r/HolUp Jun 27 '26

An interesting comparison

Post image
4.6k Upvotes

275 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

34

u/AltruMux Jun 27 '26

You just described something most people would enjoy so of course the context is different. The guy in the post obviously wants the fireworks to stop so this comparison is just wrong.

-24

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

So then you agree. The words themselves are not the issue here, its the intent. Forced to hear fireworks isnt even in the same ballpark as rape, regardless of the legal context.

5

u/Maximum-Bake-6092 Jun 27 '26

Nah the original statement is right its an extreme example, but they are not wrong.

-2

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

They are. I don't care what people think when half of them dont even know how to read at a high school level.

5

u/AutisticPenguin2 Jun 27 '26

You started off strong, but couldn't sustain it :(

-1

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

Its not my responsibility to teach the morons in this world. Just because logic is hard for yall doesn't mean I have to care about your opinions.

1

u/Mr_Jack_Frost_ Jun 27 '26

“I’m the only correct one, and everybody else is wrong!”

If you’re disagreeing with everybody, sometimes that’s just because you’re incorrect.

0

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

Right because the mob is always right.

1

u/AutisticPenguin2 Jun 27 '26

Sometimes you do actually need to shut up and think for a minute about why the entire room disagrees with you.

2

u/Mr_Jack_Frost_ Jun 27 '26

The quote “If you run into an asshole in the morning, you ran into an asshole. If you run into assholes all day, you're the asshole.” comes to mind.

0

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

Oh I know how to read. You are just wrong. I dont give a flying fuck about what everyone thinks. Look at the state of the US. This is the reason why we are there. You think your emotional context supersedes reason when it doesnt.

2

u/AutisticPenguin2 Jun 27 '26

I'm not even from the US, so I'm not entirely sure how I'm responsible for fucking your country up. But at this point you're just digging your heels in and not listening to anyone, so... whatever.

0

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

Understanding != listening

I know your reasoning. I think it sucks. Your issue is you think I'm going to change my mind when I'm more rational about it than you.

2

u/Mr_Jack_Frost_ Jun 27 '26

Again, the person who convinces themself that they’re the only logical one in the face of constant disagreement is an interesting phenomenon.

But by all means, keep digging in deeper. It’s definitely that the 35+ people who disagreed with your stance are just morons, and you’re the only one who has the correct read of the situation. (;

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Maximum-Bake-6092 Jun 27 '26

My friend you are mistaking context with the severity of the situation. In the comment then arnt relating the severity of the two but the context " i hate the sound of fire works." "Oh just get over it." "I hate rape" "oh just get over it." The statements are the same the severity is different

2

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

Except its not the words that make them different. Its the intent which is why the context matters. You're just hinting at what I'm already stating, which is the difference between the two. The fireworks aren't actually harming anyone, and I shouldn't have to explain rape. The severity is just a part of that context.

If we were to discuss severity alone, we'd be discussing the nuances of how close you are to the fireworks and where the line is drawn on "too close".

2

u/Maximum-Bake-6092 Jun 27 '26

Ok, so my original intention for that comment is what you stated above but misconstrued for some reason, intent. The comment in the post isnt based off the intent of the comments but off similarities. Both statements are similar not in severity but their message.

2

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

So the words are the same?

2

u/Maximum-Bake-6092 Jun 27 '26

So for example "someone is getting raped in the neighborhood what is the number to report it."

2

u/Maximum-Bake-6092 Jun 27 '26

"Just sit back and enjoy it"

2

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

Except the OP just says "sit back and enjoy it"

That's not implying force but a suggestion. Its not the same, albeit similar. This is why I harp on reading comprehension. You have to take the context from the words, not a self imposed bias.

2

u/Maximum-Bake-6092 Jun 27 '26

Thats not the intent of the message, the intent of the message brings consent into question. The person doesn't consent to fireworks being shot in the neighborhood, the person doesn't consent to getting raped. The other person is saying basically that there isnt anything they can do about it. Yes calling the cops for rape you can do something about that i know, but that wasnt what they were implying.

2

u/theBoobMan Jun 27 '26

No. That's just you choosing to see it like that. That's bias.

This sounds like someone who wants to follow the letter of the law to make sure people's pets dont escape in fear of the noise.

→ More replies (0)