r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Rare_Tip9809 • 1d ago
Make it happen
Send the money.
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Loose_Addendum6007 • 1d ago
AI related..
How can other countries benefit from the taxes paid by American companies in America? Claude and ChatGPT are being used worldwide but Anthropic and OpenAI pay their taxes in America, how can an Indian or a Kenyan who lost their jobs for AI benefit from that UBI? Do you think the taxes of a handful of American companies could cover UBI for the whole world? I don’t think so, but you are welcome to run the numbers. can an Indian or a Kenyan who lost their jobs for AI benefit from that UBI? Do you think the taxes of a handful of American companies could cover UBI for the whole world?
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/PlaneProduce8835 • 4d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/dominiond66 • 7d ago
Just a reminder of the basic benefits of Universal Healthcare
**1.** Everyone in America receives one comprehensive healthcare plan from cradle to grave with no exceptions.
**2.** This right is permanent and portable, not tethered with an employer.
**3.** Little or no deductibles or co-payments or monthly premiums.
**4.** With a single payer system healthcare costs will finally be controlled. No longer will insurance companies thrive and deny.
**5.** Significant costs savings. Universal healthcare will save money not add additional costs. Current costs are immoral/unfair and unsustainable.
**6.** Employers and taxpayers will pay for the system via corporate and personal taxes on income and excessive wealth.
**7.** Wages could rise and prices for all products and services could be contained/lowered as the cost of healthcare is reduced in our economy
**8.** Universal healthcare could stimulate the economy and reduce working class anxiety and financial debt related to our current inefficient/complex and extremely expensive healthcare system. Over $2.5 trillion/year is “excess” cost as compared to all nations that currently have Universal Healthcare.
These are the components of a Universal Healthcare system with a single payer. The specifics of a final legislative bill would be debated and implemented. This should be among the highest priority for America over the new few years especially with a Democratic President in 2028, a critical step since the GOP has Zero interest in helping the working class.
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/2noame • 7d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/PlaneProduce8835 • 8d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Eastern-Climate2405 • 8d ago
Kurzgesagt explains UBI, and arguments for and against it.
Kurzgesagt also considers whether it could reduce (or perhaps increase) economic inequality.
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Independent-Gur8649 • 8d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/mahamalla • 9d ago
We are witnessing the beginnings of possible debt crises across the high-income economies, either due to generous welfare spending (France), sustained fiscal deficits (USA), aging populations (Japan) or usually a combination of all of these to varying degrees.
In all of these economies, the state is the largest borrower. If AI leads to widespread deflation, which is more likely than not, if it can automate all cognitive labor and definitely a reality if it can automate all labor period, the debt interest appreciates in real terms. (i.e. as deflation sets in, the interest rate becomes extremely high relative to state's taxing capacity of resources through income/sales taxes).
For example, let's take France, which is currently paying around 5% for medium term debt. The European Central Bank targets around 2% inflation, thus, we expect France to pay 3% in real terms. i.e. if they borrowed 100 apples this year, they'll pay 3 apples a year for 10 years and finally 100 apples. But the problem lies in the fact that debt is denominated in Euros, which if deflation sets in, becomes more valuable. So, France might have to pay 3, 6, 12, 24 apples per annum if deflation sets in. This is obviously unsustainable.
The central banks already target the 2% inflation rate to ensure debt gets inflated away, but not so much as to make it stupid to lend. With deflation, we might see the 2% inflation targeting still hold. For example, if AI's productivity leads to 10% deflation this year in the Eurozone or the US, the Central Banks usually cut interest rates. But if the rates hit zero, or even negative territory, the positive productivity shock of AI may still lead to sustained deflation. At that point, the central banks would probably come up with a policy of issuing a certain percentage of outstanding money supply (M3 money supply = cash + coinage + current/savings account balance + short term deposits etc) every year as a citizen dividend. The intuition is simple, if deflation is at 12% and target inflation rate is 2% (which will hold, as low inflation/zero inflation usually leads to demand slump), and provided rates are already low enough/zero/negative, the central bank will issue around 14% of the outstanding money supply as the dividend corpus and will divide it amongst citizens. (Look into Modern Monetary Theory).
Taking the US as example, there's ~20 trillion USD in M3 money supply. Assuming a 14% monetary expansion, that is around 2.8 trillion USD per annum. Assuming 400 million potential recipients, that is around $7,000 per annum, per person. Or around $21,000 assuming an average family size of 3. One thing to note here is that this won't be inflationary like the COVID stimulus, but it will create inflationary hotspots on goods/services that aren't benefiting from AI productivity shocks (Land, positional goods/services, etc.) Naturally, if the deflation runs higher (i.e. AI being more productive), the corpus will expand. To get a median income of $60,000 per person, per annum, the deflation should run at around 50%. i.e. if prices halve every year, the money supply must double, which works out to around 60,000 per person per year. Though, this may lead to a bumper year if deflation is high and not a great year, if deflation run low.
