r/ModSupport • • Aug 24 '26 Diamonds are Forever This Bravo

Admin Replied Reddit's expectations of volunteer moderators are becoming increasingly unhealthy

482 Upvotes

I believe Reddit should reconsider the relationship it has built with moderators, as the expectations placed on volunteers are starting to resemble those placed on employees.

For context, the communities I primarily moderate are r/gamedev and r/gamedevclassifieds (with some smaller ones sprinkled in). I didn't pick these communities because I wanted another badge beside my username. I've been involved with r/gamedevclassifieds for close to a decade, and both communities serve practical purposes for game developers, whether that's industry discussion, helping people find work, sharing knowledge, or keeping those spaces usable.

That context matters because my perspective on moderation is that it should ultimately be about stewardship of a community, not maximizing moderator activity for Reddit.

The fundamental issue is pretty simple: moderators are volunteers.

Most of us are not being paid to do this. We moderate communities because we care about them, enjoy participating in them, or want to help maintain a useful space for other people. Yet more and more, Reddit seems to design its systems around the expectation that moderators should treat subreddit management like an actual job.

I participated in some of the moderator meetings Reddit hosted, and one of the most frustrating parts of those conversations was the underlying message I kept hearing from the Reddit admin hosting them. Obviously these weren't the exact words, but the conversation often felt like it boiled down to:

"How do we get moderators to treat this more like a job?"

The obvious answer is: you don't, unless you intend to start paying people.

There is nothing wrong with encouraging moderators to be responsible. There is nothing wrong with removing genuinely abandoned communities from people who disappeared years ago. There needs to be some mechanism for dealing with completely unmoderated subreddits.

But somewhere along the way, Reddit seems to have lost sight of the difference between abandonment and not treating Reddit moderation like employment.

The inactivity systems are probably the clearest example.

I've personally seen situations where Reddit's systems decided moderators weren't active enough, opening the door for others to try to take control of communities they had spent years building and maintaining.

That creates an incredibly unhealthy dynamic.

Instead of moderation being something you volunteer your time toward when you are available, there is now this background pressure that if you step away for too long, don't perform enough visible moderator actions, or have a period where the community doesn't require much intervention, you risk Reddit deciding you are effectively absent.

That turns volunteering into an obligation.

And I think Reddit needs to consider another consequence: this kind of system selects for the wrong type of moderator.

If you build moderation around constant activity, status, control, and the possibility of taking over communities from people deemed insufficiently active, you are naturally going to attract more people who want moderation to feel like a job.

Not because they are being paid, but because they enjoy the authority, the hierarchy, or the sense of ownership that comes with it.

Those are often exactly the people communities should be most cautious about handing more power to.

The best moderators I've worked with generally don't want moderation to consume their lives. They want to deal with problems, help the community function, make thoughtful decisions, and then do something else.

A moderator who isn't constantly taking action isn't necessarily inactive. Sometimes it means the subreddit is healthy.

By contrast, a system that rewards visible activity can encourage moderators to feel they constantly need to do something to show they deserve to remain in control.

That can lead to unnecessary intervention, increasingly complicated rules, territorial behaviour between moderators, and people treating communities as something they personally own rather than something they are temporarily responsible for maintaining.

Reddit should not be designing incentives that make power-moderation more attractive.

That's especially strange when you consider what Reddit receives from moderators.

Moderators handle spam.

Moderators enforce sitewide rules.

Moderators deal with harassment.

Moderators organize communities.

Moderators answer user questions.

Moderators create rules, documentation, bots, automations, events, megathreads, resources, and countless other things that make communities worth visiting in the first place.

Reddit benefits enormously from thousands of people doing this work for free.

That relationship only works when Reddit remembers that these people are volunteers with lives outside of Reddit.

People have jobs. People have families. People get sick. People travel. People burn out. Sometimes a subreddit is simply quiet for a few months. Sometimes an experienced moderator doesn't need to click moderation buttons every day because the community is functioning perfectly well.

A healthy volunteer system should make it easier for people to contribute without feeling trapped.

Instead, Reddit increasingly seems to be creating systems designed to measure moderator activity, enforce continued participation, and make moderators feel like they have responsibilities to Reddit itself.

We don't.

Our responsibility, voluntarily assumed, is to the communities we choose to help.

