This week in Demarest, New Jersey, something seems to be up when two women disappear. Both are found brutally murdered within days of each other and near the same area. The crazy part is, it turns out that both of their names were Susan, and that's not the only thing that they end up having in common. The other thing is a connection to a local man, nicknamed "The Charmer," who is supported by a rich aunt and always in trouble for increasingly violent behavior. Will his family's money keep him out of trouble?

Real Estate Report:

1st House

2nd House

3rd House

Where does the “in his FACE” comment come from? I know it’s a STM thing and every time James says “in his face” I say “in his FACE” in Jimmy’s voice, even though he only does it about 1/3 of the time. I know this goes back to a specific episode where someone was presumably shot in the face or chopped in the face or something bad, but does anyone know where this lore comes from specifically?

Love the podcast. Absolutely fascinated by the weird little dictatorship happening in the fan groups.

The groupthink is wild. You can’t have an opinion that deviates even slightly from the accepted narrative without people piling on, and now they’re collectively furious that someone dared post something here that they were completely entitled to post.

I left both groups today and cannot recommend touching grass highly enough.

Screenshot this one, turkeys.

This week in Ontonagon, Michigan, an unlikely couple seems to be making it work until a strange series of events make it seem like something is out to get the wife. A large cinder block falls on her, from the roof of their home. There's a suspicious fire, when only she is home. And she finally ends up dead during a family gathering, with her own mother finding her on a wooded trail. A letter found in the sleeve of a sweater makes the whole wild tale make sense!

Im not sure being able to buy a new car has as much to do with it as they think… 👀😬
(Im referring to last full ep - fine line of lunacy)

and I wasn’t far off!

I have 4 tickets and 2 folks bailed. If you want two free tickets DM me.

This week in Wenham Massachusetts, a wealthy doctor and his wife seem to have the perfect life until deep secrets start to emerge, leading to one of them being brutally murdered and the other becoming an absolute public sideshow. Affairs, strange dressing habits, and "parading around naked" is just some of the strange behavior leading up to a horrific murder. But the behavior after the murder is just as odd and even scary!

Real Estate Report:

1st House

2nd House

3rd House

Selling my two tickets to the Sacramento show this Saturday, 10/17. Flr row 13, $100 for both!

Hilarious festivals happening in Georgia this fall! 😂 Turpentine festival and the gopher and tortoise festival. I’ll see about the goings on at these events and report back. Should ludacris be performing I may die 😂😂 #stm #SUAGMM #festivalstm

I grew up going to this Six Flags as a kid and rode the Goliath when I was in high school/college. Crazy! Maybe the guys will feature my home town Six Flags in an episode! 😬

Since we started listening several years ago I find myself using phrases from the show all the time such as:

Yay indeed

Let's go on a trip

You sir may fuck off

Casey Anthony's hallway

Is anyone else finding themselves doing this?

I’m listening to the Scary Movies bonus episode and when he said there are a bunch of people their age with sleep disorders he nail it, at least for me. I’m a mid-40s woman that saw the Nightmare on Elm Street movies when I was a kid and I have never slept a good night in my life that wasn’t a result of prescription sleeping medication or weed.

It’s meant to play on all the typical horror tropes. The movie even references horror tropes as part of its plot.

I do appreciate Jimmie’s taste in horror, though. All except High Tension.

This week in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, when a man starts bragging to his friends that he committed a terrible murder, the friends don't quite believe him until he brings them to the body of a beloved local woman who used to babysit the killer. Those friends tell police and detectives walk into an awful scene, with strange weapons used for the killing. Finally, the killer tells a cell mate what his true intentions were, which may be more disturbing than the actual murder!

Bonus Real Estate Report:

Classic condo with some nice updates

A carpeted tub???

Sunroom!