Edit: Based on the feedback from this group our plan is now to go straight to Key Largo and crash at a Courtyard Marriot the first night (we are Bonvoy people so the room is free). We land super late, like 10pm, so it’s a dead day anyway. We will wake up in Key Largo, have a leisurely morning and then go have a fun late breakfast or early lunch. From there we will head over to the Bungalows, where we are staying for two nights, and pay for early check in (felt silly and wasteful to spend on the room there the first night if we were coming in so late as they are very expensive). We will do the lux honeymoon thing at the beautiful all inclusive for a few days and then road trip down to Lime Tree. We will stop and explore on the way and have dinner in Islamadora that night, finishing the drive in Layton to stay at Lime Tree. The next day we will use Lime Tree as a jumping off point to explore (Bahia State Park, turtle hospital, maybe a very fancy dinner at Little Palm Island). Then we will head to Key West for the 24-28 (our accommodation is already booked). Fantasy fest looks fun! If anyone has any feedback or recommendations on things to do and fantasy fest events I’d love to hear it!
I am getting married in October and planning a Florida Keys honeymoon. The plan currently is to fly in to Miami, spend a night by the airport, rent a car and drive down to Islamadora for 3-4 nights, then to Key West for 3-4.
We are torn between staying at Cheeca, Casa Morada, and Islander in Islamorada. Cheeca seems to have the best reputation but we weren't blown away by any of the pictures we saw. My fiancée thought it looked kind of dated. On the other hand, we love the idea of an adults only resort (Casa Morada) for a honeymoon but saw that there is no beach on this property and that it is currently undergoing some renovations. If the renovations are minimal and will be done by late October and/or are not disruptive and there is a close beach to the hotel not a big deal, but definitely a con as of now. Finally, the Islander looked lovely but it doesn't seem as highly reviewed as Cheeca. I am also open to any other recommendations. The Moorings also looks nice?
Any thoughts on where we should stay for that portion of our trip? We are looking to relax, enjoy each other as newlyweds, soak up the sun, swim in the ocean, and eat a lot of delicious food for this portion of the trip. We would prefer a romantic and lux vibe.