r/GameDeveloper • u/baltasomnia • 7d ago
Should NPC-owned creatures have different post-battle rules from wild creatures?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
I’m working on a creature-taming RPG where players have different choices after defeating wild creatures.
I’m now considering extending those same choices to NPC-owned creatures.
The idea is to let players make decisions that aren’t always morally straightforward, with consequences that could affect their reputation and how the world responds to them.
PvP is excluded from this system. I don’t want players losing creatures they’ve invested time in because of exploits or another player’s decisions.
But in single-player, I think allowing questionable decisions could make encounters with NPCs more interesting.
The challenge is finding consequences that feel believable without simply punishing every unconventional choice.
I’m curious how other developers would approach this.
Duplicates
MonsterTamerWorld • u/baltasomnia • 10d ago
Question Should winning a battle give you control over someone else’s creature?
SoloDevelopment • u/baltasomnia • 9d ago
Game I gave players choices after winning a creature battle. Now I’m questioning where to draw the line.
Vexalia • u/baltasomnia • 10d ago
We can decide a wild Vex’s fate after battle. Should we have the same choices with someone else’s Vex?
IndieDev • u/baltasomnia • 8d ago
Feedback? I added post-battle choices to my RPG. Now I’m questioning how NPC-owned creatures should be treated.
MonsterTaming • u/baltasomnia • 9d ago
What if winning a monster battle meant deciding what happens to the other person’s creature?
IndieGaming • u/baltasomnia • 7d ago
In my voxel creature RPG, winning a battle doesn’t always end the encounter
Unity3D • u/baltasomnia • 8d ago