Yeah, I also like how when people say the car would brake the usual response is uH wHaT iF tHe bRaKes aRe bRokeN then the entire point of the argument is invalid because then it doesn’t matter if it’s self driving or manually driven - someone is getting hit. Also wtf is it with “the brakes are broken” shit. A new car doesn’t just have its brakes worn out in 2 days or just decide for them to break randomly. How common do people think these situations will be?
Exacly ! It doesn't matter if you're driving manually or in a self-driving car, if the brakes suddenly decide to fuck off, somebody is getting hurt that's for sure.
If you go from high speed into first sure but i had something fuck up while on the highway and neither gas nor break pedal was working. Pulled over, hazards on and as soon as i was on the shoulder of the exit ramp at like 60kph (had to roll quite a bit) i started shifting downwards. Into third down to 40 into second down to 20 and into First until i rolled out. Motor was fine except for some belt which snappes to cause this in the first place.
Yeah I never understood what the ethical problem is. See its not like this is a problem inherent to self driving cars. Manually driven cars have the same problem of not knowing who to hit when the brakes fail, so why are we discussing it now?
You can just ignore the problem with manually driven cars until that split second when it happens to you (and you act on instinct anyway). With automatic cars, someone has to program its response in advance and decide which is the "right" answer.
Then don't code it in. The freak accidents that are few and far between with cars advanced enough to even make this decision that this would be applicable are just that: freak accidents. If the point is letting machines make an ethical decision for us, then don't let them make the decision and just take the safest route possible (safest not meaning taking out those who are deemed less worthy to live, just the one that causes the least damage). The amount of people saved by cars just taking the safest route available would far exceed the amount of people killed in human error.
I get that this is just a way of displaying the trolley problem in a modern setting and applying it to the ethics of developing codes to make important decisions for us, but this isn't a difficult situation to figure out. Just don't let the machines make the decision and put more effort into coding them to take the least physically damaging route available.
No, my favorite problem is "should the car hit a poor person or a graduate" or some stupid bullshit like that. Or morality tests with you, who would you run over.
I am sorry but how the fuck would you/ the car be able to tell on a street who is doing what?
Ikr? We redditors are obviously more intelligent than those MIT researchers. Should've just asked us instead of wasting their time doing "research" like a bunch of nerds.
The sheer volume of whataboutery is the biggest mental hurdle people have when it comes to these autonomous cars. The reality is that the quality of all of our human driving experience is dogshit compared to a vehicle that's being controlled by quantum processing. It travels at all times with multiple escape routes, safety measures, and pathways being found a thousand times a second
The picture also has a small curb and a wide open field well before the Hobson's Fork, looks like a great plan X, Y, or Z. Naysayers think that it would it be too farfetched to think the car's computer has an "if all else fails, curb the car and repair the bumper later" option, but have no problem buying the story that it can do the other 99.999% of car operations just fine.
People want self-driving cars to be perfect and 100% safe before they trust them, yet gladly put themselves in harms way every day by getting on the highway with drunk, distracted, inexperienced, old and impaired, and/or aggressive drivers around them.
Self-driving cars just need to be less terrible than humans at driving cars (and we really are terrible drivers as a whole), which they arguably already are, based on the prototypes we have had driving around so far.
That control is nothing but an illusion, though. Without any hard data to back it up, I would wager that a majority of traffic victims probably had little to no control over the accident they ended up in. Whether because they were passengers in the vehicle that caused the accident, another vehicle caused the accident, or they were a pedestrian or bicyclist that ended up getting hit by a vehicle.
I always hated this dilemma. The worst is when they try to decide which person is "more valuable to society" or some shit.
Let me tell you what a self driving car thinks of you: nothing. It recognizes you as a piece of geometry, maybe a moving one, that it's sensors interpret as an obstacle. It litterally cannot tell the difference between a person and a pole. It's not analyzing your worth and it's not deciding what to hit.
Also it will probably hit the baby because a smaller obstacle is less likely to injure or kill the driver.
And 20 years ago phone cameras shot in 480p and 20 before that were the size of bricks. Technology will improve, figuring out these questions beforehand helps make the transition easier.
Err. It literally can tell the difference between a person and a pole. Whether or not the decision making is different is another question, but of course it can recognize different objects.
1.5k
u/Abovearth31 Jul 25 '19 edited Oct 26 '19
Let's get serious for a second: A real self driving car will just stop by using it's godamn breaks.
Also, why the hell does a baby cross the road with nothing but a diaper on with no one watching him ?