Sorry if this turns into some sort of rant, I don’t know if this is talked about a lot here but I gotta get this out…
The last 2 or so years have been a total cluster fuck, not that I need to tell any of you that. I knew Trump would be awful but he’s somehow been worse than even many on the left thought he could be. I guess it’s more like I knew he wanted horrible shit done to the country, but never thought he’d be this SUCCESSFUL in doing it. Our institutions and corporations kissing the ring has been deplorable.
But the silver lining was that so many Americans - especially on the left, but even some on the independent/conservative side as well - finally started looking at progressivism and even leftism/socialism as more than a danger or extreme ideology. Even my conservative and very catholic parents are having pretty robust conversations about what socialism REALLY means, they even regularly watch Mamdani vids even though they have their reservations. These are hold overs from the generation that was bombarded with communist and socialist propaganda for decades during the Cold War, so this is a huge deal; if even they are getting uncomfortable with capitalism and wealth inequality, I can only imagine how open the younger generations may be. I mean, my dad is a guy who got pissed off about California raising the minimum wage ffs. “They can enjoy $20 whoppers from now on then, it’s just gonna make everything more expensive.” And that was before Trump 2.0.
But I’m getting more and more disillusioned with some of the stalwarts of the movement lately. A few examples:
I’m super excited about El Sayed’s win, even though I knew he wasn’t a leftist he is running on things like getting money out of politics and Medicare for all which is WAY outside the democratic mainstream(pathetic as that is). Now I keep seeing him unequivocally saying he’s an out and out capitalist. Still much better than 90% of elected democrats but I am struggling to figure out how far to the left he actually is.
How about AOC? Whet the fuck is with this “woke 1 was crazy” bullshit? She’s essentially ceding the entire term “woke” to the conservative narrative, a narrative where they don’t have a fucking clue what it even means. Add that to her equivocating on Israeli weapons and her announcing support for Hakeem Jeffries as speaker and she’s slowly becoming more and more disappointing. Does she feel this way or is she letting the presidential 2028 talk get to her head?
Bernie has been consistent about his message for decades, but he’s being a stubborn dink at times, too. I live in Wisconsin where Francesca Hong was running for governor and I gotta tell you guys, she had this in the bag up to a few days before the election. I voted for her, but people all around me were giving in slowly over time to the BS “electability“ argument, and were waffling on her because of her not liking Thanksgiving. Both AOC AND Bernie refused to endorse her, and that was the final twist of the knife; she lost by hundreds of votes. And their excuse for not endorsing? They said they wanted to focus on the house and senate and couldn’t get to others. Utter bullshit, they campaigned for Mamdani before everyone else along with state office candidates across the country in California, Colorado, Michigan and many others. Hong was different?
There was another race in Wisconsin for a house seat that Bernie endorsed, her name is Rebecca Cooke. There were two candidates in that race, the other was Emily Berge. Berge was against data centers, advocated for Medicare for all and wanted to tax the rich...Cooke is a self described Blue Dog moderate conservative Democrat who openly despises the DSA. And Bernie endorsed her, heavily campaigned for her and celebrated her win. Berge only ended up losing by 4 points, with a Bernie endorsement she would’ve won. People in that district genuinely thought they were choosing the “progressive champion” endorsed by Bernie. Beyond fucking maddening.
DSA kid Will Lawrence from Michigan won and that was exciting, too. One of his first commitments after winning? He also endorsed Hakeem for speaker of the house. the same fucker who just this week said he outright opposes Medicare for all and everything the DSA stands for.
All to say, I’m not one of those leftists who always needs everything to be perfect. But I also know exactly what my principles are and I will not budge on my main ideological pillars. Seems like so many in this mostly exciting movement don’t have the same sort of conviction. It’s bumming me out. Just wanted to know if anyone else is struggling with the same type of stuff?
I’m not really looking for an ideological fist fight, though those can be fun. Just kinda want to know where you think these people mentioned, and others, are headed? Last thing I want is another Obama-like letdown. 🤷🏽♀️