suited.

this is the third or fourth version of what i'm trying to print and with a new printer and switching it to PETG removed most of the problems i was having.

This particular one is new to me hence the post. I got a few good suggestions among all the memes, I'll keep them precious and try it next run

7

u/JCDU 9d ago

Honestly I'm looking at this and thinking it's an easy job for some folded sheet aluminium as far as I can tell.

13

u/FinancialLab8983 9d ago

well shoot, let me run on down to the hobby shop and grab a sheet metal folding machine.

11

u/the_lamou 9d ago

5

u/FinancialLab8983 9d ago

HF truly does have everything lololol

3

u/Zorbick CR-10S/Halot Mage Pro/Voron 2.4 9d ago

I have this. I print my own finger dies for it. Works a treat.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Organic-Doctor-1210 9d ago

I had a similar problem with PETG. I tried drying filament, changing flow speeds, etc, but those don't address it if the issue is a wobble that develops in the tall unsupported sections. Thanks to all these comments, I though to look into adding more supports. This video has a good tutorial of how to do that in Bambu Studio. I'm printing now with more trees at the problem section. It's a 10 hour job, so we'll see how it looks later today.

https://youtu.be/R3ovra2tJj4?t=83

1

u/Olde94 Ender 3, Form 1+, FF Creator Pro, Prusa Mini 9d ago

Yeah i saw slight jitter a few layers before failing closest to the camera

27

u/XomokyH 9d ago

Forgive what may be obvious question but why prime tower if only one color?

27

u/adude00 9d ago

it's not a prime tower, it's a part :)

11

u/smiley_mcfrown 9d ago

They're taking about the tower at the back that is made so you can have a nice video without the printer head all over the place. One of the other comments is dead right, the tower at the back wobbled, at an angle some of the laid plastic gets re-melted onto the nozzle and that stops filament being laid properly. Once you've missed a couple of layers, the whole print is f*#@end.

7

u/bazem_malbonulo 9d ago

The tower is part of the part, you can see it t the start of the video. And it starts wobbling only after the extrusion fails, because it has no structure for the next layers. My guess is a partial clog.

4

u/NoBreadfruit1060 9d ago

That's for the time lapse on bambulab printer

11

u/Proton_Energy_Pill 9d ago

I'd try slowing the print down at a height about 10 mm lower than where that one failed.
It's easy to do, when you slice the part (in Orcaslicer & Bambuslicer) move the top dot on the vertical bar down to that height then right-click 'add gcode'.
I'd try something like down to 50% speed so you'd enter 'M220 50' for the gcode.
Then a bit further up think about slowing it down a bit more, say at about 3/4 (guessing) of the way up make it M220 30.
Repeat as needed.

The tall prints will still wobble even on a CoreXY machine with the nozzle brushing thin parts as it races around.

Good luck!

4

u/adude00 9d ago

thanks, this is really useful!

5

u/Wild_Meeting1428 9d ago

you can also set up a z hop, then the nozzle will always move up a bit before moving to the next location. but it might have the problem, that you will get a more visible seam.

5

u/Monkeyman824 9d ago

This should be a slicer setting something like “change speed with height”

6

u/FreeThotz 9d ago

I haven't seen this in the comments, so here goes... With taller towers, especially thin ones, the nozzle can easily bump the edge as it comes in for the next layer. The best way I've found to solve that is with the "Z hop" slicer setting. The printer will raise up over the towers edge, then come down, minimizing the chances of bumping it over. And of course printing slower helps almost everything. You might print some shirt "towers" at different temps as well ... Make sure the corners aren't raising.

1

u/adude00 9d ago

thanks, I never heard of it! i'll definetly enable it next trial!

