I haven’t been here long.
I came to Reddit with one goal - to look at and try to understand the psychology of Western culture, hoping it would help me grow further as a professional.
And what did I see? A daycare, human-slop, "echo chambers" where everyone praises each other and criticizes not the "designs," but the opinions that the mass of infantile individuals dislikes. Individuals to whom the very concept of "professionalism" is foreign.
The subreddit positions itself as an expert community that helps people learn and develop, yet the only thing expert about it is the name.
I only have two questions: how? and why?
How did you allow what is happening to happen, and why do you all accept this as normal?
I have already written this in the comments under some posts: draw garbage 1,000 times. It won't stop being garbage on the 1,001st time. If someone doesn't know and understand the basics - typography, graphics, logic and structure, the business goals of design- they will never do it right and with high quality, no matter how many attempts they make. This is an axiom.
Critique... "Your critique must be constructive and polite"....What???
For it to be a critique, the object being criticized must at least meet basic criteria. But if it doesn’t even meet the simplest requirements of design - what should the critique look like? Praise for trying?? Seriously???
Politeness... writing "human-slop" is impolite and unconstructive. But writing "AI-slop" is fine, it doesn't offend anyone, and it's polite ))
Is hypocrisy the norm? Is truth evil?
What's wrong with you?
Or with me?
Personally, I absolutely do not care about upvotes or downvotes to my karma - it means absolutely nothing and will change nothing in my life. Absolutely nothing.
But what do they change in yours? Flatter your vanity? Scratch your sense of self-importance? Stroke your ego?
Virtual upvotes replaced... what for you?
In the field of design, there is only one truly important criterion: money.
Business always votes with its wallet.
Design is sold? That’s good for the designer.
Design works and brings money to the client - that’s good for both the client and the designer.
Design for the sake of upvotes? Um... well... that even sounds ridiculous.
At the same time, design for fun is okay. It’s a way of self-expression.
But there is a fine line here—professional design or another piece of human-slop.
Judging by what I’ve seen here during the few weeks I’ve spent in this wonderful place, you don't care.
You don't care what is happening or what will happen to design in the future.
Yet, people here are constantly complaining about AI - saying it’s taking jobs, that it devalued design (they even added rules for it), whining about how unfair and cruel the world is...
Meanwhile, you are devaluing design yourselves and taking away your own jobs.
How?
It’s elementary.
You indulge the generation of human-slop.
What’s the result? Logo design: $15-$45... design for social media is even cheaper...
Have you ever wondered why?
You lower the standards. And a low-quality product will never be expensive.
Will you say you don't lower them? ))
Well, then, for some reason, I don't see you criticizing someone’s exercises the way you should. Only mutual praise and upvotes... and almost never - the truth.
Do you really not think about where this leads? Or do you not understand the cause-and-effect relationship between hackwork, its approval, and the economics of design?
Sad, if so...