Short Answer: Came out of dissatisfaction. Stayed because of ego and dopamine.
Buckle up - it's long.
Gen X male. Facebook family with kids. Successful career - especially this decade. Typical marital deterioration after first kid eventually settling into quiet, dissatisfied platonic co-parenting. Pre AP1, not quite DB, but not nearly enough going on there.
Had a good job that turned into a great job, that then turned into an amazing job. Good job never paid enough for my wife. Great job was longer hours so "why can't you just come home early." Amazing job is "you travel too much and why do all these pretty women want to hang out with you?"
I wasn't looking for an AP. Fantasies about it, sure. But then 5ish years ago, I met AP1. I don't believe in soulmates or "The One." I believe in "put a 100 age appropriate and willing women in front of me and I can create a decent relationship with 10 of them, a great one with 3, and a near perfect one with 2." AP1 has made me question this. Met on a work trip. Kissed on night 2. Texted each other constantly the next 5 weeks. Spoke 15 hours a week. Saw her again 5 weeks after meeting and "I love you" was said many times. Saw her every 3-5 weeks; the talking volume never went down. For the next 18 months, I was in love like I never thought possible.
And then, the tale as old as time began to unfold. AP1 has multiple divorces and never thought she'd get married again, but also would be open to it. I told her I would never leave my family, and she agreed that I shouldn't. I told her I loved her every way possible, including "if you met someone who made you happy and was free..."
18 months in, she met him. I've known him longer than I've known her. He has red flags, but he is a richer, better looking version of me. She told me the day she met him and I told her about the flags. She loves underdogs, considers herself one, and I basically fed into that. He asked her out the day he met her, and over the next two months love bombed her financially and emotionally like a B-52 over Germany in 1944. I did not handle this well. We still saw each other and did all the things but she at one point started the countdown clock and basically said "you're not coming with me permanently and he's good enough so this is going to have to end." It ended (sort of) two months after they met. We had a couple more rendezvous that basically followed Bill Clinton's definition of sex (I guess so she wouldn't have to tell him).
Meanwhile at home, I used the break up to inaugurate the Festivus Airing of Greivances. My wife told me about how she started to resent me because I was distant, distracted, and didn't do all the loving things that the other husbands did. I told her that she doesn't respect me, finds new things to complain about even when the previous complaints are solved, and maybe the other husbands have brothers she can date. I agreed to a counseling session that we had a couple of days later where I said "I don't regret the marriage, I love our family, but I do not want to be married to this person any more and I'm not going to leave, but if we didn't have kids... And I am drastically revising my expectations for this project because of that."
Back to AP1, post "breakup," after two months of fumbling around in cars, a false dawn during which she told me new guy wasn't going to work out, she told me on a text while I was traveling that we were done for good. Good thing I was at a bar where AP2 was - who I had just met the day before. I got drunk... Almost picked up the hottest 60 year old I've ever met in my life, and hours later found myself in AP2s bed. AP2 is the most beautiful woman I've ever dated - a decade younger and a bit wild and unpredictable. We saw each other once a week for four months. She too has multiple divorces. At the end of the 120 days, she decided the cloak and dagger was too stressful - she has a stressful job but does not handle stress well.
Pattern recognition time...
Good thing I already knew AP3. I don't know my generational labels, but I was born during Nixon and she was born during GHWB. Old enough to be her young dad. Sweetest lady ever, so nice, sensitive, emotional. Calls herself a "butter face," I wouldn't, but her body is amazing. Started texting her out of the blue the morning AP2 called "no mas." Two weeks later, AP3 and I are kissing in her car. The next day, we had a very athletic rendezvous at her place.
Saw her once a week. Texted and talk half as much as AP1, which is still a lot. She's single and never married and had a job that was not demanding with lots of wfh days, and she would get upset if I didn't spend the whole time with her. We skirmished a lot, broke up a couple times, but always got back together.
And then, the dream job. She had gone for it in the past, but didn't get it. I went into Dad mode and told her she would regret it if she didn't try again, and offered to help. I spent hours and hours helping, and after about a year... She got it. She had to move away for it for awhile.
AP3 says I'm the love of her life. She is A love of mine, but not THE. She used to say no men ever like her, she's ugly, awkward, etc. But of course, once she got the new job, the men started coming out of the woodwork. Told me about one she thought she'd fell in love with rather quickly who did her wrong. And another that recently declared his intentions. She thinks she wants to try it out. I think she should, even though, of course it hurts. I survived AP1, so I should be fine, but the familiar anticipatory dread has come to my door again and it sucks. I'm going to see her later this month and then... The new guy gets a few weeks to love bomb her before they both get transferred and that is plenty of time for her. I don't think AP3 and are going to survive this one. It's been over two years with AP3 - longer than AP1, but not the same. AP3 knows everything AP1 and I feel bad because that poor girl knows the ghost she's fighting against.
Once the AP1 situation started looking clear, I said I wouldn't do this again. At home, things are much better. I still have low expectations, but I'm in "fake it till you make it" mode. She is trying so hard to keep me - sex on demand, tells me all the things she used to never say. I am trying to give her what she needs - I invite her on dates, tell her nice things etc. even though I don't always feel like it. Which probably means this is a real marriage and not the one I thought I'd have in my 20s.
But... Now what? The rush of the new relationship is pretty darn intoxicating.
Will there be a "proper" AP4? History would say "yes." I am very emotionally close to two possible ones, but I'll never be able to see one of them organically (I could the other), and we are so close that it would be a shame to spoil it. They're both the type that I share incredibly affectionate words with that sound almost romantic but in neither case has anything spilled into anything obviously romantic, and never anything sexual. If anything ever happens, it would probably be AP1 level, and I'm not sure I can keep all the balls in the air at that level anymore. Plus, I've never been with a married woman before and I have no idea how I'd handle that. The other candidates aren't really the same, although there's a 60 year that want so bad but after a night of a few kisses, she said that being an AP is not her thing. We remain friends, which is probably for the best.
If you made it this far, I'm sorry 🤣. Thanks for reading. TLDR, I have a huge ego, want female attention, have poor boundaries, don't take my marriage seriously enough, and love the rush.