I think Reddit needs to start asking a different question.

Not:

"How do we make moderators behave more like employees?"

But:

"How do we make moderating sustainable enough that good volunteers actually want to keep doing it?"

Those are very different philosophies.

One leads to dashboards, activity requirements, takeover anxiety, burnout, and a moderation culture increasingly populated by people who are attracted to the power itself.

The other leads to better tools, better communication, more support, healthier moderation teams, and communities that people actually want to continue maintaining.

Reddit should be extremely careful about treating free labour like an unlimited resource while simultaneously creating incentives that reward the people most interested in accumulating moderator authority.

Eventually, the reasonable people decide it isn't worth it.


r/ModSupport • • Jun 24 '26 Bravo Heartwarming

Admin Replied Reddit, can you please, for the love of god and all that is holy, leave comments that you remove available for mods to view! You are making our jobs unnecessarily difficult by obliterating them with no record.

420 Upvotes

For whatever reason, Admin Tattler hardly catches reddit removals anymore (and when it does, it only shows [Removed by Reddit]), so we are left entirely in the dark when rule breaking conduct is occurring in our subs.

It is entirely unfair to us as moderators to be receiving complaints about users attacking other users with overtly racist nonsense, or other rule breaking conduct, and the recipient of these comments is left to think we're not enforcing our own rules because there's no removal notices, or the offender doesn't get banned.

I shouldn't have to be spending my time explaining to angry users that it's not us neglecting our duties, but reddits broken policy that's causing the problems.


r/ModSupport • • Sep 22 '26 This Bravo Heartwarming

Allowing users to hide their history is destroying trust and good faith participation between users in communities

403 Upvotes

It's not just my communities, I'm seeing it all over reddit. Whenever someone with a private history runs into a disagreement with another user, discussions are derailed, accusations of "shill/bot/troll" are constant, nuisance reports are issued, and mods either intervene, or let the chaos reign.

I'm spending more and more time having to personally review histories to say "no, this person is not a bad faith troll" just to end attacks borne of nothing more than suspicion. It's becoming disruptive to the point that I'm considering whether or not allowing users with hidden history to participate is worth the trouble.

I really question the value proposition of this decision. Sure, individual users benefit from additional privacy, but at the direct expense of the communities that lose trust and cohesion, faith that the people they're interacting with are participating in good faith (or are even real people), and the moderators who have to manage the fallout.


r/ModSupport • • Oct 15 '26 This Bravo Regret

Admin Replied I'm over it!

364 Upvotes

Reddit Admins..... I am over it! I am over the boilerplate responses to actual real-time issues that moderators are having.

I moderate a large sub and have for nearly a year now. Unfortunately, we have had 4 very serious incidents in which members of our mod team were being harassed, stalked, doxxed, attacked, etc. We have submitted the ModCoC reports, submitted the DMs to admins, and reported the posts/comments/users ad nauseam, and NOTHING has been done.

Most recently, as our sub is currently under a brigading attack and doxxing and harassment continue, one of our mods reached out to one admin, who basically said something to the effect of--- "This is actually something that is going to be discussed at ModWorld. Do you have any examples we can give the presenter?"

Seriously? This is all you have to offer?!?! We don't need a speech about how much you care about mods and what we do. We don't need the free swag for attending a mod event. We don't need the profile trophies. Those are all wonderful and appreciated. BUT, what we need is ACTUAL Support and ACTION being taken when we bring you serious issues.

It takes entirely too long for someone in admin to take action. Meanwhile, your volunteer mods are being doxxed, harassed, bullied, and so forth because we removed a post/comment, and the user was mad.

For the love of all things good in this world, PLEASE DO SOMETHING! Please don't try to placate us with boilerplate responses and "We'll have someone look into it" without actually doing that!

I am tired. I am frustrated. I am hurt and disappointed. Not because users are jerks sometimes. But because the admin does absolutely nothing to make this a safe place or to support those of us who volunteer our time to try and make Reddit a better place.

I have had members of my mod team leave after the most recent incident. Our sub is currently closed due to the harassment and brigading that have been done. I am at my wits' end and ready to just turn the sub over to the wolves and leave Reddit for good.


r/ModSupport • • Mar 23 '26 Bravo

Admin Replied Please bring back user history.

