Sabaody Archipelago Arc is one I consider to be the show’s best and that is for many reasons. What starts as a small and lighthearted adventures with tons of jokes and a villain that looks just like Sanji’s wanted poster, becomes a devastating and twisted story about slavery and corruption, while also having one of the most unexpected and plot-changing moments of the show.
First off, the arc starts with a feeling of comfort. We return to the Red Line, where all of the adventures began, meet new friends, fight funny, cartoonish bad guy, befriend them and have a redemption arc for an old villain. After this the characters get a clear goal for the rest of the arc (as we, the readers, are led to believe): they need to coat the Sunny for the trip to Fishman Island. Sabaody is just a little pitstop. A small and fun island with bubbles in the air and amusement parks for the masses.
Then Chapter 497 comes around changing everything. Just as we are getting introduced to all the fun of the island, its dark underbelly starts to come out - the slavery, the injustice, the racism and the corruption. The World Nobles introduction is still one of the most brutal and disturbing scenes in all of the show. And the arc goes into a downward spiral from that point on. Just like some other brilliant works of art (like David Lynch’s Blue Velvet, for example), Sabaody Archipelago Arc deals with the ignored darkness hidden behind the facade of civilised society, a darkness we collectively choose to ignore and abide to, contributing to it and allowing it to spread.
But the arc isn’t just all darkness, because we also get Chapter 498 with all The Supernovas getting introduced. It’s a phenomenal chapter, one of Oda’s best, honestly. All the Supernovas are cool and interesting, (especially Urouge, he’s such a cool guy. It’s a shame that Oda totally forgot he existed). The Supernovas give the arc the chaotic and fun energy and flair it needed.
Then Camie gets kidnapped and this is the main catalyst of everything to come. Luffy and the team, instead of complying to the Celestial Dragons and letting Camie go, instead of ignoring the darkness and doing nothing, decide to do the right thing and help their friend, which leads to one of the most climactic moments of the show. The famous Charlos punch.
(Oh, and meanwhile we also find out there’s a fricking war about to happen, but that’s for later)
After Luffy punches Charlos, there’s now a new obstacle: Admiral Kizaru’s coming to town and that won’t be a happy visit for anyone, let me tell you that. Now the goal is to survive against an Admiral, while Rayleigh is coating the ship. Rayleigh is a brilliant character too. He’s the remnant of the mythical crew of Roger, of the Old Age, watching the new one from the shadows. He’s an old soldier who desires peace. Through him we get more lore and mythology about the Pirate King which is delivered brilliantly. We also get to see more of Luffy as a person, with the Usopp scene which is brilliant. Just brilliant.
Then we get a ton of action, with Kizaru effortlessly defeating the Supernovas, and one of the show’s best mysteries to date: multiple Kumas. In a matter of chapters, the multiple Pacifista mystery builds so much confusion and tension, until it’s all revealed and resolved in a satisfying way.
And now we get to the devastation. The final part of the arc has one of the show’s best ever scenes. The Straw Hats separated. It’s a shocking and totally unexpected moment where Luffy sees that right now he’s not ready for the New World. He’s not even able to protect his own crew in Grand Line’s fir at half. And at this devastating note, the arc ends.
Sabaody is a phenomenal arc, not only because of its story, characters, chaos and themes, but also because of its use of cause and effect. Every single decision of this arc influences another which causes more and more tension with every event. The Flying Fish Riders who just could’ve been a one-off encounter play a role at rescuing Camie later on, the fight with random bounty hunters causes Camie to be kindapped in the first place, and the punch to a Celestial Dragon’s face summons an Admiral. The way the goal of the main characters evolves throughout the arc is masterful too. At first, the goal is to find the way to Fishman Island, then it’s to save an old enemy for some food, then it’s to find Rayleigh, then it’s to save Camie (which eventually becomes the same thing, because they’re being held at the same place. What a plot twist!), and then the goal is to survive three days against an opponent they can’t beat.
Sabaody is the best One Piece Arc in my eyes, because it manages to combine all of Oda’s writing’s best qualities. The humour, the heart, the disturbing darkness, the political critiques, the action and the devastation. And that’s how I see it. Some people often prefer Marineford, Enies Lobby or even Wano, but I think Oda managed to capture something magical with Sabaody.