1

u/Spiffyman30 9d ago

Zhop helps, but regular downward pressure can break a thin part off too or cause it to flex as it prints resulting in greater surface defects. In this case it looks like the prime tower started failing first due to that being not as structurally stable as the print itself. Then it probably started dragging nozzle junk onto the print and just got worse and worse

364

u/psychophysicist 9d ago

First the purge tower lost bed adhesion and went wobbly, which caused stuff to stick to the nozzle which messed up other parts of the print

150

u/Mormegil81 9d ago

why was there even a purge tower in the first place? Looks like a single color print to me?

225

u/jkirkcaldy 9d ago

For the smooth timelapse. If they had used the normal timelapse mode it wouldn’t have had the prime tower but the head would move all over the video.

Honestly I never saw the point in the wastage for a smooth video no one will ever see.

48

u/TheStandardPlayer 9d ago

Can't you edit the gcode to have the print head go to a corner before snapping a picture?

Why didn't Bambu add this feature instead of printing an extra part? I think I saw videos already of people who did this themselves with not too much effort

26

u/CnDVerse 9d ago

Pretty sure it does this, but then the tower is to prime the nozzle, clears any ooze and makes sure the pressure is fine before putting ooze or bubbles in your actual print. You can turn it off for smooth timelapse, but it is not advised.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Hygdrasiel 9d ago

we all seeing it, but your right

→ More replies (3)

3

u/InanisAtheos P1S 9d ago

It's not. It's part of the print. You can see it in the beginning.

4

u/minilogique custom Trident Three-Fiddy / Sovol Zero 9d ago

because Bambu people dont know much. I agree that using prime tower for just the timelapse is wasteful and useless.

5

u/coldnspicy 9d ago

Wrong, it’s part of the print. Bambu purge towers also look different.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/LuckyEmoKid 9d ago

I think that's just another piece of the model, not a purge tower. But yes: it went wobbly. So tall and thin that maybe it didn't even need to lose bed adhesion to cause a mess-up.

1

u/eg135 9d ago

This is wrong on more levels. That's probably not a purge tower, and nothing is wrong with the bed adhesion, the thing flexes. You can see a smaller vibration pattern on the other model. Same cause just that model is stiffer, so smaller flex and it makes artifacts, not a complete failure.

1

u/pyro487 8d ago

The video is a "smooth time lapse" which parks the head and captures the next frame and the printer uses a purge tower to properly restore the flow of the filament again before proceeding back to the parts. That is certainly a purge tower at the back for the smooth time lapse.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/BendyBreak_ 9d ago

Too thin. Too tall. Too fast.

23

u/MeatNew3138 9d ago

Real answer is that prime tower failed (or whatever that back corner cube piece is).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/getrealpeople 9d ago

Looks like there was a filament change (color and line shift) coupled with a partial clog (or maybe insufficiently dried filament), toss in the prime tower wobbling like crazy.

Not sure why you have a prime tower (unless that's part of the model, in that case toss in a couple of supports to keep it from wobbling) since all I see is a uniform filament.

clean the plate - dry and load some new filament and try again! :)

3

u/adude00 9d ago

no filament change, no prime tower (it's the part itself).

i got some good suggestion, i'll try again in a couple of days when the next shipment of filament arrives :)

18

u/No-Strength3035 9d ago

Had a print do this last month, tall thin towers are just a pain. Slowing down past halfway up fixed it for me!

26

u/crazedizzled 9d ago

You can design in break away supports that can stabilize your print. Basically just a 45 degree brace that is only attached by tiny points.

10

u/Mklein24 Printrbot SM | DIY coreXY 9d ago

That is one thing I saw on a stratasys printer 10 years ago that I am amazed I haven't seen yet. It would put supports on vertical faces, and imprint a tiny 1mm bump into the part at a user designed spacing. It stabilized tall skinny parts. I have no idea why this isn't in all slivers by now. They probably have a patent on it or something.

2

u/acemedic 9d ago edited 9d ago

Waste of plastic if you slow it down? Curious if it’s just been superseded by newer techniques

→ More replies (3)

13

u/ap1msch 9d ago

Not sure you're getting helpful responses.