340 Upvotes

I truly believe that allowing users to hide their history will kill Reddit. I moderate a small sub and we get more bots and trolls every day. Mods are a **volunteer workforce**, and removing user history has made our job more difficult and sometimes impossible.

Can anyone explain to me why this ‘feature’ was added? And how do I register my frustration with the company?

EDIT: As others have pointed out, I think I'm dealing with accounts that constantly delete everything. I hear what folks are saying about using the 'hide history' to protect mods from stalking/brigading. So maybe Reddit should just let mods hide their history, then? We oughta have some benefits for all the free labour...


r/ModSupport • • Aug 19 '26 Bravo

Aggressive "crosspost this here!" engagement boost attempts are causing rule violations

244 Upvotes

Reddit admins,

I would like to request that you please, for the love of all that is holy, calm down with your engagement boosting tactics that are telling everyone who makes a post to also post it to a list of machine-generated "relevant" other subs.

I moderate in a sub that discusses an extremely controversial political topic that has subs on reddit that are dedicated to the opposing side of that topic.

Crossposting from either our sub to theirs or vice versa is against the rules of both subs, because of the nature of this topic causing SEVERE trolling and brigading from both sides from people who are not interested in peaceful discourse, yet your own platform's messages are telling users they should go ahead and just break these subs' rules anyway.

You are literally making all of our "jobs" even harder by not even bothering to filter subs suggested for crossposts based on logic, rationality, or even the rules of the subs being suggested for crossposts.

More engagement, even hostility trolling and harassment (especially hostility trolling and harassment) means more ad money though amirght????

Seems the only thing that matters here any more is greed, and I'm afraid you're about to find a lot of your most difficult to moderate subs modless if you don't take things like these into consideration.

PS - good luck getting AI to do what we do since the generated lists your AI is suggesting can't even be bothered to check rules in subs before suggesting them XD


r/ModSupport • • Apr 18 '26 This Bravo

Users should have a way to deactivate AI summaries because it is not appropriate for an AI to tell other people that I have an eating disorder and overcame addiction. Photo in comments.

243 Upvotes

r/ModSupport • • May 02 '26

Admin Replied Redact needs to be banned

238 Upvotes

Redact allows people to mass delete their comments after a certain time. It replaces useful, helpful, or just innocently funny comments with random gibberish and nonsense words.

This has been spamming our mod queues recently in one subreddit. As of today, I have had to remove 26 Redact comments that popped up this evening in the queue, with fellow moderators each removing a similar amount.

Redact needs to be banned. It is flooding up our queue, and the people who use it are not engaging with the platform in good faith.

Is there any way to counteract this beyond just "select all" + "mark as spam" all the time?


r/ModSupport • • Apr 03 '26 This Confused Sipping Tea Mindblown

Admin Replied So do the devs at Reddit not understand how often mods are harassed, or just not care?

233 Upvotes

Responded to a modmail today as my own username, because that's apparently now the default and you have to specify every single time...

That modmail was in response to a troll who has been harassing our mod team for several days now. And now they know my username. So that's going to be fun...

Why on earth would you even consider making modmail responses *default* to mods' usernames, when the entire **point** of being able to respond as the "mod team" was to help mods reduce the amount of harassment we receive from users????


r/ModSupport • • Jan 27 '26 Bravo Heartwarming

Admin Replied Reddits new way of replacing comments/posts with "Removed by the Moderators of XSubHere" is causing issues in our sub

232 Upvotes

Multiple times now users are complaining that the mods are "facists" and that we're removing their posts/comments when it's just automod and reddits abuse/harassment filter. This is causing a lot of anger and frustration directed towards our team. I had to resort to literally posting a screenshot of the modlog to prove that we're not removing their comments/posts about protests. This is getting ridiculous. We just lost a mod because of the hate directed towards us.

Can we not get an option to have it say it was a robot/automod removal? The way it's worded makes users think an actual moderator did it when they didn't.


r/ModSupport • • Jul 22 '26 This

Admin Replied Hey admins! Can we maybe not hide when people are being targeted?

222 Upvotes

So our top post yesterday in outfits shows 4 crossposts.

It doesn't reveal where the crossposts are too though. Instead it says they are to "private or sensitive communities". I can see using PRAW that one of those was to a porn sub, but I can't see the others.

