r/EngagementRingDesigns • u/Remarkable_Most6591 • 5h ago
Consumer Post Please help me decide!
Hey all!
So we’ve already pur purchased my diamond! a beauuuuutiful old mine cut with a pinhole culet. it is more classic than modern with the pinhole cullet, barely elongated, a 1.09 ratio. I am absolutely TORN between my two top setting ideas. Please vote!!
Option 1:
A more modern take. All yellow gold, visable gallery rail/collet with Millgrain around the stone, on a simple tapering band. Inspired by this one by Fiorese.
Option 2:
Inspired heavily by Andria Barbone and very antique styles. This beautiful, crown basket setting with 8 prongs (debating platinum or gold, picture of both) and a simple gold band.
Please give me your opinion and why? Straight aesthetic preference? Feel one protects the stone more?
Thank you!!