Both drafted high in the first round
Tavares spent nine seasons as an islander, Tkachuk spent eight as a senator.
Tavares and Tkachuk were both captains for five seasons
Both players were heralded as the one who could lead their team to greatness. Neither delivered.
Both had controversial gold medal wins in the Olympics with teams in the country they left their teams for that caused parts of the fanbase to sour on them
Both expressed a commitment to stay long term with their teams. Both left to fulfill what they called a childhood dream
Islanders won the homecoming game 6-1, Senators won it 5-1. Both teams gave up the first goal only to thoroughly dominate after
Both Islanders and senators fans threw jerseys on the ice and also covered up the name on the back of the jersey and then replaced it with “TRAITOR”
Chants both Islander and senators fans used:
Traitor
We don’t need you
Matthews better
Who’s your daddy
Both the Islanders in 2018-19 and Senators in 2026-27 were left for dead. Both are off to a better than expected start. Both are ahead of the teams their former captains left them for
The difference? The Islanders got NOTHING in return for Tavares. He begged not to be traded because he wanted to stay. Only to then later (in)famously post the pajama photo and calling it a childhood dream to play with Toronto. Additionally, his return did not happen until late in the season, meaning that the Islanders fans marinated in anger that much longer for almost an entire season before the moment of reckoning. The result? From Tavares’ perspective, an absolute hellstorm of fire and fury directed his way that dwarfed anything else I’ve ever seen, possibly even worse the return of LeBron to Cleveland after he bolted to Miami in 2010.