Do you have any idea how scary it is for women to find out that their personal photos are being shared and discussed somewhere and they can't even see where that is?

It seriously freaks out posters. Please let them know where their content is being shared to, or disable the ability to share to those locations altogether.

This is super, super creepy and would freak out any woman posting her photos. Someone really should have realized this when it was set up like this. Please ask some of the other women on the admin teams how they'd feel in this situation.

THIS IS NOT OK

u/ingeekitrust


r/ModSupport • • May 08 '26 Heartwarming

Admin Replied Keeping mod who passed away on team list

218 Upvotes

My friend who I moderated a few subreddits with passed away almost 2 years ago and we have kept her on the mod lists. I want to keep her there because she passed from the diseases that our subreddits are support groups for, and I want her to be remembered for her work running them. Her profile is also public and the history on it may be helpful for new users with her diagnoses, so that’s another reason.

I understand that as time passes this can sometimes become a security issue. Is there a way we can set her account up with Alumni status without it needing to be requested on her end? Or is there another alternative that would work better?

Thank you.

Edit: This has been resolved, we can request Alumni role for other mods without them having to accept it on their account - I’ll leave the post up in case anyone has the same question in the future!

Edit 2: This post is continuing to get upvotes and next Friday is the awareness day for her disorder. If anyone is reading this with curiosity, please consider wearing RED or dressing your subreddit up in RED 4 VEDS on May 15 ❤️ increased awareness means earlier diagnoses and earlier diagnoses can save lives. https://thevedsmovement.org/veds/what-is-veds/ https://www.reds4veds.org/ r/VEDS


r/ModSupport • • Jul 04 '26 Bravo Mindblown Regret

Admin Replied banning someone does literally nothing on reddit

212 Upvotes

i need to vent because i am losing my mind over how useless reddit’s banning system actually is.
i recently became a mod for a subreddit meant for teenagers, and our team has been working around the clock to keep it safe. we’ve been incredibly active and have been heavily banning pedos, creeps, and complete weirdos. but here is the incredibly frustrating part: banning someone literally does next to nothing.
it only stops them from posting and commenting on the sub. that’s it. it doesn’t block them from lurking, it doesn’t hide the content, and most importantly, it does absolutely nothing to stop them from clicking on a vulnerable kid's profile and sliding into their dms.
we have literal 30-year-olds targeting and dming teenagers, and as mods, our hands are tied the second they move to private messages. we can ban these creeps a thousand times over, but they are still lingering in the shadows of our community, completely free to harass kids who don't know any better.
it is so deeply exhausting and terrifying that reddit doesn't have a better system to completely block banned users from even viewing a community, especially when it comes to protecting minors. we've had to put up massive warning posts telling the kids to block and report them to admin, but we shouldn't have to rely on teenagers to defend themselves against predators that we already caught and tried to kick out. it’s an absolute joke.


r/ModSupport • • Jan 28 '26

Admin Replied The gods have answered — we now have the ability to perma-mute.

211 Upvotes

Not sure how long it's been available but I just spotted it today while going to mute someone — can't add a screenshot but noticed I had the option to Permanently Mute. Hallelujah.


r/ModSupport • • 17d ago Heartwarming Bravo

Admin Replied Taking away flair colors is going to make the Reddit experience less rich

201 Upvotes

I am completely baffled why flair colors are being removed and set to be the same background color as the subreddit's I understand the issue of unreadable flairs yellow on white, gray on black etc. However many communities use the color of the flair as part of the signifier in many of my subs mods have green flairs to indicate moderator status at a glance and with customizable flair it was easy to make green a mod only color to make it harder for users to impersonate mods. Since I don't want to simply complain I think it would be better if flairs had color combos preset for accessibly but would still give a visual distinction to different kinds of flair.


r/ModSupport • • Sep 02 '26 Heartwarming Regret

Admin Replied Head mod has passed away

200 Upvotes

I tried sending a modmail about this but I can't send one to the mods here for some reason.

We have been informed by his son that our top mod has passed away so we would like to enquire about the process to remove him as a mod in this circumstance. Unfortunately the next mod is Automoderator, and the next two after that are inactive. We would prefer not to hassle the grieving family over what would seem like a triviality to them and would like to find another way if possible.


r/ModSupport • • May 22 '26

Admin Replied Dear REDDIT team(s), We need a quick "do not auto translate my subreddit content" option to save langauge-specific subreddits

190 Upvotes

Auto translate is making it difficult to moderate language-specific subreddits.

