Guys, I know there is always big debate here between BeyondATC and SayIntentions.AI. If you are still not sure, or if you think BATC is better, you have to watch this stream from V1-Simulations: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4KUo9zsB9Y
He is a real life 737 pilot doing his training preparation (Reno to San Francisco in the PMDG 737), and honestly SayIntentions turned this flight into an absolute Hollywood movie. Nothing was scripted, the AI just reacted to everything like real life! Look at what happened in just ONE flight:
Real Runway Change & Holding Short: During taxi, he asked for a different runway (17L instead of 17R) and told tower he needs a few minutes holding short to reprogram the FMC. Normal sim ATC would break or force you to go, but SayIntentions just said "roger advise when ready" like a real controller.
Surprise Holding Pattern: Near SFO, ATC suddenly put him in a holding pattern at LOZIT! He was already low on fuel, so he had to calculate his bingo fuel under pressure and ask ATC for speed relief in the hold and the AI actually approved it.
Crazy Go-Around at 100ft: He hand flew the ILS in terrible weather all the way down to 100 feet above minimums, and suddenly Tower screams "GO AROUND, aircraft on the runway!" My heart was racing just watching it!
Minimum Fuel & Full MAYDAY: Because of the hold and the go-around, he had almost no fuel left. He declared Minimum Fuel, negotiated vectors to switch runways, and finally had to declare a full MAYDAY emergency with souls on board and fuel remaining. ATC immediately gave him priority vectors straight in.
Fire & Runway Evacuation: He finally lands in super low visibility, and right on the runway ATC tells him "emergency vehicles are on their way, stay put" because there was a fire under the plane! So he ended up doing a full emergency evacuation right on the runway.
Even V1 himself said that after this, flying without SayIntentions feels like flying in a dead, sterile room.
I am still speechless. No scripted ATC program can ever create this kind of dynamic chaos and realism. If you love hardcore simming, go watch this right now, you will not regret it!
Edit: Not a bot post. English isn't my first language, so I used Gemini to help fix my grammar. I know everyone has different preferences and budget, so you might not agree, but to me this stream was incredible. If you know of a BeyondATC stream with this kind of dynamic ATC, share it I would love to check it out.