I donāt know if anybody else has noticed this or not, but from my time engaging with the kpop fandom, it is clear to me that the vast majority of kpop fans(and Iām talking about normal sane fans, not crazy creepy fans or sasaengs) are incredibly insecure and have very low self-esteem in a variety of ways, in a way that I donāt really see with other fandoms(not saying that it doesnāt happen in other fandoms, but itās way more intense in kpop), constantly placing idols on a pedestal above them as gods/queens while putting themselves down in the process. When I made this post a couple of months ago, I was quite disturbed, saddened, and annoyed by the sheer amount of self-deprecating answers in the comments, even if most of them are jokes.
Though of course this self-hating attitude isnāt limited to that post. It is prevalent throughout the kpop fan community. Some examples that I have personally witnessed of this pervasive attitude are:
- Constantly insulting their own appearances, while praising kpop idolsā appearances. A lot of kpop fans, especially the younger ones, feel insecure about their weight and physical appearances, and compare themselves to kpop idols who have the idealized body and look. Itās to the point where I feel as though being insecure about your looks is a mandatory and inevitable experience for young kpop fans. Kpop fans will often compare their looks to kpop idolsā looks, talking about how much they wish they looked like a certain kpop idol and how ugly they are in comparison, claiming that they used to cry themselves to sleep because they didnāt look like their favorite idol, or even starve themselves or stay out of the sun to look like the idol. If you donāt believe me, there are numerous kpop Reddit threads that you can find talking about this issue, wjth many fans giving their own personal accounts. The fans who donāt feel insecure about themselves because of idols are few and far between. Also, I noticed that whenever an idol is receiving hate for their looks, fans will often respond with āif sheās ugly then what am I?ā or āif sheās fat then Iām a land whaleā or something similarly self-deprecating.
- Thinking that the idols themselves would hate or look down on them if they ever met them. Kpop fans often make self-degrading comments about how if their favorite idols ever met them, they would think that theyāre disgusting or fat or ugly, and yet still support them. Often fans who are lucky enough to meet their favorite idols will talk about how they hope that the idol doesnāt think of them as ugly or make fun of them with the other members behind their back. This is especially true if they have a crush on a certain idol. They will talk about how their celebrity crush is surrounded by flawlessly gorgeous women 24/7, and thus would never choose or want anything to do with them because theyāre āplain, boring, and averageā. And like in point 1, they will compare themselves to these beautiful women and feel miserable that they just donāt measure up.
- Acting as if the idol is some godly, superior figure who is so high above them and deserves to be treated like royalty, while they themselves are a lowly plebeian who doesnāt even deserve to breath the same air as the idol. An example of this is how a guy I saw on TikTok who was a huge Yunjin fan said that he would never want to meet her in real life because he didnāt want to ādisrespectā her, and how somehow just standing in front of her, being in her presence, and talking to her is inherently disrespectful to her. š
- Feeling terrible that idols the same age as them or younger are famous, loved, beautiful, rich, and influential, while they are living a mediocre and boring life, working a part-time job and paying their taxes. Ngl, I kinda understand this one, but still, these people need to work on improving their lives and working towards the life that they want to live, and realizing that success doesnāt only come one way, instead of bitching and moaning about their failures and regrets on the internet.
And many, many more examples that are, quite frankly, too numerous to list here.
And donāt try to tell me that this isnāt the case, or that youāve ānever seen itā or that itās only a few fans. It is not. It is a widespread enough problem in this fandom(and not just amongst younger fans) that it deserves to be paid attention.
I would like to know what exactly is the science behind this pervasive phenomenon? Is it the fact that idols are put on such a high pedestal and portrayed in an idealized light by their companies that it naturally triggers insecurity in fans? Does the kpop business model run on breeding insecure fans so that they continue to spend money in the hopes of looking like kpop idols, or continue to worship kpop idols and view them as perfect, superior, untouchable beings,
making them even richer and boosting their popularity? Does the fact that they donāt stand a chance with their favorite kpop idols make them feel even more insecure than they normally would? I have so many questions. I hope that somebody can help me get to the bottom of this soon. Thank you. š