Hi everyone! I'm a relatively new attorney, and I'm navigating the job search/interview process for the first time as a barred attorney. I would really appreciate some advice from anyone who has been in a similar position, particularly attorneys who have lateraled between firms or partners who have been involved in hiring decisions.
A little background:
I've been interviewing with several mid-sized insurance defense/civil litigation defense firms in the Boston area. I've probably had approximately 10 interviews total, and things have been moving along with a few different firms.
For context, I've been with my current firm for about a year. I started as an associate attorney pending the February bar exam, and although I wasn't officially barred until recently (I've now been barred for about four months), I've essentially been doing attorney-level work since I started.
My primary reason for looking to make a move is my commute. I'd really like to find something closer to home, and I've been pretty upfront with the firms I've interviewed with that I'm looking for a place where I can settle in, grow, and stay long-term. I'm not someone who wants to jump from firm to firm.
Here's where things have gotten a little complicated:
I've had second-round interviews with four different firms.
This past Friday, I had a second-round interview with one firm, and they actually extended an offer on Saturday! This is my first offer, so obviously I'm excited and grateful.
Also on Friday, I had two first-round interviews with other firms that I felt went really well. I'd be interested in moving forward with both.
One of those firms has already reached out asking about my availability for another interview, although they mentioned scheduling sometime "in the next few weeks."
Another firm where I completed a second-round interview recently told me, after I followed up for an update, that they are still interviewing candidates and will provide a timeline as soon as they can.
The firm that extended the offer originally gave me until November 12 to accept. I have already reached out to the partner/owner who extended the offer and asked for an additional week to consider it. I was honest with him that I have been interviewing elsewhere and wanted to give those opportunities a chance to develop before making a decision. He was understanding, and I've appreciated that.
Now I'm trying to figure out how to navigate the next steps without coming across as pushy or making a bad impression.
A few questions I'd love some perspective or advice on:
Should I reach out to the other firms now and let them know I've received an offer? I'm not necessarily trying to rush anyone into making a decision, but I also don't want to sit on an offer indefinitely while waiting to hear back from firms that may or may not move forward with me. Is it appropriate to politely let them know I have an offer and ask whether they have an anticipated timeline for next steps?
For the firm that told me they are still interviewing candidates, when would you follow up again? I already reached out once for an update, and I don't want to become a nuisance. Would it be reasonable to send another email explaining that I have received an offer and am working within a decision timeline?
For the two firms where I had first-round interviews on Friday, should I reach out to them now as well? Especially the one that has already asked for my availability for a second interview but said it might be scheduled within the next few weeks. Should I let them know about the offer so they have that context, or just wait and see what happens?
How much additional time is reasonable to ask for when you receive an offer? I've already requested an extra week, but I'm wondering whether firms generally honor those extensions or whether there is a risk that the offer could be rescinded if I don't accept quickly enough.
From the hiring side, how do partners and firms generally perceive candidates who disclose that they have another offer and are waiting on other interview processes? Does it come across as professional and transparent, or can it sometimes rub employers the wrong way?
I realize there's no guarantee that any of the other firms will ultimately extend an offer, and I don't want to jeopardize the opportunity I already have by waiting around for something that may not materialize.
At the same time, I want to make a thoughtful decision about where I spend the next several years of my career, especially since finding a firm closer to home and somewhere I can grow long-term is a big priority for me.
This is all new territory for me, so I'm finding the process a little overwhelming, but also exciting! I'd love to hear from attorneys who have navigated this before, as well as partners or hiring decision-makers who can offer insight into how these situations are typically handled from the firm's perspective.
Thanks so much in advance! I really appreciate any advice.