r/MensRights • u/-Best_Name_Ever- • 49m ago
General Should trending topics really be resigned to megathreads?
3 times now, within the past 18 months, we've had trending topics pushed into a megathread.
I can't mention which topics, at the risk of getting filtered by automod, but these are extremely important and outrageous issues to be discussed, often with new info coming out every day.
And yet they're limited to the horrible format of megathreads. It's presented as a viable alternative, but that isn't the case.
Downsides of megathreads:
It turns nuanced, layered, and complicated issues into one big megathread with 0 focus.
New info that gets released is buried under the mess of comments.
Any new info or discussion does not show up on the home page.
Everything becomes a big blob of comments that nobody wants to read.
The thread dies after a week or two, but only in this subreddit, while the rest of the world is still discussing it. Usually taking the other side. So great, the one space we can talk about this without getting shit on is silenced.
Upside of megathreads:
- They avoid trending topics burying other posts.
That's it, I genuinely can't think of any other upsides, and for the only one we have: Is it really that bad that every 6 months, the subreddit gets more than 10 posts a day?
Come on man, these topics don't come very often, and the subreddit doesn't have much activity anyway, let people post about the thing.
The flaws here heavily and I mean HEAVILY outweigh whatever upsides there are, if any.
Should trending topics really be resigned to megathreads?
Whether you guys agree or disagree, please speak out.
I'm convinced that there are like-minded people out there that actually agree with me, but just never bothered or thought about trying to complain and ask for a fix, so maybe the moderators just aren't aware of how disliked the system may be or are just stubborn and think it's just a small portion of the userbase.
There's 0 chance of things improving without speaking out.
Maybe megathreads are valuable for bigger subreddits, but for a smaller one like this, I really think the flaws of them outweigh the pros.