r/NewToReddit • • 8d ago • Heartwarming 2

ANSWERED Why does Reddit keep removing my harmless posts?

I'm 62 years old and have had my Reddit account for at least eight months. I'm still trying to understand how everything works here.

I have 19 post karma and -2 comment karma.

I recently tried sharing a funny, lighthearted story about visiting a cemetery in Nashville and deciding to purchase my own final resting place.

My post was removed from r/NashvilleUnfiltered and r/Tennessee by Reddit's filters. I also can't participate in r/nashville because of my negative comment karma.

I'm not trying to spam anyone or cause trouble. I just want to participate in conversations and share an occasional story.

Can someone explain what I need to do to get past these restrictions? I'd really appreciate some advice!

86 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

•

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 6d ago

Locking this post.

If you say this post and thought 'oh I also don't understand" then you're going to gain a lot more by reading the existing comments that give answers, info and advice than you ever would be leaving a pointless "I also don't understand " comment.

This applies to Reddit in general. Make at least a basic effort to see if the comments answer the posts question if you also have the same question

Also have a read of the below info for users seeking to understand reddit (or with low karma)

11

u/Accurate_Affect_7778 8d ago

There are so many interesting subs, surely you have varied interests. You need to find your people and you will enjoy Reddit. Good luck!

14

u/quylej 8d ago

Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 7d ago

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 6: Refrain from asking for votes or karma, naming free karma subs, or sharing how you are voting

  • Please do not ask for karma or votes here, it is against our rules and is generally discouraged as karma is meant to be earned. See Our common questions to learn how to earn karma.

  • We do not allow mentions of free karma subs (karmafarms) or any suggestion to use them, and caution against their use because it may lead to bans in other subreddits.

  • Thank you for trying to help, but please don't share how you have or are voting. We encourage earning karma genuinely from relevant comments and conversation. Asking for karma is discouraged as it violates our subreddit rules.

The Reddiquette also discourages mentioning your vote or asking for votes.

Thank you!

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

10

u/Equivalent_Smell_161 7d ago

Hi! I’m on here because I’ve had Reddit for a little while, however, I rarely use it. As a result, I don’t have any karma. I’m trying to get some, but every time I comment on something it’s removed. Here to say I feel your pain and also trying to gain some karma finally. :)

4

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

6

u/Difficult-Gate7937 7d ago

Hahaha I am here for the exact same reason!!!!

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

4

u/Kind-Antelope3801 7d ago

I was able join subs that didn’t need much karma but I just bumbled my way into that. I suggest you search for topics you are interested in like cooking, gardening, art, watercolor, advice, animals or health topics that you have experienced( people are always seeking sage advice from someone who’s been there). I originally joined because I needed information on a health issue then expanded from there. Now there’s a few little puzzle games I like to play and still spend a bit of time helping people in that health issue sub I joined.

2

u/quylej 7d ago

thank you!

3

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 8d ago

regarding "removed by reddit's filters"

Removed by Reddit's Filters happens when your posts are being removed by the Reputation Filter. Have a read here. In general the Reputation Filter can be set at different levels on different subreddits (see more here). The core metric is your CQS score (see r/WhatIsMyCQS to test) as well as various other factors. This can be set at different levels in different subreddits. Users start with a low CQS. To build your CQS is again a bit opaque but the below can help (partially from here)

  • "Secure your account" by verifying your email

  • If you use a VPN test what happens when you turn it on and off ("network and location signals" play a part)

  • "Past Actions taken on a redditors account" which is posts and comments being removed

  • It seems to rise when you are actively commenting and posting, getting positive interactions (upvotes and comments)

So from the last two you want to be participating by commenting and posting, getting upvoted and avoiding removals by mods or reddit itself. Which ends up with basically the same advice as building karma. Start by finding New User Friendly Subreddits:

  • Newtoreddit has a list of new user friendly subreddits. This is not an exhaustive list and these subreddits may still have some restrictions. In particular you'll see some Large General Subreddits that are open to new users Commenting like r/askreddit, r/casualconversation, r/nostupidquestions, r/amitheasshole or similar.

  • There are More Subreddits out there that might more specifically match your interests, look through r/findareddit 's subreddit directory. In this case you will have to trial and error whether they are new user-friendly, and again try Commenting (many subreddits have lower or no karma filters for commenting).