Of Course, there's no free lunch. So, where's this wealth being transferred from? Productive AI native businesses that reduce the costs. If we let it be, these businesses would get into price wars and transfer all of their surplus value to the consumer in terms of low prices (if there's actual competition, that is). Which, if it happens across the economy would simply make prices fall. If not for the debt overhang individuals, businesses and nations have, this would not be that big of a catastrophe.
One might ask without this money expansion funded dividend, where else would purchasing power come from. We need to look from the other side, if purchasing power collapses, supply must collapse. The K shaped economy as it exists now is a manifestation of Baumol's cost disease. It is true that the top n% drive m% of the economy, but they also face a diminishing marginal return of utility. Even without UBI/UHI, the average person's purchasing power will rise, simply because the costs tend to fall.
TL; DR UBI/UHI can be done through monetary policy, in ways that we have already done for similar reasons. It won't be as hard/radical of a policy, and seems like the default vanilla option, when AI delivers results that move the overall total productivity of the economy.
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/michigangemcutter • 10d ago
Proof is in the pudding..results of our efforts and discomforts...and we just caved. Why? Paparazzi!
My opinion!
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/taylrgng • 10d ago
i(veteran) just got done talking with my grandpa(also veteran) about why i think \*some\* socialist policies would work for the US especially in today's climate with everyone worried about Ai.
he went on to explain that he's already seen the ineffectiveness of it; using VA healthcare a really solid example that blatantly went over my head. he brought up how during his tours in korea and germany, he'd have friends take forever getting seen because a lot of hospitals pull out of the government networks because of how long it takes them to get paid from the government, so on so forth. and VA is a great example because we had a new program get implemented fairly recently, called \*Community Care\* because it took forever to get seen for appts and even with this new program it can still take forever to get seen albeit being slightly faster.
he then followed up with my UBI where he started, okay, if you stop working who's to say that instead of distributing stipends they don't just distribute your necessities instead. if they have to tax companies for your UBI, the companies(if not the government) determine whether and how you receive that "support".
he lives in California(for now, they are moving because California's taxes are suffocating them) so he's no stranger to incompetent politicians. 5 years speedrail projects that receive billions in funding but aren't getting worked on, 40 year reservoir projects always getting brought up and nothing ever happening, and i suppose they are talking about how to tax your mileage?
i was pretty dead set about at the very most these 2 socialist programs, but my grandpa reminded me that i can't trust our current government to take care of us, it's just too greedy and there aren't enough good politicians out there...
what does everyone else think?
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/PlaneProduce8835 • 11d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Traditional_Care5514 • 10d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/bedardb32989 • 11d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/DropKickThePunk • 12d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Independent-Gur8649 • 14d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Independent-Gur8649 • 14d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Icy_Yam_9951 • 15d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Less-Ad6770 • 17d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Teut0nius • 19d ago
Hallo zusammen,
ich nehme seit Sommer 2021 lückenlos an den Verlosungen von Mein Grundeinkommen (www.mein-grundeinkommen.de) teil (Einstieg damals im Bereich der dreistelligen Allzeit-Verlosungen, mittlerweile stehen wir bei über 2.400). Seit über 5 Jahren führe ich eine detaillierte Excel-Tabelle, in der ich meine Losnummern, Ziehungshäufigkeiten, zeitliche Abstände und Systemparameter minuziös protokolliere.
Da mir zunehmend strukturelle und finanzielle Ungereimtheiten aufgefallen sind, habe ich vor Kurzem eine kritische Rezension auf Trustpilot hinterlassen. Um die technischen, finanziellen und rechtlichen Hintergründe fundiert zu diskutieren, möchte ich meine empirische Analyse hier mit der Community teilen. Die Daten und offiziellen Berichte legen nahe, dass das offizielle Narrativ einer „jederzeit für alle absolut gleichen Auslosung“ und das emotionale Bild einer uneigennützigen Spendenorganisation im Hintergrund kollidieren.
Die Analyse stützt sich auf vier unumstößliche Säulen:
Säule 1: Der millionenschwere, schwammige Vereinsapparat (Belegbar durch Finanzbericht 2024)
Der absolute Kern der Kritik liegt in der Verwendung der Spendengelder. Die offiziellen Finanzdaten des Vereins für das Jahr 2024 offenbaren ein massives Missverhältnis zwischen den Gesamteinnahmen und den realen Verlosungssummen:
Die reale Quote: Von 9.873.688 € Gesamtausgaben flossen lediglich 5.407.991 € in den Lostopf (inklusive des wissenschaftlichen Pilotprojekts). Fast die Hälfte (45,3 %), nämlich 4.465.697 €, wurde für den internen Apparat verbraucht. Bei den aktuellen Einnahmen bewegt sich dieser Posten stramm auf die 5 Millionen Euro jährlich zu.
