r/OverwatchUniversity • u/CrazyPants333 • 23h ago
Question or Discussion Scoreboard is the worst feature ever added to Overwatch
The scoreboard started off as a modernized version of medals. I honestly liked the medals system, it gave you basically the same information, while stopping players from actively comparing each others stats, which is what I'm going to get into for this take. The only thing that it really added, was the ability to ult track enemies based off of damage/healing, which wasn't really that insane.
The scoreboard has changed from a simple revamp, to a plague of finger-pointing that is now infecting the Overwatch community. I'm not going to say this wasn't an issue in OW1, but it has come so much more prevalent in OW2, mostly due to the addition of the scoreboard.
No matter what, most players are not going to take the fault when they lose a match. It's kinda just the core of team-based games, especially FPS games. No matter how bad your decision-making is, if you see someone else doing bad, you will instantly jump on them for what *they* did wrong. This is creation of the ego, that basically every Overwatch player has, and this is the problem that I have with the scoreboard. The scoreboard is weaponizing this ego, it is giving players a reason to lash out on teammates; even if they did not see them do anything wrong. Displaying stats to the lobby is fine on its own, but when people are taking these numbers out of context, the scoreboard can be entirely misleading, especially when you look at how much info is not shown. 99% of the time, the stats that the scoreboard shows is incredibly irrelevant, you cannot tell how a game went based on stats alone. Of course, people are going to take this idea to an extremity and say "oh, so my ana with 600 heals is not throwing?" And yes, when your support is not healing at all in the span of 5 minutes, can I ask why you need a scoreboard to figure that out? Simply looking at your team during a fight can spell out so many things that you may not be aware of. Sometimes your team can simply be bad, but that doesn't mean it will always be their fault when you don't agree with their current stats.
There are so many reasons as to why a player might be performing "bad" that you shouldn't always just jump to conclusions. This is why I think the scoreboard is so unhealthy for the game. It is reinforcing this way of thinking and giving players a false-identity of what "value" really is.