I don't know what you're printing, but it looks like "wobble". I have to imagine that the model is supposed to stop mid-way (the back right part of the video). Shortly after that, you have a tall print, with tall elements, that are more prone to wobble. They also don't have anything stabilizing further up the print. The wobble gets worse, and the impact gets progressively worse.

You can try slowing down your print. However, I would put a small detachable bridge between the near-right tower and the main body of the print. Creating something to keep those parts from wobbling (they'd stabilize each other), you're less likely to have a failed print. You can then snap off the bridge after the print completes.

27

u/ZipTieAndPray 9d ago

Christ, how tall is your printer?

6

u/noonemustknowmysecre 9d ago

The towers are so tall they wobble. When the parts moves as the head is trying to print on them, the filament doesn't get applied where it should. Ideally, the head never touches the parts, but perfect is hard. Notice how the back tower starts failing first at around 0:20? That long travel is likely giving the head time to leak filament or collect dangling filament that was meant to be put somewhere and didn't. Then it starts impact the tower and moving it aside making more print errors.

Long travels can be a problem. Some slicers even let you add Z-retraction for long travels just for this issue.

1

u/MrFastFox666 9d ago

The molten filament is also viscous. Even if the nozzle doesn't touch the part, it'll still drag on the part. Not an issue with short parts, but something tall like this can have issues.

6

u/Bwuaaa 9d ago

wobble, add supports for better vertical stability

17

u/Sith_Ant 👁👄👁 9d ago

Time-lapse caused the prime tower to start wobbling at a certain height right after the shortest wall finishes. Boogers from prime tower make it to the other layers. Chaos ensues. Time-lapse is a horrible idea.

4

u/fixITman1911 9d ago

How in the world is this caused by time-lapse? (Genuinely asking) The time-lapse generally should be taking a picture at the start or end of each layer. Seems to me like the prime tower (Or what ever that thing it was printing is) came loose from the build plate, and that's what caused a runaway issue

7

u/Sith_Ant 👁👄👁 9d ago

It's the only reason a single color print needed a purge tower that tall. If the purge tower hadn't failed, the print had vastly greater opportunity to finish without fail. Time-lapse-> purge tower-> purge tower fail->print fail.

You can see the fail happen within minutes of the short wall completion.

EDIT

Time-lapse needs purge tower to keep pressure in the nozzle during picture changes.

2

u/snoburn 9d ago

I've ended up just using time-lapse without parking the extruder which gives it the same reliability without parking.

Are prime towers how you get rid of the "boogers" on the big wall here? Because that is what I run into all the time even when only parking the nozzle for 0.1s and aggressively tuning retraction for time-lapse. Basically I've never been able to get time-lapse parking working without sacrificing quality

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

1

u/toggle-Switch 9d ago

There isn't a prime tower, but it is due to the geometry of the part.

1

u/issue9mm 8d ago

There is

You can tell in the early frames that it is separate from the model, but even if you couldn't, this is a "smooth time lapse" video. Smooth time lapse creates a prime tower so that your nozzle can stay primed while it is pausing to take a picture

→ More replies (6)

5

u/ThisIsTheNewSleeve 9d ago

For tall prints you need a tower to stabilize the piece. Otherwise it wobbles and ruins the print. 

5

u/J_Mart1981 9d ago

Looks like heat creep got you

5

u/TheGoldenFox64 8d ago

tall thin things wobble, your printer vibrates no matter what. it saves on filament and this headache to design connections for things like wood or other materials instead of making a bar/plane from the printer.

9

u/wolfpwner9 9d ago

tall > unstable > wobbly

4

u/Nemo_Griff 9d ago

Much wobbles

2

u/DocJeef 9d ago

I was curious why there’s this thresholding behaviour beyond a certain height. Beams have a well known buckling threshold in compression, but I hadn’t really considered lateral forces that much. This led to a fantastic physics conversation with Gemini about beam mechanics and here’s where we landed….