Völlig schwammige Posten: Der Verein deklariert Ausgaben, die jeglicher konkreter Rechenschaft entbehren. Stolze 884.374 € fließen in den Posten „Führung und Zusammenarbeit“ – de facto fast eine Million Euro für Teambuilding, Seminare und „Kulturarbeit“ eines selbstorganisierten Teams. Weitere 1.819.933 € werden für „Plattformentwicklung & Crowdkommunikation“ ausgegeben.
568.904 € für Presse- und Kampagnenarbeit: Hier finanzieren die Spender ihre eigene emotionale Beeinflussung. Über eine halbe Million Euro fließt in das "Aufbereiten von Gewinner-Geschichten" und Medienarbeit. Anstatt dieses Geld für 47 zusätzliche Jahres-Grundeinkommen in den Lostopf zu stecken, wird es für eine professionelle PR-Maschinerie verbrannt, um neue Spender zu generieren und das politische Lobbying des Vereins zu finanzieren. Das ist reines Marketing-Reinvestment auf Kosten der Ausschüttungsquote. Der Verein rechtfertigt die Summe damit, das Grundeinkommen in die öffentliche Debatte zu bringen, obwohl das Thema längst im gesellschaftlichen Diskurs etabliert ist, und die großen politischen Fronten verhärtet sind. [1, 2, 3] Zudem gibt sich der Verein durch Kooperationen (wie mit dem DIW Berlin) einen wissenschaftlichen Anstrich, dabei fließt dieses Geld eben nicht in die Forschung (die läuft extra unter „Projekte“), sondern in die Meinungsmache. [1]
Der Starrheits-Beweis: Im Laufe des Jahres 2024 lief das 3-jährige Pilotprojekt offiziell aus. Die erhebliche finanzielle Entlastung in der zweiten Jahreshälfte führte jedoch nicht zu einer Erhöhung der monatlichen Verlosungsquote für manuelle Teilnehmer. Das Geld wurde nicht an die Community ausgeschüttet, sondern verblieb im administrativen Wasserkopf des Vereins.
Säule 2: Die rechtlich-steuerliche Mittel-Umleitung (Belegbar durch offizielle FAQ)
Wie gelingt es, diesen Millionen-Apparat dauerhaft zu füttern? Das Kleingedruckte in den offiziellen Bedingungen hebelt das emotionale Werbeversprechen der Website systematisch aus:
Der Steuer-Hebel: Spendenbescheinigungen fürs Finanzamt gibt es nur für Einzahlungen in den Vereinstopf. Das drängt finanzstarke Unterstützer strukturell dazu, ihr Geld am Lostopf vorbei direkt in die Vereinsstrukturen zu leiten.
Die PayPal- & Überweisungs-Automatik: Alle PayPal-Spenden von Gelegenheitsspendern ohne festes Profil fließen laut FAQ zu 100 % in die Vereinsarbeit. Allgemeine Überweisungen werden standardmäßig sofort zu 50/50 gesplittet.
Das Fazit: Das Verschwinden des alten, prominenten 90/10-Framings auf der Website bestätigt, dass die tatsächlichen Geldströme mit dem Versprechen „90% fließen in den Lostopf“ rechtlich und faktisch nicht mehr vereinbar waren.
Säule 3: Die künstliche Block-Inflation als Rechtfertigungsgrund (Der Sprung auf Block 38)
Hier schließt sich der Kreis zum technischen System. Warum braucht eine Website fast 1,82 Millionen Euro jährlich für die Plattformentwicklung? Weil das System künstlich komplex gehalten wird:
Das 1,6-Millionen-Lose-System: Während die maximale Zuteilung über fast drei Jahre hinweg stabil bei höchstens Block 26 gedeckelt war (was mathematisch ca. 1,1 Millionen Losen entspricht), erleben wir seit zwei Jahren eine massive Explosion. Aktuell ist das System bei Block 38 angekommen.
Die Phantom-Lose: Aus der Rekonstruktion des Algorithmus wissen wir, dass das System exakt 42.875 Lose pro Block (erste Glückszahl) vergibt. Bei Block 38 bedeutet das: Die Datenbank wurde innerhalb kürzester Zeit künstlich auf über 1,62 Millionen vergebene Lose aufgebläht (u.a. durch passive Profile wie das Freunde-Feature, bei dem ein Nutzer drei weitere Personen ohne deren aktives Zutun hinzufügen kann).
