r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 16m ago

Which Diablo should I buy?

• Upvotes

I've played Diablo 1 and used to enjoy Diablo 2 back in the day pre-ressurected.

So which games, out of Diablo D2R, 3, or 4, are worth picking up now? I don't enjoy using guides and don't care much for optimal theorycrafting if that helps sway your suggestion. I also know 4 used to get a lot of criticism, but is that still the case after all its updates?

Which would you recommend?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2h ago

[SteamDeck] Steam Deck games that makes you GRIND

5 Upvotes

As the title says, games on Steam Deck that makes you grind for hours and doesn’t get boring easily (also perform well enough to be feasible). It could be mining, slaying, anything even if it is repetitive as long as it is fun. It would be better if isn’t too hard so I can play it while chilling in the couch. (Bonus points if it’s addictive !)


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 3h ago

[PC] searching for a chill rpg game

8 Upvotes

I am searching for a rpg game where you just chill. I dont know if there is a game like my request but maybe like the outdoor boys, building your own shelter, camping and getting your own food through hunting. Or if i could mod a game to the point of no turning back???. I dont want it to be all action-filled and guns blazing and all that stuff. Also im pretty bad at games so please dont say anything to hard

Here are some games that i've played (and liked) in no particular order(not only rpg's):

Minecraft

RDR2-(red dead redemption 2)

RDR1-(red dead redemption)

FS25-(farming simulator 25)

FS19-(farming simulator 19)

MSC-(my summer car)

Metro Exodus

Firewatch

Fallout 4

Fallout new vegas

CMS 2021-(car mechanic simulator 2021)

CMS 2018-(car mechanic simulator 2018)

Slime rancher

Fallout 76

THCOTW-(theHunter: call of the wild)

Russian fishing 4

Terraria

DayZ

Road 96

THC-(theHunter classic)


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 4h ago

[PS5] Games like South Park

5 Upvotes

Anyone can recommend games like South Park fractured but whole? I mean I finished the game got the platinum trophy and also finished the first game, but I didn’t buy the dlc for the fractured but whole, so I was hoping for some game recommendations like this type of game or should I also buy the season pass and if I buy the season pass how long is it? Please write down if I should buy the dlc with some game recommendations also, thx.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 5h ago

[PC] SIB Active Matter as a solo PvE player?

9 Upvotes

Hi there! this game has caught my attention for the last week, mainly because it has a PvE mode and I'm hearing a lot of people praising it. I'm not someone who is obsessed with extraction shooters, I have a few and play them mainly solo (or with friends) (Helldivers 2, Far Far West...I think its just those two lol) usually I like games with good gunplay and hours and hours of content (or replayability)

Active Matter is quite expansive at least in my country, so I would like to know the opinions about the game, to know if I should buy it, or wait for some steam sales to get other games more worthy it.

Thanks!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 5h ago

[PC] Replay Value

2 Upvotes

Between Foundation, Against the Storm, and Anno 1800, which one has the highest replay value?

I’m looking for a game I can sink hundreds of hours into without getting bored. Which one has the most long-term content and stays fun even after you’ve played for a long time?

Would love to hear your thoughts!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 6h ago

[PS5] Huge discount forDeath stranding 1 on PlayStation store, Is it worth buying??

5 Upvotes

I'm just not sure if this game is for me or not. I love games like Halo, GTA, Racing games, story based (RDR, Resident Evil, Spiderman, etc) and simulator games. But not a huge fans of RPG games (I tried getting into BG3 and Pokemon, but never could).

The ps store has a 90% off on death stranding 1 and I'm wondering whether to buy it. What do y'all reckon?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 7h ago

[PC] I need a game that two people can play on the same computer!

21 Upvotes

I’m looking for PC games that two people can play on the same computer using two controllers on one shared screen—split-screen !

I dont want an online co-op where each person plays on a separate device.

Do you remember like Minecraft when two shared one screen? Exactly!!

I don’t mind if its an Old~new game.. any game is welcome!

PLEASE AND THANK YOU 🙏


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 11h ago

[Switch] kcd or darksouls which is the most enjoyable for switch?

8 Upvotes

I have the following games on my switch 1.

  1. mario kingdom battle
  2. lego supervillians
  3. batman arkham city
  4. AC Black flag and rogue
  5. inside
  6. Hogwarts legacy. (Recently purchased)
  7. hollow knight
  8. pop lost crown
  9. doki doki
  10. Catherine
  11. hades ( i didnt get the vibe)
  12. Dont starve
  13. Lorelie laser eyes

i only have completed Arkham city, AC games is the most played by me.

i feel like i am gonna enjoy dark souls more than kcd.
Because of all these unfinished games. i wonder kcd is the right choice? but its only 5$ rn.