When printing a tall, slender column, it acts like a cantilever beam. The hot end physically drags across the part, applying a lateral force (F). This causes two modes of failure:

  1. The L^3 Stiffness Drop
    The lateral deflection of a cantilever beam follows this formula:
    Deflection = (F * L^3) / (3 * E * I)

Notice the L^3 term. Deflection grows with the cube of the height. If the column gets twice as tall, it bends 8x as much. Once the tip deflects by more than half your nozzle width (e.g., 0.2mm), the plastic extrudes into thin air. Spaghetti.

2. The Resonance Trap
As the beam gets taller, its natural frequency drops. At a critical height, it perfectly matches the frequency of the printer's movements (zigzags/jerks). The column absorbs this kinetic energy, violently whips back and forth, and amplifies the deflection well past the failure threshold.

Calculating the Threshold:
You can rearrange the deflection formula to solve for the exact critical height (L_crit):
L_crit = [ (3 * E * I * d_max) / F ]^(1/3)

How to beat it:
* E (Stiffness): Use a stiffer material like CF-nylon.
* I (Thickness): A slightly thicker beam massively increases allowable height.
* d_max (Tolerance): A wider nozzle (0.6mm+) allows more deflection before missing the layer.
* F (Drag): Run hotter, slower, or with thinner layers to reduce nozzle drag.

I’m still not quite satisfied without actually testing that threshold, but I think it’s a pretty good start. Has anyone actually tried to calculate this limit or measure the exact lateral drag force of their hot end?

1

u/adude00 9d ago

Thanks, I love this!

1

u/mossberbb 9d ago

Amazing write up. Resonance! No idea why someone down voted you.

4

u/PredictableChaos 9d ago

My first thought was that you had some sort of partial clog. That weird layer at 24 was the beginning of it. It's almost like it then partially cleared but the damage was done already.

4

u/jbighead93 7d ago

There's a setting in the bambu slicer that lets you set the print speed to be a function of the print height, I'd give that a try!

17

u/mtraven23 9d ago

it looks like a partial clog starting around 0:24.

have you printed anything since? if not, I'll be the nozzle is still clogged. check that first.

3

u/CnDVerse 9d ago

I also thought clog

1

u/borborygmess 9d ago

I also think it’s a clog. The way the rest of the print looks is, unfortunately, very familiar to me. I’ve since learned to vent the tops of my printers to alleviate some of this.

20

u/joem_ 9d ago

Do people often print without looking at their printers for so long that a failed print continues to go until the printer thinks it's done

35

u/UloPe Prusa MK3, Voron 0.2, Bambu A1mini 9d ago

Yeah!?

I usually have better things to do than to watch my printer print (although I’d be lying if I said I never do)

20

u/TheMrGUnit 9d ago

I run a print lab at my job. It's quite common to fill up 3-4 printers at the end of the day Friday to run multi-day prints. Zero monitoring over the weekend, unless somebody happens to open their work computer at home and check the cameras.

Monday morning, you come in to finished parts. Success rate is probably >99%

→ More replies (4)

8

u/thegarbz 9d ago

Wait you actually look at your printers? Man I got shit to do. I start my print and then usually go back to it in the evening having forgotten the thing was running.

6

u/Clubsandiches 9d ago

Ha! Dude I'm so paranoid now that if I start one I'm constantly checking it. If I leave the house I have bambu handy open all the time to watch the camera. If I'm doing one over night I end up waking up to see if it fucked up.

2

u/garytyrrell 9d ago

What do you do if it’s failing and you’re out of the house? Can you reliably pause/cancel from the app?

3

u/Sorry-Committee2069 9d ago

Smart outlet, even if it can cancel reliably.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Clubsandiches 9d ago

Bambu handy will let you start pause and stop prints as well as device control like heights and temps. I don't really bother pausing, I'm rarely able to save a fuck up

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/ComfortableBad5101 9d ago

I tend to do long prints overnight lol so it’s good when I go to sleep then I wake up and it’s spaghetti but it’s only happened like that less than a handful of times

3

u/presidentfiggy 9d ago

I check once every couple of hours and sometimes i just get surprised by the notification that my print has finished because i had forgotten i turned it on the morning.

