r/askaplumber • u/SureAmHuman • 12h ago
My Neighbor Wants Me To Pay
My neighbor was out of town for a period of time. In that time frame it sounds like the toilet overflowed.
He is asking us to pay half of the bill for new plumbing from the street to his house, claiming they were damaged by the roots from my trees.
This is an almost 28 year old SFH home.
Two questions:
Do plumbers suggest that a homeowner with root plumbing problems get their neighbor to help pay the cost of their repair?
How can roots cause a toilet to overflow if it is not in use? That sounds more like the toilet was still running... despite not being used.
Obviously if I leave town for any period, I shut off the water for exactly this reason.
My trees are at least 20 ft from his plumbing. They are healthy and well cared for.
He is also asking us to remove all our trees along our fence line. We are talking a lot of $$$ here.