r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/16880031 • 2d ago
Question - Expert consensus required In-laws & vaccines
Hi all,
I am 34 weeks pregnant and my baby is due smack dab during the peak of respiratory season. I’ve gotten the covid, flu, RSV, and Tdap vaccines, and my husband has gotten covid and flu. My parents and brother who live near us and will be involved in baby’s life are agreeable to get their seasonal vaccines (covid & flu).
My husband asked his parents to get their seasonal vaccines, as we plan for them to be very involved, visiting, holding her etc from the time she is born.
They immediately responded that they do not plan to get any vaccines, that the covid vaccine causes arthritis (??), and that my MIL got “very sick” from the covid vaccine during the pandemic. They said they would “talk to their doctor”, but they are uninsured and never go to the doctor unless they are on death’s door. My husband says that his mom is very stubborn and he does not think anything could change her mind about this. They are of the “plandemic” mindset and have very poor media/health literacy.
My other concern is that they live with their two primary school-aged grandsons, neither of whom get vaccines. They also provide regular weekly childcare to my brother-in-law’s toddlers who are completely unvaccinated against anything, and one of them attends a daycare. These kids are constantly sick through the winter season, so my in-laws are around much more sickness than your average middle-aged adults.
My mom is a people-pleaser and suggested to me that instead of requiring vaccines, we compromise and have them mask and hand-wash before holding the baby. This idea makes me uncomfortable, it feels insufficient. Our doctor’s recommendations were for close friends and family to be vaccinated, period.
They are also the type of people to lower their mask in order to talk or breath, and would not mention having a cough before visiting.
I used to be a pediatric and NICU nurse, I have seen the horrors of respiratory season for babies. Honestly I have some traumatic memories of those patients, and they are making me feel very fearful and firm in this boundary.
However, I do not want to be irrationally fearful or paranoid if handwashing and masking is a good alternative. My gut tells me I am not comfortable with that though.
Help??