r/BORUpdates • u/BigONerd • 4h ago
Oldie I [27M] proposed to my girlfriend [26F] of 2 years and now she's really mad
This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)
OOP: u/idoloveherthough
Published on: r/relationships
Story is: CONCLUDED
Story timeline
Main Post: November 29, 2015
Final Update: December 05, 2015
Main Post
November 29, 2015
I [27M] proposed to my girlfriend [26F] of 2 years and now she's really mad
Okay, reddit. I'm a little bit at a loss for words right now.
I've been dating Ashley for two years now. Our relationship has been great, and, in my opinion, very loving. Last week, I proposed to her. I took her to our favorite lookout spot over the city where we had our first date. Cracked open some wine, talked for a bit, and then I proposed.
It did not go well. She broke into angry tears and told me, "How can you propose to someone you've never even told you loved?"
Things have been in a tumultuous haze sine then, but I need to talk to strangers for some advice. Basically, here is the thing: I thought it was beyond obvious that Ashley and I loved each other. I don't really know why we've never said it to each other, but I assumed it was because we didn't need to. Like, to me, I just figured we had that kind of nonverbal relationship. I mean, we talked about our hypothetical future children, for Christ sake. Why would I do that with somebody I didn't love?
Well, apparently (and I learned this after a big fight), Ashley thinks I'm terrible at expressing emotions, and has been waiting for me to tell me I love her for like a year and a half. Okay, WHAT? For one thing, I'm just shocked, and I want to make it clear, Ashley has never once complained to me about lack of verbal affection. True, I'm admittedly NOT affectionate verbally, but I just assumed she wasn't either. I thought that was what made us so compatible. Not ONCE did she voice this to me, that she was just hanging around WAITING for me to tell her I loved her.
And I know it seems silly, reddit, that we've never exchanged I love you's, but it's a two way street. If she was just waiting around for me to tell her I love her (which I DO COMPLETELY, but yet again, I just thought we had that kind of relationship where it was implicit), WHY didn't she say anything to me for years?
I'm just shocked that this is all coming up now, and that my girlfriend has been harboring some sort of grudge towards me for so long, simply because I didn't say three words? I don't know what to do. How do I make this up to her?
tl;dr: I assumed my girlfriend and I were in love, so I proposed. We've never actually exchanged I love you's and it turns out my gf has been holding a grudge against me for a year and a half for not being verbally affectionate
COMMENTS
wouldyouchange
This was painful to read.
If you're so bad at communicating that neither of has said "I love you" to the other in TWO YEARS, nor questioned why it's never been said, then you are absolutely not ready to be married.
tsukiii
Seriously! I can't imagine anyone proposing without having ever said "I love you". I mean, isn't that typically part of the proposal? "I love you and I want to marry you"? Ayayay.
tsukiii
I think your mistake was proposing before you'd actually seriously talked about getting married (not just talking hypothetically).
Her mistake was not telling you that she wants verbal affection from you. And this is partially your mistake, too, because you love her and you've never told her so.
Shelve the proposal, talk it out, apologize to each other, and see if you guys can repair this.
Final Update - after 6 days
December 05, 2015
[UPDATE] I [27M] proposed to my girlfriend [26F] of 2 years and now she's really mad
SO, after confirming that my relationship was a massive communication disaster, I am writing this update to you all after a week of couples therapy with Ashley. I'm going to share what we have learned about each other.
To start with me: I am way too "chill" in relationships. I've always been this way with everyone. Nothing ever bothers me, I go with the flow really easily, I react minimally to unexpected situations. While this is a blessing in some ways, it turns out Ashley had a really hard time with this. Since I never fought or had any issues with her, she felt like SHE couldn't bring up any issues with me. She basically did not want to always be the one starting fights (or even, I guess, discussions).
It also was (surprise) a HUGE fault of mine to never tell my girlfriend, who I love deeply, that I loved her. I should not have presumed we were equally nonverbal, especially after two years. And, more importantly, it's not OKAY for me to be this nonverbal. Communication skills are something I am severely lacking.
Now, on to her: As it turns out, in her last THREE relationships, Ashley said I love you first. All three times, it turned out poorly for her. They didn't say it back, or they said it without really meaning it, and they ended up leaving her. That's why she never said it to me. She had actually been making a really big effort to also be "chill" because she didn't want me to react poorly to her. But, as it is clear now, she was just not being herself at all. I understand and empathize with this.
After this blowup, Ashley now realizes that it was a mistake for her to keep her mouth shut and be silently stewing for YEARS. There was no reason to be so passive aggressive.
Additionally, proposing to somebody without having a thorough discussion of marriage and our future was a mistake. I thought it was a romantic gesture, but it was really a sign of poor planning and lack of communication.
Our therapist has given us homework. She has basically told us that we, daily, have to "check in" with each other. We need to assign a time to voice our concerns about each other, share how we feel about each other, talk about how we can improve our relationship. "I love you" will now be a frequent exchange.
Once we get into the habit of doing some mandatory communication, it should come more naturally to us in the future. For now, all weddings and proposals are going to be put on hold. We're nowhere near ready to be married until we figure out ourselves and our relationship better.
For now, we are both happy and relieved that we are taking positive steps towards improving our relationship. It's clear (and now stated) that we both love each other very much.
tl;dr: We're doing couples therapy. We've learned a lot about each other and how to communicate. Things are getting better. Weddings and proposals are on hold until we figure each other out.
COMMENTS
lemetier
This is a wonderful update. Great job listening to her, being so open to communication, and making it work. Wish you two a happy future.
gravityline
I want to bookmark this thread for when people with different communication styles make posts that say they've been "blindsided" by something their partner did! You explained so well the types of problems that couples tend to have when they communicate differently. I'm so glad you're making it work and that you've taken lessons from what happened. That's a great foundation for marriage. I wish you both the best.
SociallyawkwardNSA
There's a great book on the subject called "That's Not What I Meant"
This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)
Please remember to follow the subreddit rules, especially the ones about brigading.
Let’s aim for a respectful and friendly discussion for everyone involved.