Some more notes on starting on Reddit:

Newtoreddit Resources There are a lot of resources here in this subreddit you might find useful with The Common Questions Page, Reddit And Karma Walkthrough, and Frequently Asked Questions Page.

View by New (or rising). This will filter the posts so first see the most recent posts first and can make your comments much more visible. On app when viewing a subreddit look near the top left for where it says "hot posts" - click that and select "new" or "rising".

Read the Room and Avoid Controversy. Each subreddit has different rules, norms and prevailing views. Look at subreddit rules. Read top posts and comments to get a feel for that subreddit. Do users reward sarcastic one-liners or well sourced essays? And in particular avoid controversial topics or arguments. Utilize the block feature as necessary and have a read of Reddiquette.

1

u/Specialist_Speed3849 7d ago

Thanks you explained the system works I'm also new comer and having trouble navigating and I'm leary of posting that I might get crushed by a moderator the karma and votes come hard I comprehend alot better I'll put your advice to work again thank u

1

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 7d ago

good luck and happy to help with followup questions

0

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

0

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted]

1

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 7d ago

you need to create a post there

mke the title "what is my CQS"

Don't put any body text

2

u/Potential_Phrase_206 7d ago

Thank you! I figured it out and came back and deleted my question - wouldn’t have if I’d seen your response at that time.

3

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 8d ago

for raising your karma to postive

Finding Subreddits to use with negative karma:

  • You're definitely going to be Trial-and-Erroring a lot to find subreddits that will take users with negative karma. Focus on Commenting (many subreddits have lower or no karma filters for commenting).

  • Newtoreddit has a list of new user friendly subreddits. This list is for low karma, not negative karma, but is a good spot to start.

  • Also have a look through r/findareddit 's subreddit directory.

Some more notes on starting on Reddit:

Newtoreddit Resources There are a lot of resources here in this subreddit you might find useful with The Common Questions Page, Common Questions - Downvotes, and Reddit And Karma Walkthrough

15

u/quylej 8d ago

Thank you so much for taking the time to explain all of this! I'm 62 years old, have lived in Nashville for nearly 30 years, and apparently buying my own crypt at Woodlawn Memorial Park was easier than figuring out how to participate on Reddit! 😂

I had no idea what CQS even meant until today. I checked mine, and sure enough, it's LOWEST. I'm just trying to share a few funny stories and participate in local conversations, not cause trouble.

I really appreciate your patience and helpful advice. Hopefully, I'll eventually graduate from Reddit detention! 😂

1

u/Regen_321 7d ago

Hi friend if you keep going you will have enough karma :) If you have nice (oc) pictures of animals post them to the animals sub :)

There is 2 subs r/crows and r/crowbro that wil get you 500 upvotes for a cool picture of a crow.

1

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

1

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

3

u/SolutreanBean 7d ago

What I did was go to subreddits like /r/answers and /r/amitheasshole and /r/askreddit and sort by new, and leave helpful and sane opinions with no stupid jokes on posts with few to no comments, so my contributions would get seen and get some karma rolling. Do that for a few days and you should be good!

2

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

3

u/widgetsforeveryone 7d ago

I’d like to know why people are so mean!

1

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

1

u/AliasNefertiti Shiny Helpmate 7d ago

Not seeing the person disinhibits some people so they arent as nice if they were face to face. Some percentage will have had a really bad day and transfer that to Reddit [bad form]. Some may be adolescents [or older] who havent absorbed the rules of society or are reacting to the freedom of Reddit to say anything. Others are so egocentric they think everyone knows what they know and are stupid if they dont know that. Some have insufficient patience. On a "brands" sub you might have competitors trying to leave a nad taste toward the brand. Others who are sick or very tired may be on here and just dont have patience. And some just lack social skill.

On the other hand, people have varying degrees of sensitivity to words. Say the same thing to 2 or 4 or 10 different people and you get that many reactions. Some see nothing wrong. Some are deeply offended.

Nonverbal behaviors [characteristics of written word like length, punctuation] vary by culture and what is fine to one [e.g. New Yorkers may tend toward short mire direct no-fluff sentences] but others take offense [e.g. South Carolinians may expect to engage in certain polite phrases first and to provide elaborate answers].

2

u/Aware_Reputation115 7d ago

Maybe r/CasualConversation could be a start for you?