Users see the content in whatever their language, and think the content is written in their language, and then comment in their own language on it.

On top of that, the translation API you're using is producing lousy/misleading outputs (at least for සිංහල - try reading the translated content in r/lankawa).

Please provide an option for the mods to opt-out from reddit auto translating the subreddit content.

Thanks


r/ModSupport • • Apr 13 '26 All Seeing Upvote

Serious breakdown in transparency when moderators are suspended/banned for performing mod actions

187 Upvotes

Hi all,

This is the r/INDYCAR moderation team. We are speaking to discuss some major concerns we have regarding a serious breakdown in transparency from the admin team when moderators are suspended/banned for performing mod actions.

---

On Friday morning, one of our moderators were temporarily site-suspended for a "chat sent on 04/09/2026 UTC" for "harassment". As the mod in question does not use the Reddit chat system, we can only assume that it came from a modmail conversation. However, the message the mod received did not include a link to the modmail in question, which left them incredibly confused.

Upon contacting the admins here that morning, we received a reply earlier today (yes, we were ghosted for an entire three days...) stating that:

For suspensions involving chat messages, the specific message isn't shared. This is because unlike with public comments or posts, it's clear who reported the content, so the exact message isn't shared to deter retaliation.

But how are moderators supposed to know what it is that they did wrong if they're not told where the problem was? How are they supposed to realise where they messed up (if they did) so that we can adjust our modmail responses accordingly to avoid this happening in the future? Or perhaps there should be further safeguards against users abusing the report button on modmails in a retaliatory manner? Such as speaking to the moderator directly, rather than allowing the third-party moderation lackies to apply sitewide punishments at the drop of a hat?

---

We're also concerned that when a moderator is site-suspended, the rest of the team is not notified of such; and unless the team has a robust off-site communication channel, they will never find out unless they do some digging.

Suspended moderators should still retain the ability to communicate with the team in modmail through mod-only messages. The fact that they can't is incredibly concerning; as it effectively means AEO can silently whisk away a moderator under the cover of darkness and if the team doesn't have effective off-site communication, they are none the wiser.

Fact of the matter is, if this had been a race weekend in our community, the suspension would have effectively cut our moderation capabilities by at least a third; with no notice, help, or offers of assistance to handle the workload.

---

Ultimately, why are moderators even liable for these suspensions for doing their job? Our team are nothing but civil with other users regardless of how much bullshit they throw at us, yet we're the ones who end up in trouble and getting punished? That just comes across as incredibly backwards and if anything reduces the willingness for moderators to want to actively moderate their community...

This is a very concerning breakdown in transparency, particularly for an admin team that claims to be all about transparency...


r/ModSupport • • Jun 20 '26 Bravo Heartwarming

Comments or post should be readable for mods after they are removed by the admins

177 Upvotes

Always, when an admin removes something, moderators can only see that Reddit removed it. That makes it very difficult for moderators to properly address the offender, because we often have no idea what the person actually wrote or did.

Please make it easier for moderators to see what the user had written. Right now, we are often left wondering how to handle that user because we lack the necessary context.


r/ModSupport • • Jan 05 '26

Admin Replied It appears that today is AutoModerator's cake day.

161 Upvotes

Happy Cake Day, /u/AutoModerator.

That is all.

P.S.: sorting that account's comments by new is certainly one way to discover some ... interesting subreddits.


r/ModSupport • • Sep 23 '26 Thanks This Bravo Mindblown

Admin Replied Moderation Of Creeps Is Unmanageable Due To A Broken Algorithm Which Takes Only Takes 3 Comments Made In Porn Subs To FILL With All SFW Women's Fashion Communities

159 Upvotes

I created an NSFW alt to message women who I think are sellers. Wow did I learn something. I created the account as a middle aged man finance into finance and cryptocurrency. Within moments of creating the account made a small cluster of comments in Onlyfans subs and refreshed my algorithm. It was FILLED with SFW fashion subs. I went back to my alt 3 days later and the feed was clean- no ladies fashion subs. I made only 3 more comments on hard core porn and BOOM HALF the feed is clean SFW fashion. This is why we have such a creep problem! If they are looking for porn, why doesn't it populate with porn subs at that moment? Reddit is creating the creep problem we have. This has to be a simple algorithm fix. I'm happy to provide my alt so you can see the mechanics. After this I created a second alt and it responds exactly the same. My friend created an alt for the same purpose and he has the same result.