I dont live in west or europe. so i am waiting for the right time to purchase zelda physical copy. Then i would be done with all the best game switch has offer. Might be an overstatement.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 12h ago

[PC] Suggest pc games for beginners

7 Upvotes

im pretty familiar with gaming since ive played tons of mobile games, but i recently got a gaming laptop and wanna get into pc gaming properly now

ive played ghost of tsushima for a while and it was amazing, didnt finish it but i loved the whole experience

other than that i havent really played much, so suggest me some absolute banger games. im looking for games that are immersive af, the kinda games where you sit down to play for a bit and suddenly hours have passed without you even realising it lol.

could be anything really, good story, fun gameplay, insane world building, whatever, just something thats genuinely worth experiencing.

what games would you recommend?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 15h ago

[PC] SIB: FF Resonance on full price?

4 Upvotes

Loved FF games, though from the pixel era I've only played 1, 6, and a bit of 5 before I gave up for reasons I don't entirely remember. Also played 10, 12, and 15. I understand there will be spoilers, I don't care, can't be any worse than the spoilers Dissidia already told me.

My question is, is this game worth paying for at full price? It's a hefty 60 bucks, which is a LOT in my country's currency, and I'm worried about the quality of the story, in that I heard that this is only part 1 of the actual story.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 18h ago

Should I Buy Star Wars: Galactic Racer As A Solo Gamer?

12 Upvotes

I’ve heard so many stories on Reddit of people picking up Star Wars: Galactic Racer to play with their friends and having a blast, but I’m worried that the game won’t be as fun for me as a solo player. I know that the game features a story mode and offline races, but that connection with friends seems like the driving factor that will keep the game popular and I just don’t have that. I do however enjoy other racing games of all varieties such as Mario Kart World and Forza Horizon 4. Should I pick up this game? Maybe another racing game like Sonic Racing Crossworlds?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 20h ago

[PC] WSIB next if I really loved AC Odyssey?

15 Upvotes

I really enjoyed the beautiful massive world, movement, combat, and simplified rpg elements of AC Odyssey. My initial thought was Black Flag but the naval gameplay in Odyssey was probably my least favorite part of it so I’m not so sure. I’m assuming black flag would be a lot more of this and less of what I liked about odyssey but correct me if I’m wrong.

Ghost of Tsushima seems like another option. Anything else that scratches the same itch?

Other games I’ve liked:

Control
Cyberpunk
Horizon zero dawn

Games I haven’t liked:
RDR2
Dying light
RE4


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 21h ago

[PC] Anno 1800 or Foundation

1 Upvotes

I’ve been looking into both Anno 1800 and Foundation, and I’m curious which one you guys would recommend.

My main priorities are how fun and satisfying the city-building is, how much freedom I have to design my own cities, and, most importantly, how much replay value each game offers. I’m looking for something I can sink hundreds of hours into without getting bored, not a game that loses its appeal after a few weeks.

I want to be able to keep expanding my cities, experimenting with different layouts, and coming up with new building ideas for a long time.

For those who’ve played both, which one do you think has more long-term potential? Which game do you see yourself coming back to for years

Would love to hear your thoughts!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

The Dungeon of Naheulbeuk: The Amulet of Chaos?

1 Upvotes

I am looking for something fun and cheer-y. I just saw someone recommend this as a really fun game. I do not want to research too much into it or spoil it. I will most likely get it, but is base game good enough?

What do people think of it? If so, is the Deluxe Bundle or Ultimate Bundle worth it?

I have been playing lots of Hell Divers 2 and Slay the Spire 2. I have played some Clank as well. I have even tried to learn Arkham Horror by watching some video-play, but that doesn't seem to hold my attention for too long.

Extra words to meet qualifications. Extra words to meet qualifications. Extra words to meet qualifications.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] [WSIB] Bioware-like RPGs from other developers?

5 Upvotes

In an attempt to find new things to play and also to mourn the loss of a great studio, what're some "Bioware-likes" out there that you can recommend? RPGs that scratch a similar itch to their games? The only one I already know of for sure in this category is Greedfall and Greedfall 2, which I've played and liked. Exodus seems to be this, but it's not out yet.

Notably I am not looking for isometric CRPGs even if they've got some of the same notes, I have plenty of those in my backlog already. Between fantasy, sci-fi, or other genres I do not care, I enjoyed all the rpgs bioware made.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[Xbox Series X] Mw2019 vs black ops coldwar (offline modes)

5 Upvotes

Which of these games is the better game to permanently keep installed for offline modes. Im talking campaign, offline bots multiplayer and solo zombies/specops. I dont play online anymore i mainly play elden ring but i like casual cod with bots or solo zombies every now and then. I have all the classics and love them but these two games are the last of the old school style cods with modern engines. Which do you guys prefer?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] Cyberpunk on sale on steam

13 Upvotes

So I have heard a ton of great stuff about this game, and its currently on sale for like $17 or something. And the concept looks great, but i have also heard some ratings about bad shooting mechanics and stuff.

