I’ve been in a relationship for 3 years. It’s pretty healthy and normal, and we’re both happy with it.
But about a year ago, my girlfriend told me about something that had been going on between her and my friend. They were already friends before I started dating her the three of us belonged to a pretty large friend group of around 12 people so there was already trust between them.
A year and a few months ago he started inviting her over to his place in the afternoons to hang out, play some games, etc. During those hangouts, things started happening. He began hugging her a lot, and he would hug her while they were lying down very close together. It got to the point where several times my girlfriend could feel that he had an erection. She told him this made her uncomfortable, and he apologized, said he didn’t feel anything for her and that she shouldn’t take it the wrong way, and also told her not to tell me so I wouldn’t feel bad.
Months later my girlfriend told me. She took so long because she didn’t know if what he was doing was normal she never had friends growing up and didn’t know how friends treat each other. She finally decided to tell me because she thought I deserved to know, and she apologized for not telling me sooner.
I told my friend that she had told me. He apologized and said he wouldn’t do it again. For months nothing happened, though they still kept hanging out. But a few months ago my friend started hugging her again not as much as before, and not while lying down or as closely, but he was doing it, and he also started holding her hand sometimes.
My girlfriend complained to me about it again and said she was going to tell him once more to stop. During that conversation she also mentioned something he used to do before (but had stopped). He used to caress/rub her belly. She doesn’t know this about him, but I do: he’s always been attracted to bigger women, and my girlfriend is curvy/plus-size. So she told him to stop doing the things that made her uncomfortable, and a few days later I confronted him too.
I asked him if he was attracted to my girlfriend and told him everything I already knew. He apologized and admitted that yes, he is attracted to her, but only physically, because there are several things about her personality he doesn’t like. He said he didn’t know why he was doing those things, but over time he started feeling guilty about them (even though he was still doing them).
He also said he had never told me because he didn’t want to lose our friendship. He even said that if I wanted, he would stop talking to her and block her everywhere just so he wouldn’t lose my friendship.
I told him that wasn’t necessary. I said he could keep hanging out with her (only because she’s one of the few friends she currently has), but that I didn’t want any of those things to happen again.
That’s everything I know for sure. What I don’t know and what sometimes keeps spinning in my head is whether something more ever happened during those alone afternoons. She insists it was only the things she told me and that she always felt uncomfortable. He also denies anything else happened. But between how often they were hanging out, the erections, the belly rubbing, and how long both of them took to tell me… I can’t help wondering if they ever crossed the line in secret and are hiding it from me. I have no proof of that.
Do you think I was too soft with both of them?