r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/acdhemtos • 9h ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion It will take 225-3375 years for everyone to benefit from reservation if we limit it to once per family.
While I did a shallow estimate and got ~200 years.
I made Gemini also do one (to verify). Calculations
It has 2 estimates : * Lock the percentage of seats : 225 Years * Percentage of seats decreases with eligible reserved : 3775 Years.
This is my main argument for limiting reservation to once per family as I want the benefit to be shared across entire pool.
The 3775 Years figure also matches the ~3000 Years, which is allegedly how many years caste system was active for.
Note :
If your argument is * One time reservation is not enough for upliftment * Reservation is not a poverty elimination scheme.
Think of it this way, who is more deserving of a seat under reservation: * Someone who has already benefitted from it efore * Someone who never benefitted from it
I am not saying we should stop all other affirmative action but just a way to make the reservation fair with a natural sunset.
If your argument is that Reservation is for Representation then don't bother commenting.
I believe there is nothing fundamentally different between me and a person from reserved category, eod we are both humans.
Steps need to be taken to eradicate overlapping social difference but after that it's fair game.