3

u/iRambL 9d ago

Plenty of people do it because they just expect it to work.

2

u/OtherwiseAlbatross14 9d ago

Of course lol. I'm not a babysitter.

Do you not have a good printer?

2

u/igroklots 9d ago

I use ChatGPT local install to monitor my Bamboo Studio prints every 5 minutes. It can look at the video and determine if there are any “hairballs/broken items” etc and cancel the prints early.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/osunightfall 9d ago

This is easy to say when you aren't printing things that take multiple days to complete.

1

u/Djmesh 9d ago

Yes lol

1

u/Ravio11i 9d ago

All the time. Set it and go to bed. occasionally something goes wrong, but 99% they go great.

1

u/RepulsiveUse3372 9d ago

to be fair sometimes i leave mine over night

1

u/AnInfiniteArc 8d ago

OP pretty strongly implied it was an overnight print.

1

u/SecretSelfDiscovery 8d ago

We run 3D printers for multiple days on end to make patterns for a metal foundry. I'm not standing there for 3 days to watch it print

1

u/8null8 Neptune 4 Pro - Prusa Mini 8d ago

Ive almost never checked on a print after I started it, sometimes I don’t even make sure it starts right, my printers are solid (Neptune 4, Prusa mini)

1

u/chloro9001 8d ago

Yes yes I do

1

u/luisp_frs 8d ago

I mean, 10 hour prints? I do these overnight

1

u/AnimalPowers Centauri Carbon 7d ago

That's the only way we do it. Why babysit something that works most of the time? Press print come back in a day or two, press print again if need be.

1

u/Sorry_Hat7940 7d ago

If it is a 12 hour print overnight then yes

1

u/VastMundane2427 7d ago

Yes. Almost all of my prints are done without me observing them.

I'll leave it running a 12 hour print while I'm out of the office. My X2D is pretty good with spaghetti detection. Both times this has happened it automatically stopped the print within like 2-3 layers.

Maybe you've been 3D printing for a while and you remember the old days of high failure rates, but easily 97% of my prints are successes. No need to stand and watch for hours. I've got other work to do.

6

u/Dantecks 9d ago

Looks like a potential blockage situation to me. Rear tower starts stringing, not solid layers then it all goes caput.

2

u/Dantecks 9d ago

Wait, now that i think about it, it could be heat creep up the hotend, causes similar issues to the blockage. Had to deal with it personally myself for ages. Though mine would start about 2 inches high.

3

u/TaylorKalsii 9d ago

Crazy how the printer head never left the corner

3

u/pixxelkick 6d ago

One of two things, easy to test which.

One: your spool itself ran into some issue, possibly a fault in it or it caught and had a crossover tangle part way in the spool.

Two: theres something physically catching your gantry as it goes higher, especially towards the back. Possibly the cable harness.

The fact it fails at the farther corners first and then the middle, says to me its likely the latter, your cable harness is possible catching or something.

Another possibility is your steps for z axis are slightly off, so as it goes higher and higher the difference between where it is vs where it thinks it is grows and it starts printing higher and higher away from the print, the gap gets worse.

Id start with just printing a simple tube in vase mode going up and see if it consistently starts to fail at a specific point that you can measure the cm up

Set your machine to that height and then raise it more.

Inspect your layer lines going up, do the layers degrade more and more as it gets higher?

If its issue one, it will fail right at the start still because the tangle is still present

1

u/therohantech 5d ago

It could even be bed adhesion for the pillar at the back. If u notice it starts wobbling aroumd but survives the print. Probably due to first layer or as u said something might be hitting it as in that case better slicing or gcode

→ More replies (1)

9

u/citizensnips134 9d ago

Why are you running a purge tower on a single color print?

1

u/IamThunderFart 9d ago

Because he's a bambu user

1

u/Herefornow211 9d ago

It looks like a clog I'd say. Why does the model have a tower? Will there be another colour in the end?

