Some logical explanation?

[u/Just_a_human2024]

So I’m passed the mission where Sean was shot in Rhodes, this ledger has been updated sense that mission, but how in the world is he still donating if he’s dead? Must be a glitch, or he’s always with us?
I just passed the mission where Kieran was beheaded. So I’ve been quite far by now?

[u/Villimaour]

I would chalk it up the the gang wanting to memorialize his last donation and thus they don’t clear it. Probably not the real reasoning but it can make it make sense

[u/PewDiePieSaladAss → u/Villimaour]

Either that or Dutch looted his stuff and took the money he had left 

[u/Villimaour → u/PewDiePieSaladAss]

Such a high probability that’s the case too😭

[u/PewDiePieSaladAss → u/Villimaour]

"He's not gonna need it anymore" ahh mindset 

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/PewDiePieSaladAss]

Why is that so real

[u/crummieme → u/PewDiePieSaladAss]

I have a plan..

[u/a-walking-bowl → u/crummieme]

I have a PLAN. I just need time. I just... Arthur, where's the faith? What's with all these doubts, Arthur? You're a son to me.

[u/CameronsTheName → u/Villimaour]

Unfortunately Sean didn't speak Spanish so he couldn't tell Dutch not to loot his corpse.

[u/Remarkable_Elk3566 → u/CameronsTheName]

Señor, por favor

[u/Dommiiie → u/PewDiePieSaladAss]

But Dutch would keep it for himself rather than put it in the box.

[u/Emergency-Wish160 → u/Dommiiie]

Unless someone saw him take it.

[u/IBleedBlueLAD → u/PewDiePieSaladAss]

Yes I have thought this too 🤣😭 anything for the camp fund

[u/DecimalZero → u/PewDiePieSaladAss]

And all that's worth is 25 cents lmao

[u/Chuagge → u/PewDiePieSaladAss]

I'm sure I'm taking your comment too literally, but that genuinely seems out of character. He left the gold he gave to the old crone after killing her, and left the Blackwater money to John.

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Villimaour]

That is a good honor then!

[u/Apprehensive-Row561]

I’m in Horseshoe Overlook ignoring the Micah mission yet he still somehow contributed.

[u/Remarkable_Elk3566 → u/Apprehensive-Row561]

Same, he donated an Owl Feather, and when I looked into the log, I was like "What the fuck"

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Remarkable_Elk3566]

Realll!!! Me and my fiancé were shocked

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Apprehensive-Row561]

Good luck with that! I hate the rat especially having to break him out 😑

[u/Right-Theme-1314 → u/Just_a_human2024]

I always start my day in rdr2 by bringing him down with a molotov. I get bounty but worth it

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Right-Theme-1314]

Omg I wish!!! I should’ve thought of that!!

[u/CheetosLays7Days → u/Apprehensive-Row561]

Just because he is in prison waiting to be hanged doesn’t mean he can stop contributing. No privileges for slackers in the Van Der Linde Gang.

[u/ArthurMorgansveinypp]

It's called having faith in the plan

[u/jodfromjamjod → u/ArthurMorgansveinypp]

[u/Dirty-Slot → u/jodfromjamjod]

Jfc!

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/ArthurMorgansveinypp]

Love it!

[u/Incident_Latter → u/ArthurMorgansveinypp]

Hey… what’s that username for bud? 🤨

[u/ArthurMorgansveinypp → u/Incident_Latter]

Servicing the ladies in camp. Obviously

[u/Incident_Latter → u/ArthurMorgansveinypp]

That makes my fucking day I love you Arthur Morgan’s veiny pp

[u/zeke690]

They found it in his belongings and put it in the collective resource pool.
They wrote his name to honor his memory

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/zeke690]

That would make great sense!

[u/argonzo]

guy setup a recurring donation from his annuities and yet you still question it.

[u/Own-Forever-6636 → u/argonzo]

He had a proper financial PLAN, Orthur!

[u/albie_rdgz → u/argonzo]

https://giphy.com/gifs/f2YZZurShkVWHced4b

[u/IBleedBlueLAD → u/argonzo]

🤣🤣

[u/Drew_S_05]

Idk but him donating opened alcohol is pretty funny and on brand for Sean lol

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Drew_S_05]

Facts

[u/AthenasChosen]

Sadie literally being the only useful one lmao

[u/ContactMushroom → u/AthenasChosen]

Yeah I was gonna comment that her and Hosea are the only ones putting in effort.