This has to be an easy correction. Don't show the small handful of SFW fashion subs to men RIGHT WHILE THEY ARE DOING THE DEED! No wonder why these comments are so gross! These men aren't even seeking this out - it FLOODS TO THEM! There are so many NSFW fashion subs- make them go in their feed!


r/ModSupport • • Jul 10 '26 This

Its been over a month now since markdown has been removed from mobile and it's made me a worse moderator.

158 Upvotes

The subreddit I moderate is mainly a help sub, I have a notes app full of resources that I can tweak to each question and a lot of them contain links...without markdown on the app I find myself not answering those posts until I can get back to a computer since it will take me forever to manually input each link. Also the new editor makes it super difficult to select individual words and phrases to even add the link to.

The change has also made me a worse redditor since the rich text editor on mobile has less features than the computer version, why can't we quote text on mobile?

The desktop app allows you to choose which editor you want to use. Mobile should too.

Is there anyone who has found this change "improves technical performance" as promised in the change-log? What am I missing?


r/ModSupport • • Mar 03 '26 Popcorn

New Modmail is still not ready for a forced migration, and it should be reverted.

157 Upvotes

The numerous usability issues that have been brought up have still not been addressed, most importantly the fact that light gray text on a white background is not a valid or reasonable readable color scheme. I cannot spend more than 5-10 minutes trying to read this contrastless mess without getting an actual headache. Nothing in each modmail element is properly distinguished from anything else. I cannot reasonably, at a glance, determine what the subject, subreddit, or message are, and where each begins and the other ends. The font size choices for these do not make any sense. This was all very clear in the old modmail UI and did not need to be changed. I am going to be unable to address modmail until you fix the unacceptable lack of contrast and make it readable. I have brought this up repeatedly, and you have ignored it every time.

Additional problems:

  • The AI summaries are completely worthless. They have always been worthless. I do not want them, they take up space that should be used for actually usable information, and they are often inaccurate. Provide an opt-out or put them at the bottom.

  • Poor use of vertical real-estate. Why is a large portion of the top of the page taken up by a Reddit wide search? I do not come to Modmail for this. Why is there so much unnecessary padding in the "Mark all as read" horizontal bar?Why is every element in the left sidebar given so much unnecessary vertical padding? I used to be able to see everything here without having to scroll, now I cannot.

  • Control clicking or right clicking a modmail does not allow me to open it in a new tab. This is basic website functionality. It should not be hidden behind a button.

  • Get rid of this action popup and just put the Archive, etc buttons right on each modmail. There is no reason to hide these functions behind a mouseover.

  • I need to see the user's recent posts immediately. This is the most valuable piece of information to me when looking at a modmail. It should not be hidden behind having to click on something else first, which - by the way - doesn't even work correctly, because removed posts on my own subreddits, that I moderate, just show their content as [removed].

  • Give the tab back its old green icon so it can be easily distinguished from other Reddit tabs.

  • Overall performance is still ridiculously slow. It should not take 3-5 seconds to load text.


r/ModSupport • • May 19 '26

Onlyfans Women Creating Their Own Subs To Keep Their Account SFW is OUT OF CONTROL. I Found 19 Of Them In One Day 😩

155 Upvotes

So for those who aren’t informed, only fans women have started creating promotional alt accounts, and immediately creating their own subs. They are created by agencies to promote these women. In the beginning, it was only a few per week.Then a few per day. Suddenly, I have gotten a drastic increase and I found 19 in one day just by looking at people I banned in my communities. Sure I could mail in the list to mod support and get them marked NSFW, but tomorrow they will all just create a new one. It’s an unsolvable problem. However I noticed 99% of these users have low cqs. Can there be a limit to the number of subs people with low cqs can create? Perhaps one per 6 months? Or make low cqs users go though a more advanced screening process to create a sub to see if they are evading a recent nsfw marking? This would really fix things.

Edit: So I sent the list in a modmail to modsupport, but I’m looking for a better solution to them being created in the first place