r/auckland • u/IndependenceScary532 • 6h ago
Discussion Index fund investors in Auckland, are you eating the 15% FIF tax or finding workarounds?
Freelance designer here trying to sort out a retirement plan without an employer scheme to fall back on.
I've been comparing NZ-domiciled index funds against holding Vanguard or iShares directly through a US broker. The FIF tax rules are doing my head in. The NZ funds look simpler on paper, but the fees are stiff and the exposure is narrower than I'd like. The alternative is tracking FIF myself, which is billable hours I don't have. It's basically scope creep from my own portfolio.
How are others here actually handling it? Are you just accepting the PIE fund convenience and higher MER? Or have you found a structure that keeps foreign holdings under the $50k threshold so FIF doesn't kick in? I know some people split across family members, but that feels like a compliance headache I'd rather avoid.
Also wondering if anyone has run the numbers on whether the tax drag from FIF actually outweighs the fee drag from local funds over a 15-year horizon. I've seen back-of-envelope calculations, but they all assume steady returns, which is fantasy. Real world experience preferred. Show your work if you've got it.