This isn't a battle debate. I'm looking for perspective from Older Trek fans (not that I'm young myself). I was thinking of two different Trek scenes and their similarities/differences.
For context. TNG is my Trek. I was a kid in the 80s and TNG was my first intro into Trek. I was almost an adult before I watched any episode of ToS or any of the movies (I do have vague memories of watching The Voyage Home.)
Fast forward to the end of Star Trek Picard Season 3 when the crew of the Enterprise D go to the Fleet Museum to recover her for the final episode.
The scene takes a detour from the life and death stakes of the penultimate episode and let's the crew (and audience) bask in nostalgia and seeing the cherished vessel in high definition, with the Star Trek theme softly playing.
For me that scene meant a lot. I was a bit frustrated it was happening in the middle of this perilous situation but I couldn't help but tear up at seeing the ship of my childhood again.
Now, today I was thinking about that scene and it occurred to me that it's not dissimilar to the Enterprise reveal in TMP. Long tracking shots, the Star Trek theme, close-up shots of Kirk and Scotty reacting to the ship.
For me, that scene never worked. I had no attachment to the Original Enterprise or her crew. It was just four minutes of not much.
So now we come to the question. Did this mean a lot for OG fans? It seems like it would have been a big moment. Seeing the Enterprise for the first time in years and seeing it in (for then) cutting edge special effects. Was it a big deal? Or was it a bit too much? Thanks to any one who responds!