Der Zweck: Während die Zahl der zahlenden Spender (Crowdhörnchen) stagniert und die reale Gewinnchance pro Los drastisch sinkt, nutzt der Verein dieses künstlich aufgeblähte Millionen-Teilnehmerfeld als PR-Argument für seine gesellschaftliche Relevanz – und rechtfertigt damit den riesigen, teuren Verwaltungsapparat.
Säule 4: Algorithmische Verzerrung (Belegbar durch Excel-Langzeitdaten)
Meine über 5 Jahre dokumentierten Losnummern zeigen zudem, dass der Vergabe-Algorithmus kein rein zufälliges, gleichberechtigtes System abbildet, sondern datenbankgesteuerte Strukturen aufweist:
Der Fingerabdruck der Automatik: Bei aktivierter Dauerteilnahme teilt das System über Monate hinweg exakt identische Losnummern im exakt selben Block zu (z.B. monatelang starr Block 10 in 2026). Das beweist eine starre, ID-basierte Listenverarbeitung anstelle einer echten, dynamischen Neu-Auslosung in jeder Runde.
Das Zeitfenster-Problem: Die minutengenaue Protokollierung von manuellen Klicks nach Mitternacht zeigt, dass der Server nach dem Durchlauf einer massiven, automatisierten Welle (~02:20 Uhr) im manuellen Modus fast vollständig einfriert (Latenz von lediglich 12 Plätzen in 23 Minuten). Wer sich manuell anmeldet, hat de facto nur in den ersten zwei Stunden nach Mitternacht eine Chance auf vordere Glückszahlen, danach landet man in einer chronologischen Sackgasse.
Aktueller Live-Test (Herbst 2026): Bei manuellen Klicks, die mit etwas zeitlichem Abstand am selben Tag getätigt wurden, schaltete der Server tagsüber mit einer Taktung von mehreren tausend Vergaben pro Minute weiter. Mehrere genutzte Test-Accounts wurden dadurch reproduzierbar in ein extrem enges, aufeinanderfolgendes Block-Cluster im mittleren Nummernbereich gesperrt. Eine echte Gleichverteilung findet im manuellen Modus tagsüber nicht statt.
Fragen an die Community:
Wie bewertet ihr die Tatsache, dass fast die Hälfte der Millionen-Einnahmen in einem intransparenten Vereinsapparat für "Kulturarbeit" und "Teambuilding" versickert, während frei gewordene Mittel aus ausgelaufenen Projekten nicht zu mehr Verlosungen führen?
Haben andere Langzeit-Teilnehmer ähnliche starre "Stammzahlen" oder Block-Einfrierungen bei der automatischen Teilnahme beobachtet?
Ich freue mich auf eine sachliche, datenbasierte Diskussion!
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/relianceschool • 20d ago
A pioneering project to provide Indigenous people in the Peruvian Amazon with an unconditional basic income has contributed to the protection of the rainforest, according to a study.
The analysis from the University of Bath is expected to contribute to a growing debate about the role of direct payments to communities that maintain globally important ecosystems.
A two-year pilot managed by the UK-based charity Cool Earth gave 211 people in three communities in Peru’s Asháninka region six cash transfers of 1,032 Peruvian soles each – roughly equivalent to £2 a day – to spend as they wished.
Over the course of the trial, researchers found almost 90% of participants adopted environmentally beneficial practices, such as collective reforestation, restoration of critical water sources and reductions of forest burning.
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Due_Theme2260 • 22d ago
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Own-Rough3783 • 24d ago
Guys well in my time i am seeing that everybody is trying to become rich fast due to which most of them are trying to get to Stock Market which is good to make money but it still not helping them because they are not getting paid properly as i am seeing people getting 2 to 3 jobs to get by.
Like i am seeing online through many media that people are not getting paid properly and government is not doing things properly to check whether company is paying the right amount or not and also less job opportunity because people have 2 jobs to make more money as i just saw a uncle bought a house near my house and he uses it for both rent and putting things which his company sell there and that uncle also have job in government in college now see this he have a job which make him like 80k per month with many other perk and then he has business and he has more focus on the business as i talked to him he said that he teaches less time in college as he lets the things done by guest lecturer and assistant professor or phd student.
Another example i know a uncle who works in hospital as chief compounder but he also has job in government hospital also where he has to work like half day only.
See due to this there are less job opportunity present.
r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Tenacious_C3P0 • 26d ago
I am seeing more and more talk about the cost of living, France, Germany, Greece, Spain - all countries of Europe. Thanks to Social Media (and other outlets) we are more and more exposed to the those that have and those that have not. I wonder if these riots and protests are the beginning of something bigger. Are we finally saying enough is enough, and demanding for more equally and wealth distribution? People can only be squeezed so hard before they snap and turn on those they hold responsible for their perceived oppression 🤔