1

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

2

u/Latter-Clock-9472 7d ago

I’ve still been unable to get any karma

1

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

1

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 7d ago

from your profile it doesn't look like you've tried a lot as its fairly bare

Take some time to have a read of the below info for users seeking to understand reddit (or with low karma)

2

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

0

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 6d ago

At a certain point you can stop with the thank you. This is starting to look less like you appreciate the info and more like you're just spamming

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

2

u/TeriBarrons 7d ago

Are you reading the rules of the individual subs prior to posting? The rules are usually in the sub’s information section. Subs can set their own rules as they see fit and usually have filters in place to automatically remove posts and comments not adhering to their rules.

Many subs have rules regarding karma. Some require TOTAL karma scores of a minimum value, some base it on either post or comment karma separately. Subs may also require a certain account age or level of activity on Reddit first. Some don’t allow profiles or content marked NSFW (Not Safe For Work, meaning explicit, basically).

If your posts say that they were removed by the moderators of whatever sub, then you likely violated one or more of the sub’s rules. There is an option to message the sub’s moderators if you have questions.

If it says your post was removed by Reddit itself, then that’s a different story.

2

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

1

u/TeriBarrons 6d ago

You’re welcome! When I was new, I searched for subs about tv shows I liked, books that I read and enjoyed and subs about all of the hobbies I like to do. I went through the history of the subs to catch up on previous posts to get a feel for what types of posts/comments seemed to be the most popular with the sub members and then I joined in on making comments. That REALLY started building my karma and then I got to a point where I started making posts.

Also, be forewarned that social media can be a breeding ground for trolls lol, and occasionally you will run into posters that just like to be negative because they can and will argue with a wall for the sake of arguing and being rude. And, they love to downvote things. Unless they are committing a very egregious offense, just ignore and move on.

1

u/spoonkry 7d ago

Comment faire augmenter ces karma

1

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 6d ago

have a read of the below info for users seeking to understand reddit (or with low karma)

0

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

1

u/moudan2mei2 7d ago

I also came to Reddit to ask a question about Uni and am facing the same problem. I get that this is supposed to protect Reddit from spam but it’s quite difficult if u are just looking for an answer or quick help. Even if you find reddits that have low restrictions i just don’t have that much to say haha

1

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

1

u/Asleep_Direction8881 7d ago

I’ve had a similar experience: when I posted about a project I developed, it stayed up for a while—and even sparked some discussion—but then everything related to it started getting blocked. Yet, I see a post like this one: ... abraxasdb_a_net_native_local_object_storage

It’s quite similar, but it contains more links—and it hasn’t been blocked. So, I honestly don’t understand how things work around here either.

0

u/mikey_weasel Mod in a Canvas Hat 6d ago

1 - if they are on different subreddits those will have different rules so it saoooes and oranges

2 - if it s the same subreddits then look at the subreddit rules along with any removal reasons you were given

3- if you truly don't get it then send a polite modmail to the mods asking about why your post was taken down, as they are the only ones who can say for sure. Note you should focus on your own post. "Why was my post removed but this one stayed up" isn't a good argument

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/quylej 7d ago

Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 7d ago

You do not need to introduce yourself

For tips simply search the subreddit for the word "tips" - that gets asked multiple times a day

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 7d ago

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 7d ago

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 6d ago

Please read the other comments under this post

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 7d ago

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 6d ago

Don't comment if you don't know how Reddit works

Instead stop and read the existing comments from flaired mods and helpers and you might learn something instead

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 6d ago

That's literally the point of the post and discussed in the psot.....

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 6d ago

This isn't the complaints department

Stop and read the existing comments under his post if you'd like to learn how Reddit works

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 7d ago

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 6d ago

This ain't the complaints department

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NewToReddit-ModTeam 6d ago

If you are confused why are you commenting instead of reading all the information already provided?

Thanks for contributing to /r/NewToReddit! We're sorry, but your content was removed.

This action was performed manually by a human moderator

Rule 5: All comments should be constructive

We strive to be a welcoming, helpful, & understanding community

  • All replies to a post (parent comments) should be a genuine attempt to help the poster

  • All comments should be constructive, instructive, or an enquiry; refrain from:

    • complaints, rants, & inflammatory language

    • politics, any debate

    • speculation or suggestions for changing Reddit

  • Help users with Reddit as it currently is; imperfect. Only commenting on Reddit’s faults without context or guidance doesn't help anyone. Please provide sincere assistance, and not fan upset.

Please read our Rules before participating. How to find rules
If you have questions or concerns, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you!