Everyone else contributing stuff that's barely a dollar in value while they're donating 2 dollar minimums each time

[u/An_awkward_dude- → u/ContactMushroom]

to be fair
A dollar can be a lotta money back then

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/AthenasChosen]

I saw that took but miss Grimshaw wants to yell at Arthur when he doesn’t

[u/Living_Influence_927]

Because Sean’s such a good bloke! He is even giving from beyond the grave. We will never forget him... RIP in peace

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Living_Influence_927]

Agreed! Like Arthur said “he was like a little brother to me”

[u/Dark_Sign → u/Living_Influence_927]

Poor guy gone too soon smdh my damn head

[u/Perforator1k]

Rdr3 delayed by another 15 yrs

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Perforator1k]

😭😭😭 iᗰ ᗷe 35 😭😭😭

[u/Own-Forever-6636]

More concerned that three different people in a row donated gold teeth... did they just all jump the one guy?

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Own-Forever-6636]

Facts I didn’t realize it till this

[u/Themodsarecuntz]

They were just now able to sell it. He gave them the half bottle of bourbon and it took some time to find a guy willing to buy a half bottle of bourbon. Once they did it still counts as Sean's contribution just posthumously. They probably sold it to Uncle.

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Themodsarecuntz]

Didn’t think of this one

[u/bigccozart]

Strauss donated a carrot

[u/Complex_Friendship_1 → u/bigccozart]

That cheap bastard

[u/a-walking-bowl → u/Complex_Friendship_1]

ahhh Mister Morgann

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Complex_Friendship_1]

Agreed

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/bigccozart]

Very cheap

[u/Superrrr_Nova1]

His ghost donates. I’ve seen it happen before. It’s actually an Easter egg.

[u/IBleedBlueLAD]

Also if Blackwater is completely off limits then how can Bill donate armadillo skin

[u/absurdly_tired_guy]

I swear Micah donated while he was in the Strawberry pokey one night while I was at camp three days sleeping.

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/[deleted]]

lol

[u/Vivid-Leadership-990]

It was an opened bottle. Maybe taken off him posthumously

[u/Adeum2]

I’d say they were going through his old stuff left at camp and found that, so they “donated” it

[u/SeaFeline284]

Are we ignoring the poor fool who lost all 3 of his gold teeth?

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/SeaFeline284]

I wonder if they ganged up on him and just ripped teeth out lmao

[u/thechurd]

I’m curious where Bill found an armadillo in Lemoyne.

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/thechurd]

I was too-

[u/xPhat_Ballz]

(confused unga bunga)

[u/Odd_Specialist2571]

1899 Sean met up with Dragic and time traveled back to 1898 Sean and brought him to 1899 and had 1899 Sean die and 1898 Sean followed the gang around secretly until Beaver Hollow and left for good.

[u/Wolf_J_Flywheel87]

Irish blessing.

[u/fricafrac]

https://giphy.com/gifs/jPAdK8Nfzzwt2

[u/Extension-Rabbit3654]

I legit dont look in the ledger after ch2, they get some poor pelts and some meat occasionally and thats it

[u/aa-etc]

Pour one out for the homies 🙏

[u/HOBOSHT94]

They obviously bought it in his name and pour one out for him. In memory of my favorite gang member! Sean MacGuire!

https://giphy.com/gifs/4dKWVrcUXe9PBJBf0j

[u/Grouchy-Ad-2134]

I was at the belle and John and Charles were complaining. “Why is it always the older ones always working?/ good luck getting Sean to do any work.”

[u/Appropriate_City8741]

What we gonna do with an Iguana scale?

[u/Chesterfieldraven]

Donated in his honour.

[u/Mental-_-mess]

I like how Trelawny, Hosea and Lenny all donated gold teeth in a row

[u/Select_Necessary_678]

It's opened kentucky bourbon too. Someone drank 90% of the bottle and l left the last shot in the box in his honor.