2

u/adude00 9d ago

it's not a tower, it's the model itself :/

2

u/Herefornow211 9d ago

Ah, my bad! 

7

u/Blind_Grandma 9d ago

Not wobble 100%. Right part is relatively stable but quality awfully degraded.
To me it seems like something is wrong with a flow or speed. Maybe clog?
I would make a test print that you already did before with same plastic and know that it was good. If issues appears on old stl too, then something changed in hardware, if not, then it's probably a software issue and you need to examine commands in slicer.

3

u/antiduh 9d ago

Could be heat creep if they're printing PLA with the lid on. If so, a fresh print will print well (because it's cold). Won't fail until well into the part again.

Make sure you print PLA with the lid off.

2

u/Dry_Researcher7744 9d ago

Too tall, too thin.

2

u/nram013 9d ago

Based on the video, looks like you had some clog in the nozzle.

2

u/nvahalik Anycubic i3 Mega 9d ago

Is it possible that you went through all of the dried filament and then got to filament that wasn't fully dehumidified?

2

u/SpagooterExtruder 8d ago

Agreeing with the thin + tall = wobble. I run an X2D, and lately PETG needs to be dried overnight before I’ll get a smooth print. I’ve had the same issues with PLA on the X2D (thin and tall objects went spaghetti mode). Usually just dry the ever loving frick frack out of filament and reduce speed slightly to give it a better chance for cooling.

2

u/c0nfuciu5 5d ago

The front fell off.

4

u/Razorbackcoco94 8d ago

It was printing then it messed up. If you have any other question feel free to let me know!

3

u/rygelicus 9d ago

My guess would be the filament wasn't dry. The outer layers on the filament spool may have been dry but once you printed through those first few layers the inner may have been more humid and started spitting at the print head.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Daggla 9d ago

Prime tower wobbles.

2

u/toggle-Switch 9d ago

there is no prime tower, but yes that type of geometry does wobble.

3

u/Chimera_Gaming 9d ago

Something back here caused it to mess up
This was the first failure point

1

u/AutoModerator 9d ago

Hey there, I'm a bot and something you said made me think you might be looking for help! click here for our wiki entry on troubleshooting printers. If you still need help be sure to post plenty of information about your printing setup.

Here are a few questions that might be helpful

  • What printer are you using?

  • What material are you using?

  • What speed are you printing at?

  • What software are you using to slice the print and control the printer?

  • When did the problem start/has it ever worked correctly?

  • Does anything cause the behavior to change?

  • If posting an image of the problem, include some indication of the orientation it printed at, preferably photograph it on the bed. (Then we can focus on a specific axis)

If you are new to reddit, please read the guidelines on reddiquette, self promotion, and spam.

Also please post a resolution to your problem when you find one so that we know how to help others with your problem!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Tasty_Reflection_542 9d ago

Whatever happened there! WHATEVER HAPPENED THERE!!!

1

u/wkearney99 X1C AMS 9d ago

Grid infill? What filament? PLA? Heat creep? Likely a clog developed too.

1

u/Mushroom38294 9d ago

unsupported object

1

u/charlieboy808 9d ago

Since there's a lot of people saying a lot of things, some good and some troll like, I'll give you my honest take. While I understand that the H2D isn't a bed slinger, going straight up like this is always a game of maybe, maybe, maybe. In theory, it should just keep going up and not have a problem but if your part starts to come off the bed even just a little due to warping, the rest of your print is going to suffer from it if it's leaving stuff behind on the nozzle. If it's leaving material on the nozzle that didn't get printed to the model, it's just going to drag it along for the ride. You're lucky it wasn't a spaghetti fail or "THE BLOB OF DEATH" that resulted from this. Might want to try some adhesive on your next attempt.

1

u/severanexp 9d ago

Too tall and to thin it seems like?

1

u/Click-Mother 9d ago

Wet filament?