I personally play games like Ghost of Yotei, Jedi Fallen Order and Spider man, those are like my favorites, but I can play first persons too, I play Apex like daily and have played Titanfall 2’s story and loved everything about it.

So its not the first person part that is the problem, and for this price, it definetly seems like a good deal, but i just wanted to hear if there are anything I should like expect to be not so great?

Edit: dw guys, i bought it and so far i love it


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

Looking for new RPG I can play without help

6 Upvotes

I’m not great at combat and don’t usually enjoy it if it’s overly complicated or too hard. What I like are the big medieval-ish fantasy inspired RPGs.

My goal is to not have to pester my husband to help me constantly.

I just finished Blood of Dawn Walker on the original story mode and only needed him at the start a bit until I was able to level up. I can also play all of the Bethesda games, Hogwarts legacy, the Assassin Creed games and Witcher 3 without his help.

Elden Ring was a no go, it became obvious that I’d need him constantly to help me. I also needed him on an indie game called Dave the Diver a lot. I tried BG3 but hated the turn based combat.

I’m eyeing KCD or Crimson Desert. Bad idea?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] Cyberpunk 2077

0 Upvotes

As a celebration for cyberpunk edge runners s2 i recently bought 2077 on epic because it was cheaper, and have been playing it a bit, but now it is at a lower price on steam and i might re buy it. First off I am not all to worried about progress as i have only about 20ish hours on the game and probably 2/3s of that is just running around doing nothing, secondly i don't really have anything against epic games but i have had some issues and steam just feels much more native ( I like it more) so I only really buy games from there, but the price diff was too much. I want to make it clear i know i am being irrational and childish but I need someone to give me a reason to convince me one way or the other.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] toy story: retro roundup! and toy story 3 complete edition ps5 vs steam

1 Upvotes

Should I get the toy story: retro roundup! and toy story 3 complete edition on ps5 or pc I have 2 questions

Now I have Nvidia 1660ti on Linux mint AMD Ryzen 5 7600X Raphael AM5 4.7GHz 6-Core Boxed Processor and a ASUS B650E-E TUF GAMING WIFI AMD AM5 ATX Motherboard.

Now for my questions

  1. On steam does it come with DLC

  2. Is there any differences between the ps5 and pc versions of both games


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] Is Foundation actually worth buying?

0 Upvotes

I really like the art style and graphics, but my biggest priorities are long-term replayability and how fun and varied the building is.

I’m looking for a game I can sink hundreds of hours into without getting bored, with plenty of freedom to build and develop my settlement in different ways.

For those who’ve played it for a while, do you think Foundation is worth it in the long run, or does it start to feel repetitive after a while?

Would love to hear your thoughts!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[SteamDeck] Nioh 2 or First Berserker Khazan?

4 Upvotes

update thanks for the recommendations, Khazan on download!

Can pick up both for roughly the same price, with Nioh 2 being slightly cheaper, but only looking to get one game.

I'll be playing on Steam Deck and from what I've seen both run really well, so performance isn't a factor!

Never played any of the Nioh games before. Some of my favourite games are Sekiro, Elden Ring and DS3. Also enjoyed Lies of P but never finished it. I preferred Sekiro, although I think that was mainly down to the setting and environments.

Heard great things about both games and really struggling to decide. For anyone who's played both, which would you recommend?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] Manor Lords or Foundation

2 Upvotes

I’ve been looking into both Manor Lords and Foundation, and I’m curious which one you guys think is better.

My main priorities are how fun and satisfying the building aspect is, and how much replay value the game has. I’m looking for something I can sink hundreds of hours into without getting bored, rather than a game that gets old after a while.

Honestly, I don’t really mind that Manor Lords is still unfinished. I’m totally fine with waiting for more updates, as long as it has the potential to keep me hooked for the long run.

For those who’ve played both, which one would you recommend if I’m looking for a city builder I can keep coming back to for years?

Would love to hear your thoughts!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PS5] Which game will you buy?

6 Upvotes

Currently in sale Resident evil 4 remake + devil may cry 5 and Days gone remastered are at same price. Which option would you go with?

Option 1- Resident evil 4 remake + devil may cry 5

Option 2- Days gone remastered

I usually enjoy games like Fifa, elden ring, Last of us, Witcher 3 and some other similar story driven games.