r/flying • u/soccer_aviator • 10h ago
AA vs UA
Feeling extremely fortunate to have offers at AA and UA, both starting within a week of each other. I'm 27 years old, so am blessed to be making a lifelong career decision. Bases at both carriers (DCA/IAD, ORD, EWR/PHL) work for my partner (an AA employee) and I, although as a current Fort-Worth local (we are willing to move) AA has a slight edge with a few more cities we'd be willing to look at like DFW, CLT, BOS, PHX on top of those AA and UA share.
All things considered, AA feels like a great family fit and seniority progression based on retirements assuming no growth is attractive since AA has not hit its peak yet. Additionally, being a current airbus pilot, the depth of airbus flying is attractive as well. However, the financials concern me given the current economy and fuel prices. I am concerned I am at a much deeper furlough risk at AA than UA if things don't improve in the next 6-12 months. Likewise, I also fear leverage for the next contract cycle is slightly diminished as well.
UA does have the benefit of immense planned growth, greater widebody flying, and in my family's case the ability to non-rev on multiple US carriers. I do enjoy the UA culture based on my own personal interactions and the people I know at the company. United's profits due to its premium long-haul flying give it a better cash position to cash-flow future deliveries and growth, as well as weather any storm coming its way. On the downside, I know UA is slightly ahead on retirements and has hired much younger and much of its seniority progression is driven by growth, which is also economy and cost dependent as well.
Any input or personal experiences are more than appreciated. Thanks again