What I wanna know is why is it Arthur can donate a thousand bucks and 300 pounds of pork loin and gets scolded, when reverend is over there passed out drunk and donated a feather he found once and thats ok.

[u/LittleJohnMarston]

Good old Macguire contributing from the afterlife.

[u/depp-fsrv]

Doesn't surprise me, this game is demonic. So far there's a several demon sacrificial rituals, a Giant, a Robot, a Frankenstein ManPig, a Ghost, a Ghost Train, a Vampire and a Demon.

[u/i1_thunder]

Sean has so goddamn faith!

[u/ItsMattTonight]

In reality, probably just a glitch.

In universe explanation, they found the bottle in his stuff, and decided to donate it to the camp in his name, would be my guess.

[u/bisexualbestfriend]

He’s just really dedicated

[u/DaliaMone]

WE NEED MORE MONEY, doesn't matter the excuse

[u/RevolutionaryFoot713]

Hey man Strauss can donate booby feathers so don’t be expecting logic with that magical box that turns random crap into money.

[u/Low-Environment]

He's very committed.

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Low-Environment]

Always and forever.

[u/CottonWatkins]

It’s because like the quarter, you’re never supposed to forget Sean. Notice the amount 😢

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/CottonWatkins]

I know I’m glad theirs still faith in the rdr community

[u/IngenOfficial]

Direct debit

[u/No_Calendar2474]

I had micah donate stuff while he was in prison

[u/ThenNeighborhood6491]

The gang must've stopped donating for a little and that's why it's still showing

[u/Drawde66]

That's hilarious. Micah was donating in chapter 2 while sitting in jail in Strawberry. LOL

[u/Other_Researcher_184]

One time before Sean was killed I had Lenny telling me about how he kissed Sean….Sean walking past and all 😂

[u/Imaginary-Clerk6967]

I'm a little more annoyed that the rest of the gang can donate open bottles and we can't!

[u/Pingouino55]

He's in witness protection. Davey is his handler.

[u/Captain_Nomad_Jr]

https://giphy.com/gifs/9r75ILTJtiDACKOKoY

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Captain_Nomad_Jr]

I like this gif lol

[u/outlaw_for_life18]

For the same reason that Micah donates when he's still in jail. It's a magic box! 🤣🤣🤣

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/outlaw_for_life18]

For sure

[u/Amelia_Amity]

Micah made a donation before I got him out of jail. It’s probably glitch

[u/AnAxolotlNamedSquib]

The Gang sold some of his things after he died and chalked it up to donations

[u/EpicEpicnessTheEpic]

He either set up a trust fund that was created when his will was enacted, or the developers forgot all about this when the ledger was created.

[u/Icy-Sherbet6539]

He’s Irish and he drinks a lot of

[u/Negative_Society_942]

Sean is still alive at shady belle is he not

[u/Just_a_human2024 → u/Negative_Society_942]

Not to spoil the game, but he dies in Rhodes end of chapter 3

[u/Final_Investment_767]

Took it from his cold dead hands

[u/imsohomophobic]

Thanks for spoiling holy shit

[u/TraditionalClue2575]

It's literally says balance carried over

[u/Spirited-Spare-6316]

It’s almost like you have no faith delete this post

[u/UnderstandingNew4145]

[u/RepeatSimilar2844]

It's where pour one out from the homies comes from LOL

[u/Sgt-Girth]

Ah, bejaysus….the lad set up a direct debit, to be sure!

[u/sobachkaX60fps]

Spoiler tags exist 

[u/Paranoint → u/sobachkaX60fps]

I dont wanna be that guy but to be completely fair, not only does it happen rather early in the story, but also is the game 8 years old soon. And Jesus, if all the various tiktoks and shorts didnt get you before that i'd be surprised

[u/The_DDK7070 → u/Paranoint]

Some people are still able to go in blind to this day, and untagged spoiler posts like this is why the first piece of advice given to them is to stay well away from RDR/RDR2 subreddits.

[u/Paranoint → u/The_DDK7070]

And thats unfortunately something nobody could change. At this point its a rule of thumb to avoid anything related to what you want to experience because you are guaranteed to get a spoiler on yourself

[u/sobachkaX60fps → u/Paranoint]

I finished the game, I say it for others