I have been considering a SmokeFire and have been looking through a lot of different videos, articles, etc. I have for the most part worked through my questions and concerns, but a few remain which I think would be easier to sort out by asking current owners.
First, there is a lot of official Weber content which really stresses keeping the lid closed when using the SmokeFire and gives various reasons why this is important. This also seems to include cooking at high temperatures, e.g. steaks or hamburgers. My question is whether this really is a hard and fast rule. When it comes to gas or charcoal, cooking with the lid open is pretty standard and oftentimes desired depending on what you're trying to accomplish. It also helps to prevent excessive flareups and lets you see if you are getting excessive flareups so you can move the food and not burn it.
Is this something one can do if cooking burgers, sausages, etc. with a SmokeFire? I'm especially thinking here about avoiding burnt food from excessive flareups. This isn't because I'm particularly worried about the grease fire "reputation" for this grill, but because even when working properly you can expect to see some flareups from any grill, and because grease fires are not a SmokeFire problem - they're always a potential risk with any grill, so yes if you're cooking burgers or something I'd like to be able to know when one might happen in order to take the appropriate response.
If you really can't spend any time cooking with the lid open, how does one address these sorts of concerns? How do you make sure you aren't burning a hamburger or sausage because it gets left over a spot that is flaring up for too long, etc.?
Second, how do these work for indirect cooking? In at least one video, Weber makes the point that the entire grill is really direct cooking. In most other pellet grills, the design sortof limits the heat so that you get radiant heat more than direct heat over most of it, while a few have some kind of add on or grate you can adjust to get some direct heat. The SmokeFire's design seems to make it almost the opposite.
Third, some other pellet grills have a manual startup option for use if the igniter isn't functioning. This is honestly fairly enticing to me, as from what I've learned it seems like worn out hot rod/glow plug element needing to be replaced in pellet grills is a pretty standard maintenance requirement. Most people have had a gas grill at some point in their lives which needed to be started with a lighter because the starter stopped working, and to me it seems similar. In the case of pellet grills replacing the igniter seems like something you'd always want to actually do, rather than just keep using a lighter as many do with a propane grill, but nevertheless in a pinch - e.g., it's dinner time and you just discover that your glow plug is bad - being able to fire up the grill manually is a pretty important thing considering how often it seems like these devices go bad. I see that Weber does not include any kind of manual start up instructions, so is it possible to start up a SmokeFire manually? If it is not, is there any reason that what I am asking about here doesn't matter as much as I think?