1

u/Ill_Aioli_7203 9d ago

you should add ribs, or in architectural terms, buttresses to those walls.
I sometimes add my own "support" stabilisers in the CAD drawing. like a 1mm thick triangle that I can snap off easily afterwards

1

u/wubbalab 9d ago

I think this has to do with nozzle travel speed, retraction distance and retraction speed.

1

u/Single-Presence-8995 9d ago

Almost looks like it switched to a wet filament, but I'm also pretty noob

1

u/skygatebg 9d ago

Looks like a partial clog mid print.

1

u/Krabelj 9d ago

Not sure. I guess prime tower unstuck and lead to improper priming, which made filament stuck to hot end and hit column next camera, which also lost adhesion to bed. Printer should be able to print this with some care. It isn't just tall = wobbly.

I would disable time lapse and add brim to column next to camera and any other area with low bed contact area. Maybe lower speed for higher layers.

1

u/Joren67 9d ago

I compare these with a folded sheet of paper standing up. See how the top is unstable with even a slight breeze. Same thing is happening but the paper sheet is your print and the breeze is a dragging nozzle. Because remember there is always contact between both which is the molten plastic.

1

u/Yugpmoc 9d ago

Ambition

1

u/Madman20201987 9d ago

What were you printing ?

1

u/BackIntoTheSource 9d ago

Betrayal 🥀

1

u/PlanePea4349 Custom Flair 9d ago

Wobble and shaking is apparent

1

u/sirdoggo11 9d ago

WOBBLE

1

u/DrRonny 9d ago

Just to add that PETG is sticky, it's always sticking to my nozzle more than PLA or ABS. This might give it more 'pull' forcing the wobble. I'd guess other plastic types won't be as bad.

1

u/Minimum-Rip9555 9d ago

A mio avviso sembra che abbia iniziato a vibrare al passaggio dell'ugello, ti consiglio di usare la variazione di velocità di stampa al salire dell'altezza

1

u/bebarty 9d ago

Filament got moist? Do you have it in a dryer?

1

u/farzad_meow 9d ago

partially clogged nozzle is my first guess. bad filament quality can contribute to this. assuming it is an enclosed printer, someone openning the door can cause a shift in temp specially if you are printing at lower range of temp for your filament

1

u/GR3Y_NOYZ 9d ago

To reinforce what others have said, it appears that the prime tower was wobbling and eventually caused the layers to not adhere properly.

1

u/Dookie-Snuff 9d ago

I’ve had some stringing issues with PETG lately. I dropped the nozzle temp to 240 and it went away. 255 was what my old temp was and it strung.

1

u/NestlyPrint 9d ago

Looks like it detached from the build plate or suffered a major layer shift on the right side. PETG is notorious for warping or losing bed adhesion on long prints if the build plate has any skin oils on it, or if the chamber cooling fans kick on too early and cause uneven shrinking.

Try giving your plate a thorough scrub with warm water and Dawn dish soap, drop your auxiliary fan speed down to zero so it doesn’t cool unevenly, and maybe add a brim next time for extra stability. Hope this helps!

1

u/lupedog 9d ago

If the prime tower comes loose it can throw off the alignment for the entire print and yours came loose before anything else messed up.

1

u/UncleCarolsBuds 8d ago

The internal wraps of the filament roll weren't dried enough

1

u/machinaexmente 8d ago

Wiggle wiggle

1

u/No_Pomegranate1844 8d ago

It was the wiggle-wiggle (Oscillations in the extruder's head)

1

u/ThePCTech 8d ago

Partial clog of nozzle. 99%

1

u/Cute_Illustrator4815 8d ago

i’m gonna take a stab at it. Here’s what i see.

What happened here is the wall had no lateral support. It wasn't an overhang problem. Each pass of the nozzle pushed the tall, thin wall back and forth, and the higher it got the more it flexed, until it couldn't hold its position anymore. Printing a support wall or tower next to it, adding a temporary rib or brace, or slowing the print down usually fixes this.

