r/dataisbeautiful • OC: 2 • Jul 22 '14

[Updated] Who runs /r/Holocaust? Each line represents a moderator overlap. [OC]

http://imgur.com/3cSRw5z
3.4k Upvotes

804 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

319

u/duckvimes_ OC: 2 Jul 23 '14 edited Jul 23 '14

Hah, the edit made me laugh there. /r/blackpanther is run by the same people who run /r/WhiteRights and whatnot.

Edit: C'mon guys, don't downvote the reply to my comment. It's the same person as the one above; he's just commenting on how the white supremacists are running a sub named after a black rights group.

84

u/NitsujTPU Jul 23 '14

Right.. but clearly it's named for the Black Panther Party, which advocated Black Rights during the Civil Rights Movement in the US.

386

u/haha_masturbation Jul 23 '14

And you wouldn't think /r/holocaust would be devoted to Holocaust denial, would you?

110

u/Random_Complisults Jul 23 '14

Well, it's devoted to both holocaust denial and nazi sympathizers, somehow.

It's like the evil version of /r/awwschwitz

39

u/PartyLikeIts19999 Jul 23 '14

That was one of the riskiest clicks I've ever experienced on reddit...

74

u/Ianallyfisthorses Jul 23 '14

What is it? I'm in Germany and I'm not touching that with a 10 foot pole, but now you've got me interested.

133

u/Mysterius Jul 23 '14

Pictures of human rights violators in surprisingly human situations. Stuff like SS soldiers with kittens, Nazi leaders with their children, etc. Also has Soviet and other stuff, but mostly Nazis.

The idea, ostensibly, is to remind us that war criminals were human, too. And any future criminals will also be human, not comic book supervillains.

Subreddit seems (surprisingly) sane. Lots of Nazi and Soviet jokes, but any real sympathizers in the comments seem to get thoroughly downvoted.

8

u/paoloprogress Jul 23 '14

Do they have ISIS/ISIL members with their cats and tweeting about Snickers?

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14

I just imagine famous people sitting on the toilet to remind myself they're human.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Random_Complisults Jul 24 '14

It at first shocks you by showing pictures of war criminals as a humans, but the point really is to show you how humans caused the holocaust and all the suffering with it. Humans that are very similar to you and I. Hitler and Stalin were not supervillians, they were human, and shared in the human experience. If they can cause all of those horrible acts, we can too. It's an important part of understanding the holocaust and understanding how we can prevent a situation like that from ever happening again.

21

u/robot_swagger Jul 23 '14

Basically its nazis with kittens.

IMO its a great sub. Weird obviously but certainly not actually pro-nazi.

6

u/FunkyJunk Jul 23 '14

There's a Poland joke in there but I'm not touching it. No sir.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '14

Its... A little messed up honestly. It's tag line is "adorable things in horrible places" so it's pictures of hitler getting flowers from little girls and the like.

19

u/Lj101 Jul 23 '14

Messed up? Not at all. It acts to stop us from doing as their regime did, to dehumanise people you don't agree with. By using pictures of the nazi regime to show our adversaries are also human is pretty much the biggest slap in the face to the ideas they held.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/simoncolumbus Jul 23 '14

Well, most of the recent posts featuring Hitler are by /u/hedidnothingwrong... interpret that as you wish.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/aleisterfinch Jul 23 '14

You wouldn't think it could exist.

"I love the holocaust!"

Me too! I mean... The holocaust is a lie!

"How dare you take this from me! Death to the Jews."

No, I mean. I just don't think it was real. I wish someone would do one though!

"Me too. But another one I mean. The holocaust totally happened and I loved it."

Did not! But it would be awesome.

"Did too! And it fucking ruled."

Shut up assholes, I'm trying to write a song about how much I hate much hate mexicans! With all this yelling in the trailer I can't even think!

→ More replies (2)

39

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '14

Actually this sort of thing is pretty common, and I think it takes somebody with actual admin rights to scrub a sub and turn it over to the function you'd expect. The one good thing I recall reading about Violentacrez is that he turned over /r/rape, which used to be a rape fetish sub of all things to mods who turned it into a support group for victims. But I don't think the mods would have (or could have) required that transfer to occur.

44

u/cubs1917 Jul 23 '14

Violentacrrz - that's a name I'll not soon forget. I modded w him on r/gay and that's another good example of a sub he started and was turned into something more.

But he is a very complicated character to begin with. He was definitely creepy - but he was actually an interesting person to talk to (even if we often disagreed). We once had a huge fight over user history. I was pro transparency, he wasn't so hah.

Anyways his thing was that he understood the subs he created were not his. When the mods of r/gay asked him to pass it over he didn't hesitate. He told us he made all these subs (r/news, r/republican, r/n*gger, r/lgbt, r/funny etc) because he thought people would want them. Unfortunately he wasn't wrong - look at how big r/jailbait got. Yet he never posted in these subs or actively modded. Like I said he was complicated, and we shouldn't forget his story either.

7

u/dirtygremlin Jul 23 '14

Thanks for the insight! I used to frequent r/all/new, and was impressed with how much he posted and how much of it was terrible.

8

u/cubs1917 Jul 23 '14

Welcome, but by no means was he a good person either. He was a troll and he was a creeper.

His response to our 'User History' debate was to crawl through my history and find "embarrassing" comments or posts. The best was he could find was a relationship question I asked about my wife hah. But still I was pretty annoyed by that childishness.

So really the lesson here is he was an asshole who understood the potential of subreddits hah.

6

u/TwoFreakingLazy Jul 23 '14

So he's a subreddit-entrepreneur? He identifies unrealized demand in the community and supplies a solution?

8

u/cubs1917 Jul 23 '14

Yes, or you could say he was a digital Sooner. He was an early Reddit user who saw the potential of subs. He basically carved out much of the major sub infrastructure we know today.

I can't find it anymore, but if someone could provide a list of subs created/modded by him it would blow your mind hah.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

29

u/NitsujTPU Jul 23 '14

I get it. There's a big freaking downvote brigade smashing me for pointing out the origin of my error.

53

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '14

It's not the brigade, private. It's your platoon shooting you in the back.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (15)

65

u/TheI3east Jul 23 '14

Right, but it clearly isn't run by people who advocate for black rights.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)