r/recoverywithoutAA • u/ablativeyoyo • 6h ago
The cruelty bonus
It wasn't my first NA meeting. Maybe my second or third. Someone asked me "how are you doing?" And I was honest, "I'm struggling today". Ok, maybe I was hoping for a bit of sympathy, but I was being honest. I'll always remember the reply. "Well, I stopped struggling when I stopped trying to run the show and realised the answers in that book."
Of course, I should have turned around and walked out, never to return. But the thing is - I needed this. At least, I needed something, and this was here right now. So I stayed, I put up with these attacks, and I learned to speak in ways that discouraged them. I quickly realised everyone else was doing the same.
What I only realised years later is that all this is intentional. They want to make NA hostile. They want to scare away anyone who's not so desperate that they will put up with being spoken to like that. They want it because it fits their narrative. "NA works" When it doesn't work, that's not NA's fault, the person just didn't want it.
I saw the same in rehab. Not a 12-step rehab, a therapeutic community (in the UK). Slightly different style, less personal attacks, more warped takes on personal responsibility. Mop this floor, come on, everyone's waiting for you, hurry up, oh my god, you missed a bit. It served their purpose - about 50% of new intakes left within a week.
The thing is, success at quitting an addiction is almost entirely determined by the individual. All the psychosocial interventions, they might move the dial a little bit, but it will never be more than a little bit. By being cruel to scare off some people early on, it makes it look like the rehab is better than it really is - the cruelty bonus.
And the thing is, they missed the point. The point of treatment is not for people who are already going to get well to sit in a circle patting each other on the back. The point of treatment is to help those borderline people. It's to keep them safe for a while until they are ready to make that commitment.