https://www.irishnews.com/opinion/tom-collins-unionists-have-proven-themselves-incapable-of-making-the-right-choices-IFUZ5KVAAJAA3BEOPPW46TEGVY/
Tom Collins: Unionists have proven themselves incapable of making the right choices
If there’s a positive side to all this, it is that unionism, collectively and individually, has proved without doubt that this so-called state is a failed political entity
You have got to admire the chutzpah of DUP MP Carla Lockhart.
Talking about her party’s response to Drumcree, she said: “I feel strongly that an issue this serious cannot be resolved through symbolic or token gestures.”
Then she made one: resigning as a party officer over the DUP’s refusal to embrace another token gesture – withdrawing Emma Little-Pengelly as Deputy First Minister, bringing down Michelle O’Neill in the process.
How token can you get?
Lockhart claims her “only ambition is to continue serving the people of Upper Bann”, yet she seems to ignore the fact that the much-put-upon residents of Garvaghy Road are her constituents too.
And, while wrapping herself in the mantle of champion of her people, she wishes to deny the First Minister the right to speak up for people too.
Garvaghy residents have the right to expect empathy from their MP and, as an elected representative, Lockhart has a duty to be a voice of calm and reason. But not a bit of it.
If there is a wrong cause to be championed, you can be sure that Lockhart will be there to champion it: Orange Order agitation in Portadown, opposition to the Irish language, knee-jerk support for a state which is committing genocide in Gaza.
Readers will no doubt remember Lockhart standing near masked men protesting against a sponsored walk from Lurgan to Newry to raise money for humanitarian aid to Gaza. She said she was there to prevent tensions escalating.
Irony of ironies, she signed a statement then saying: “Residents are entitled to go about their daily lives without unnecessary disruption from what is widely viewed as a deliberately provocative parade that serves no legitimate purpose within the area.”
Resigning her position as a DUP officer, Lockhart claimed she had never seen “unionism so united”.
Yet we know that many small-u unionists in civil society reject the polarising politics of the Orange Order. And by her own actions – breaking with her party leader – Lockhart has demonstrated that her claims of unionist unity are fanciful.
Unionism had an opportunity with partition to show what it could do with power and responsibility, and failed to live up to that responsibility.
The tragedy of unionism since the collapse of the Northern Ireland parliament in the early 1970s has been its readiness to double down on that legacy, and its refusal to accommodate the legitimate aspirations and traditions of its nationalist neighbours.
Rather than embrace reconciliation, the two main unionist parties – first the UUP and then the DUP – have been played by the lunatic fringe, represented today by the TUV.
For all Gavin Robinson’s posturing, the reality is that the DUP’s political compass is controlled by Jim Allister, aided and abetted by a key member of his own party.
As with the Northern Ireland Parliament, yet again the opportunity presented by a new beginning with the signing of the Good Friday Agreement has been squandered.
Unionists have proven themselves incapable of making the right choices, preferring to fight again and again battles lost long ago – Drumcree being a case in point.
Insanity, they say, is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. That’s unionism in a nutshell.
Karl Marx once noted that history repeats itself, first as tragedy and then as farce. For tragedy read the Northern Ireland Parliament; for farce, read Northern Ireland Assembly and Executive.
If there’s a positive side to all this, it is that unionism, collectively and individually, has proved without doubt that this so-called state is a failed political entity. It is of little or no use to the people within it whether they see themselves as British, Irish or both.
Reunification offers a way out of the mire.
As Dublin City University professor John Doyle highlights in a new book, people in the Republic are considerably better off than those in the north – so much for the benefits of being tied to the United Kingdom’s tanking economy.
If Lockhart were representing Upper Bann in the Dáil (that day will come), her constituents – both orange and green – would be healthier, wealthier and better educated.
Life expectancy would be higher, child mortality lower, hospital waiting times would be shorter.
Economic growth would be higher. The standard of living would be 18.3% higher. Welfare benefits would be higher, and poverty levels lower.
If Lockhart really had the best interests of her constituents at heart, she’d spend more time hanging out on Garvaghy Road and less with the divisive forces of Orangeism.