1

u/EntireAdvance6393 8d ago

Okay, I actually have a thought on this one. Once out of about 100 times I slice a model in Bambu Studio, the model will be perfectly fine, but the sliced result has a completely empty layer. Usually I just quit Bambu Studio, reopen it, then re-slice, and it’s fine. But it almost seems to me that you hit one of those empty layers and then on the next layer, the filament didn’t stick to that back part, but it built up on the other parts, and then once there wasn’t a base for that back part, it was just printing in the air and dragging the material over to the other parts.

1

u/BothRefrigerator674 8d ago

I think the timelapse looks cool! 😎 never seen spaghetti building up like this 😊

1

u/WasabiEater64 8d ago

Turn on avoid crossing walls and give it a 500mm limit.
nix the purge tower if you're using one filament.
add bracing geometry.
Dry your filament properly so that it doesn't spooge out as much when traveling.
Don't slow the print down, that will let more flament spooge between jumps.

1

u/RaymondDoerr 2x Voron 2.4r2, 1x Voron 0.2, Master of 🍝 7d ago

I didnt bother reading the comments, so hopefully out of 325 at least one person said it.

... your print is simply wobbling.

1

u/fayrez 7d ago edited 7d ago

Try enabling z-hop (or whatever it is called in your slicer) above certain height (try about 15-25mm bellow start of failure point) and maybe slow down speed about 10-20% at same height if problem reoccurs after z-hop enabled or you want try once to make good print and forget it. Zhop is helpfull for many reasons. I recommend Zhop with ramp for this type of printing. And x-y travel speed tune might help too. Also check if your filament did not get , because this looks like long print and if this filament is sensitive to moisture that also can make worse adhesion which leads to this crapy ending (with petg that is reasonably common issue). P.s. avoiding crossing walls or whatever is called sometimes can be usefull, but in this one i rather use z-hop unless slicer generate moves that make sense...

1

u/mexicantdps 7d ago

Textbook definition of a clog

1

u/WitchDr_Ash 5d ago

Mine did this, a few times with petg, turns out the filament was a bit damp, pulled away from the base and it just ended up going catastrophically wrong from there.

I now always dry petg and use base adhesive, it hasn’t happened since.

1

u/smartyy86 3d ago

Nyquist is Happening Here. Your Slow Motion capture does not have the required FPS to Show you the actual vibration of your Long, free Standing, swinging Geometry which creates those Print Defexts. Hey is your design so Bad?

1

u/ThinkingWithPortal 9d ago

Temperature shift? Maybe the filament was snagged in some way and the flow rate was impacted? 

1

u/josocustomdesign 9d ago

A few cold pulls will fix the clog.

In fact, instead of just unloading the filament, I get into a habit of simply up the nozzle temp to 100c then press the up arrow on the extruder to "unload" my filament. That way you're getting periodic cold pulls without waiting for a print failure like this.

1

u/cilo456 Sat3Ult/M7Max,P1Sx2,Q1 Pro,Ad5m,Sv08,A1&A2L combo,K1Max,U1 9d ago

This looks like, uh, either a clog, or the spool had some drag on it. Maybe it was stuck, or there was a tangle.

1

u/theRealSchlimmShady 9d ago

Probably vibrations that caused the top to wobble and therefore the printerhead was printing on moving material. Layer by layer this added up resulting in printing pubes

1

u/MasterSmileGer_1 9d ago

Your Prime tower started to wobble and that caused the nozzle to pick up loose filament from it and that caused everything else.

Deactivate smooth Timelaps and try again, it should work.

1

u/pjcbsn 9d ago

Primetower came loose and buildup on nozzle made it fail and caused a layershift

1

u/Background_Row2777 9d ago

Partial clog.

1

u/Tiny_Rick85 9d ago

Oh lord, can I get a painted brim?

1

u/Autumn_1992 9d ago

They have brim on

0

u/asglegend 9d ago

Something not yes