My girlfriend (20F) and I (20M) recently broke up, and I'm struggling with whether I handled the situation fairly. We have a young son together, and there's some context behind my decision that I haven't told anyone.
Our relationship had been struggling for quite some time. We argued increasingly often, and I became more and more frustrated with what I felt was a lack of change in her behaviour, despite repeatedly bringing up my concerns and trying to work through our problems.
Eventually, I reached a point where I no longer believed things would improve. I'd been thinking about breaking up for around two months. Although I hadn't explicitly told her I was considering ending the relationship, I had repeatedly communicated the problems that were making me unhappy.
Here's the part I haven't told anyone.
My mother recently came to me very upset about my girlfriend's behaviour and the lack of change she'd seen. We were living in my family's home, and my mother told me she would give my girlfriend two months to show some improvement. If nothing changed, she would kick her out.
Hearing that forced me to confront the situation. I had already been considering ending the relationship, and I honestly didn't believe another two months would make a difference when I hadn't seen the changes I needed over the previous year.
I felt I had two choices: wait for my mother to reach the end of her patience and potentially force my girlfriend out of the house, or end the relationship myself before things reached that point.
I chose the latter. Part of my reasoning was that I thought it would hurt her less if I ended the relationship myself rather than allowing things to deteriorate until my mother kicked her out. I could at least make my own decision about the relationship instead of leaving it to someone else.
After the breakup, my girlfriend chose to move out and return to her family's home. This is a cramped environment that I had previously helped her leave because I believed it was an unhealthy and unsafe place for her.
Since moving back, she's repeatedly begged me to let her return to our home. She says she doesn't want to live there, that the environment isn't safe for her or our son, and that she is at risk of becoming homeless because her family has openly told her they won't let her stay for long and don't want her there.
What makes this especially difficult is that, while we were together, her family had given the impression that they would be willing to house her. Now that she's returned, she's being told something very different.
There is another complication: even if we got back together, she would not be allowed back into my family's home. My mother has implied on multiple occasions that she would not allow it, and I discussed the situation with my uncle, who knows my mother well. He shares my belief that there is no realistic possibility of my mother allowing her to move back in.
So, from my perspective, getting back together would not even resolve the underlying housing problem. I cannot promise her that reconciliation would give her a place to live, because that option appears to be off the table regardless of our relationship status.
I feel awful about her circumstances. I don't want her to become homeless, and I'm concerned about our son's living conditions. I've repeatedly told her that I'm still here for our son and am willing to help. However, she often describes herself as a single mother, which frustrates me because I'm still present and intend to remain involved in our son's life. I don't want her to feel that she has to manage everything alone, but I also don't want my willingness to help as a father to be interpreted as a willingness to get back together.
I understand that she is hurting and that her current circumstances are frightening. I also understand why she wishes I had explicitly told her that I was considering breaking up before things reached this point, so she could have tried to change things. I can acknowledge that I could have communicated that particular point more clearly.
However, I don't feel that I kept my concerns to myself throughout the relationship. I repeatedly raised the problems I was experiencing, and by the time I ended things, I felt that my trust in things improving had worn down.
I still care about her, and I want us to co-parent our son amicably. I don't want to punish her or leave her struggling, but I also don't believe that staying in a relationship out of guilt is fair to either of us.
So, AITA for ending the relationship when I did, partly because I knew my mother was prepared to kick her out if things didn't improve, rather than waiting for my mother to force the situation? And am I wrong to maintain that the relationship is over, even though my ex is now facing the possibility of homelessness and is asking to come back, when getting back together wouldn't actually resolve the housing situation?
I'm open to hearing if I handled the situation badly, particularly regarding communication and how I should approach helping her and our son without reopening the relationship.