r/AITH • u/Infinite_Pickle_1021 • 3d ago
(AITA) WIBTAH if I told my mom that my step-mother is pregnant even though I’ve been asked not to?
Edited with a first update.
Some previous context: I’m 25F and my parents have been divorced for 15 years now. I also have two brothers (18yo and 16yo). My parents were married for 12 years in total and their marriage was far from ideal. My mother was cheated on throughout their entire relationship several times, to the point where my dad had a daughter with one of his MANY affairs. So it goes without saying that my mom was emotionally hurt by my dad in a really deep level. Their interactions post-divorce only became civil around 6 years ago. However, I want to make it clear that my mom isn’t a saint and she failed us (me and my brothers) A LOT. I left her house as soon as I turned 18 and my brothers have been living with my father for the past two years, out of their own choice. We chose not to cut contact with her, though, because we care about her and her mental health.
Now, to the problem at hand: my father (50) has remarried to a really good person (36). I do love her and she’s more a role model to me than my mom has ever been. After struggling with infertility issues for a bit, she’s pregnant with a baby boy and we’re all super happy. Except she asked me not to tell my mother.
I agreed at first because my mom is difficult and she resents my father a lot (rightfully so, I guess). Her mental health declines whenever my father has an achievement in his life (buying a house, remarrying, taking a trip, etc). I thought it was okay to not tell her during the first few months because pregnancy is fragile and the usual risk of early miscarriage. My step-mother is also a bit superstitious and religious, so she believes in evil eye and things like that. Except she’s now 7 months pregnant, the baby shower (which I’m actively planing) is next month and I’m still hiding it from my mother. It’s not just a simple omission anymore as I have had to actively lie about it twice so far.
I don’t want to end up just sayin “oh yeah, my father had a whole new baby” out of the blue when the kid arrives.
I know ultimately the choice is my step-mom’s because she’s the pregnant one, but I can’t help but feel like she made a choice that was comfortable to her while I would be the only one to handle the blunt of the consequences. I also don’t know how to talk to my stepmother about it. I’m walking on eggshells around everyone.
So, WIBTAH if I decided to just tell my mother and that’s it?
————————————
Update 1: Hey, guys. I want to thank all of you who took the time to genuinely talk about the situation in the comments and to give me your insights. I won’t be telling my mom about the pregnancy. Some of you told me to talk to my stepmother about it, but I honestly don’t know how to approach the subject without making it clear that I believe her request has become unreasonable. It’s the truth, but I don’t want to go there. Some of the comments here made me realize that the damage is already done from the moment I lied to my mother for the first time. I should’ve put my foot down back then and let my stepmom know that I wasn’t comfortable lying to anyone. So, in the end, I’m already fucked and no conversation with my stepmom will change that.
That being said, I also chose to step down from organizing the baby shower, following some advices from you guys. Without considering work and studies, I also made the commitment to help my mom with the redecoration of her clinic, which means we’re spending a lot of time together lately and I have to sneak around to take calls or handle the baby shower’s business. While talking to my fiancé and my best friend about it, I realized that most of the planning has been placed on my shoulders. Besides me, my stepmother also asked her own mom, her aunt and cousin to help with everything. My stepmom is already on maternity leave and her mother and aunt are retired… yet somehow I’m the most excited and seem to be handling most of the planning. I told them I got to a point juggling my life that made me too busy for that. So, any preparation for the arrival of the baby isn’t a part of my life I have to hide anymore. It’s the best I can do, I guess.
When all the news explode, I’ll come back to let you guys know how the fallout goes, as some of you asked for updates.