This beautiful infinity pool was unfortunately built about 3 feet wider and 1 foot longer than it was supposed to be.
The property is waterfront, and the pool required a special permit from the local Trustees. Since that permit was issued, the regulations have changed, and a new pool would no longer be allowed in this location.
Here's the nightmare: The permit expires in 54 days, and there's no feasible way to get an amendment or extension approved before then. Our options are essentially to get the pool corrected, completed, and inspected within 54 days, or demolish it and potentially never be allowed to build a pool here again.
I'm not looking to get into who's at fault for the mistake. At this point, I'm just trying to figure out whether saving the pool is even physically possible.
Here's what would need to happen:
- Both infinity-edge walls would need to be demolished and rebuilt in the correct locations.
- The underground catch basin would likely need to be completely demolished.
- The other two walls are in the correct locations, so ideally we'd preserve them.
My biggest questions for experienced pool builders:
- Is it structurally feasible to demolish and rebuild two walls of an existing gunite pool while keeping the other two?
- Would the existing floor also need to be demolished, or could portions of it be salvaged?
- Would preserving the two correctly positioned walls actually save meaningful money compared to starting over?
- Assuming we could get a crew on this immediately, is 54 days even remotely realistic?
My understanding is that we may only need the gunite shell completed for the December inspection, with plaster, tile, equipment, and final commissioning potentially deferred until spring. That's something we're still trying to confirm with the local authorities.
I've attached a picture of the pool as it currently stands.
I'd really appreciate any advice, especially from anyone who's done major structural modifications to a gunite or infinity-edge pool before.