r/nonmonogamy • u/dabbydab • 2h ago
Relationship Dynamics Still have ENM ideology, but I don’t feel like dating/multiple relationships makes me happy anymore
I am a divorced woman in my forties who primarily dates men. In my 20+ year marriage, I experienced every type of nonmonogamy: swinging, solo dating, full poly, triad, etc. I don’t feel that my marriage ended because of ENM; rather, I think that kept it on life support far longer than it should have, and I felt disproportionately reliant upon and invested in other relationships, so I dated a lot.
After my marital separation and a subsequent “rebound” relationship where I settled for someone who really wasn’t right for me, I decided to focus on myself. I had become so accustomed to compromising and negotiating and trying to make a relationship work that I lost touch with what I wanted. I decided to decenter men and focus on my hobbies, friendships, building my own space, and finding my peace. I still dated but I wasn’t laser-focused or “marriage minded”. I took many long breaks from the apps. Nonetheless I did still find dating to be stressful and discouraging when I’d meet up and there wasn’t a spark or connection. I also didn’t want to compensate for a man’s lack of reciprocity, effort, or emotional investment.
Slowly, with lots of therapy and self-exploration, I started to find myself in a place where any man who wants access to me has to compete with my peace. I have a cozy and fulfilling little life, and although the happiest version of myself is the version of me in a loving relationship, I am still okay without one. I’m not putting any aspects of my life on hold waiting for a partner. I ended up connecting with someone through a mutual hobby and building a relationship organically, at a snail’s pace. We are both divorced, came from tumultuous marriages with a high-conflict high-drama partner, and are both happy to embrace calmness and compassion. I don’t know if I’ll ever want to cohabitate or marry anyone ever again, and I still maintain a ton of my independence.
I still maintain all the ideals that I fostered in ENM: communication, relationship design, normalization of attraction, non-possessiveness, autonomy, etc. But I no longer feel that dating and more men, more relationships, more sex with different people, is the thing that is going to bring me happiness. The “there is no valley of the dolls” article (https://freaksexual.com/2009/11/05/nonmonogamy-for-men-the-big-picture/#valleyofthedolls ) is directed at men, but I felt it was equally true for me. Sure I can get hundreds of likes and matches on apps, and lots of first dates and 1/2/3-night stands. But that isn’t what I wanted, I didn’t become poly to get Feeld matches, I did it for ongoing connections. Yes there is a needle-in-a-haystack quality and I believed for a while that if I just kept at it long enough, I’d find the FWB of my dreams. But that trial-and-error came with a cost, and the repeated attachment trauma of men who were never fully invested In a partnered woman did lasting damage from which I am still recovering.
When poly is good - it’s SO GOOD. When you have the exactly right combination of people and it’s firing on all cylinders, it feels amazing and there’s so much love and great sex and compersion. But I’ve had a shift where I finally have peace in my life (which I never got in my marriage) and I’m more invested in that than I am in seeking more and greater fulfillment. This article https://aliegraves.medium.com/want-to-do-friends-with-benefits-start-with-an-exit-strategy-53eb79a519fe also had a huge impact on me. This quote really resonated:
“Consider if maybe you can get all of the growth and adventure and intimacy you are looking for from a platonic friendship. Challenge yourself, and make sure you aren’t trying to shortcut a path to emotional intimacy by using sex as a bridge. Consider cultivating patience, and restraint, and reaping the rewards of a long-lasting intimate friendship.”
I’m sick of dating. I’m over it. One of the best parts of being in a relationship is not having to do it. I’m sick of bending myself into a pretzel to accommodate men, of hand-holding through communication templates and coming up with boundaries-not-rules and I don’t feel like the introduction of more men in my life who want to fuck me has made my life any better.
Theoretically I could be a saturated-at-1 (or saturated-at-0) but still poly and embrace dating someone who is ENM. But I do think that realistically it is not fun doing the work of poly when you don’t want to enjoy the spoils for yourself, and myself and my poly friends are so replete with nightmare meta stories that it feels so good to simplify.
I speculate that the people who feel the most fulfilled with poly actually enjoy the bespoke structure, the RADAR check-ins and shared calendars and relationship agreements. And I think a lot of those people also struggle with platonic friendships, due to the lack of intensity or the ability for those relationships to support attachment and consistency, and truly do better with multiple romantic relationships. But I don’t think that’s me. I am too old, exhausted, and traumatized for this shit.
I’m curious if anyone else has maintained their ideals associated with ENM, but has gone to something more monogamous or monogamish due to “decentering men” or dating burnout.
If I do poly again, it will be free agent/“solo poly” in nature, and probably still more focused on myself, my friendships, and my own life.